First Time Stories
11,520 stories • Page 24 of 120

I Thought We Were More Chapter
I Thought We Were More Chapter 13
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
21,560

I Love Dick
I Love Dick
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
22,557

I Thought We Were More Chapter
I Thought We Were More Chapter 15
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
15,046

I Lost My V Card To My Coach P
I Lost My V Card To My Coach Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
4,839

I Lost It
I Lost It
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
2,041

Influencing Sadaf
Influencing Sadaf
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
21,126

I Thought We Were More Chapter
I Thought We Were More Chapter 06
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
1,907

I Want To Be A Model
I Want To Be A Model
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
22,623

Innocence Lost 30
Innocence Lost 30
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
12,566

It Barely Fit
It Barely Fit
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
4,358

Immobilized
Immobilized
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
12,452

I Promised Mama
I Promised Mama
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
23,941

I Randomly Got Fucked By A Str
I Randomly Got Fucked By A Stranger
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
7,910

I Think Were Alone Now
I Think Were Alone Now
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
22,310

It S Your First Fuck Carson Ta
It S Your First Fuck Carson Tan
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
15,708

Innocent Schoolgirl
Innocent Schoolgirl
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
7,475

Interview With A Happy Ending
Interview With A Happy Ending
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
12,770

If Only 1122
If Only 1122
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
3,731

Indian Paradise
Indian Paradise
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
17,913

It Can Be So Easy Chapter 01
It Can Be So Easy Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
10,648

Im The Luckiest Man Alive
Im The Luckiest Man Alive
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
6,483

In Spring We Loved
In Spring We Loved
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
24,585

I Was Not Alone During My Gap
I Was Not Alone During My Gap Year
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
9,675

In Step Chapter 02
In Step Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
18,645

Indecency 1
Indecency 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
17,220

Intimacy With Songbird
Intimacy With Songbird
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
8,287

Innocence Lost During The War
Innocence Lost During The War
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
1,401

Intrusive Seduction
Intrusive Seduction
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
5,708

It Started On New Years Eve Ch
It Started On New Years Eve Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
9,964

I Begged For His Cock
I Begged For His Cock
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
15,545

Ice Storm Becoming Beta
Ice Storm Becoming Beta
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
13,917

I Wanna Be Bad
I Wanna Be Bad
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
24,883

Its All Academic After All
Its All Academic After All
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
13,674

In Trouble With The Principal
In Trouble With The Principal
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
20,367

I Never Knew Her Name 1
I Never Knew Her Name 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
20,459

I Lost My Virginity To Dryad
I Lost My Virginity To Dryad
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,674

It Was The Night Before Christ
It Was The Night Before Christmas
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
12,048

Indian Mom Fucked By Milkman 0
Indian Mom Fucked By Milkman 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
17,724

Ice Cream Girl
Ice Cream Girl
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
11,019

Its Only A Game 1
Its Only A Game 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
12,311

Ikky Nikki
Ikky Nikki
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
9,824

Innocent Girl 1
Innocent Girl 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
9,672

Impressively Average Chapter 0
Impressively Average Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
13,991

Ill Take Care Of You 1
Ill Take Care Of You 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
17,164

I May Be Small
I May Be Small
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
23,548

I Did It For The G String
I Did It For The G String
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
5,971

I Guess Im Bisexual Now
I Guess Im Bisexual Now
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
12,922

Its Too Darn Hot Day 64
Its Too Darn Hot Day 64
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
16,135

I Am Not Sure How This Started
I Am Not Sure How This Started
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
4,107

It Was A Dark And Windy Night
It Was A Dark And Windy Night
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
21,140

If I Knew Then Chapter 01
If I Knew Then Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
5,621

Im Not Gay Part 01
Im Not Gay Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
9,214

I Am A Cocksucker A Bi Cocksuc
I Am A Cocksucker A Bi Cocksucker Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
18,326

Its Never Too Late 8
Its Never Too Late 8
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
21,330

In The Wild West Of Ireland
In The Wild West Of Ireland
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
4,876

Im Not A Naughty Girl I Promis
Im Not A Naughty Girl I Promise
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
22,474

I Seduced A Str8 Teen Boy
I Seduced A Str8 Teen Boy
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
1,470

I Needed A Blowjob
I Needed A Blowjob
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
9,381

I Want To Know You
I Want To Know You
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
17,078

Im Just A Gigolo Chapter 4
Im Just A Gigolo Chapter 4
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
12,993

Its Game Day
Its Game Day
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
6,373

I Had No Idea
I Had No Idea
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
12,395

Innocence Has Its Secrets
Innocence Has Its Secrets
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
7,846

I Can Dream
I Can Dream
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
8,315

Its Hard To Find Good Help
Its Hard To Find Good Help
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
9,057

I Still Wonder
I Still Wonder
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
24,400

It Was More Than Just Sex
It Was More Than Just Sex
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
15,689

Its Got To Be Perfect
Its Got To Be Perfect
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
11,666

Innocent Molly 1
Innocent Molly 1
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
15,100

I Dream Of Kathy My Teacher Ch
I Dream Of Kathy My Teacher Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
24,452

I Hate Christmas
I Hate Christmas
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
14,693

Im Done 5
Im Done 5
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
20,255

In The Stacks 3
In The Stacks 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
2,426

Innocence Lost Chapter 01 4
Innocence Lost Chapter 01 4
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
9,365

I Discovered I Like To Suck
I Discovered I Like To Suck
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
10,436

I Was A Teenage Sex God Chapte
I Was A Teenage Sex God Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
15,964

Indian Fever
Indian Fever
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
18,806

I Accidentally Sucked Dick Par
I Accidentally Sucked Dick Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
13,582

Innocent Andrea Chapter 01
Innocent Andrea Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
762

Intent Sealed
Intent Sealed
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
15,324

Innocent And New
Innocent And New
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
20,716

Interstellar Impregnation Part
Interstellar Impregnation Part 07
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
1,759

Indiscretion Of A Married Wome
Indiscretion Of A Married Women
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
12,876

Innocence Educated
Innocence Educated
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
16,328

I Begged For His Cock Part 02
I Begged For His Cock Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
13,255

I Thought We Were More Chapter
I Thought We Were More Chapter 12
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
23,368

I Am Superman Chapter 01
I Am Superman Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
13,572

Its Too Darn Hot Day 01 02
Its Too Darn Hot Day 01 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
6,328

Its Just Amazing
Its Just Amazing
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
4,040

Ishmaels Girl A Virgin In Ruin
Ishmaels Girl A Virgin In Ruins
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
4,953

Isabel The Beauty Next Door Pa
Isabel The Beauty Next Door Part 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
15,394

I Thought We Were More Chapter
I Thought We Were More Chapter 10
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
7,278

Introvert And Virgin
Introvert And Virgin
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
2,201

In The Park 22
In The Park 22
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
19,697

Indescribable Need
Indescribable Need
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
18,128

If Then
If Then
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
21,950