First Time Stories
11,520 stories • Page 23 of 120
I Own This Woman
I Own This Woman
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
24,862
Indian Volleyballers
Indian Volleyballers
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
9,025
I Was My Sisters Life Model
I Was My Sisters Life Model
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
22,885
I Lose My Virginity For Christ
I Lose My Virginity For Christmas
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
3,133
Igniting Harriet
Igniting Harriet
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
4,077
Inseparable Part 04
Inseparable Part 04
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
22,419
Its Better With Love
Its Better With Love
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
5,133
It Is Snowing
It Is Snowing
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
2,285
I Wont Forgive You
I Wont Forgive You
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
21,910
I Need To Suck A Mans Cock
I Need To Suck A Mans Cock
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
16,881
I Became An Art Model
I Became An Art Model
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
5,829
I See Brucey Knickerbockers Di
I See Brucey Knickerbockers Dick
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
10,956
I Love Chemistry Class
I Love Chemistry Class
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
4,417
Intern Meant Tramp
Intern Meant Tramp
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
15,335
In The Beginning Was The Word
In The Beginning Was The Word
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
15,346
Iya Chapter 03 Iya Does Troy
Iya Chapter 03 Iya Does Troy
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
9,752
Interns First Business Trip
Interns First Business Trip
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
15,696
I Dont Want To Be A Virgin 1
I Dont Want To Be A Virgin 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
4,065
I Swallowed
I Swallowed
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
10,209
It Started With A Snog Chapter
It Started With A Snog Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
23,641
I Thought We Were More Chapter
I Thought We Were More Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
24,955
I Didnt Mean To Have Sex With
I Didnt Mean To Have Sex With Him
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
5,853
It All Started With A Dream Ch
It All Started With A Dream Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
7,586
Initiation At Pretty Marsh
Initiation At Pretty Marsh
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
4,398
Im Glad They Tricked Me
Im Glad They Tricked Me
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
2,468
In The Tutelage Of Ms Kline
In The Tutelage Of Ms Kline
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
12,747
I Saw Malati And Had Saroj
I Saw Malati And Had Saroj
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
17,358
I Am The Night
I Am The Night
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
4,759
In Nothing But My Shoes
In Nothing But My Shoes
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
13,352
I Cant Believe I Am Doing This
I Cant Believe I Am Doing This
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
5,357
If Not Tracy Mother Will Do
If Not Tracy Mother Will Do
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
8,463
I Am Superman Chapter 02
I Am Superman Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
17,798
Its A Big Black Cock New Years
Its A Big Black Cock New Years
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
19,867
I Am A Cum Slut
I Am A Cum Slut
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
2,432
I Lost My V Card To My Coach P
I Lost My V Card To My Coach Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
18,488
If Alex And I Meet In Person
If Alex And I Meet In Person
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
18,993
Its Just A Hand Job
Its Just A Hand Job
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
16,214
Is That Really You
Is That Really You
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
15,937
I Like The Way You Eat
I Like The Way You Eat
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
21,731
Initiation 32
Initiation 32
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
8,098
If You Dream It She Will Cum
If You Dream It She Will Cum
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
8,308
Introducing Susan
Introducing Susan
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
24,252
Ill Fix That
Ill Fix That
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
23,083
Introduction At Bitter End
Introduction At Bitter End
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
17,044
I Finally Lost My Virginity
I Finally Lost My Virginity
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
2,299
I Remember 16
I Remember 16
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
6,019
Innocent Invitation
Innocent Invitation
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
8,378
I Want Her To Be My First
I Want Her To Be My First
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
23,003
It S Icky
It S Icky
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
6,062
I Is For Independence Day
I Is For Independence Day
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
12,595
Identical Obsession Next Door
Identical Obsession Next Door Part 01 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
9,050
Invisible 15
Invisible 15
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
3,156
It Started On New Years Eve
It Started On New Years Eve
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
3,650
Idris Fills Me Up
Idris Fills Me Up
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
16,218
Innocence Lost 8
Innocence Lost 8
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
19,900
Its Good To Be Me Part 01
Its Good To Be Me Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
24,457
I Really Shouldnt
I Really Shouldnt
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
18,884
I Came To Visit You
I Came To Visit You
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
7,264
It Was Her Moms Idea
It Was Her Moms Idea
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
9,667
Innocent 3
Innocent 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
23,276
Intimate Virgin Creampie
Intimate Virgin Creampie
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
15,276
Illegal Immigrants
Illegal Immigrants
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
24,045
I Dream Of Kathy My Teacher
I Dream Of Kathy My Teacher
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
20,070
I Lost My V Card To My Coach P
I Lost My V Card To My Coach Part 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
16,792
Im An Adult Now Ocean City
Im An Adult Now Ocean City
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
5,987
In Androon
In Androon
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
7,318
Insanity Plea
Insanity Plea
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
14,641
Its For Science 1
Its For Science 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
9,527
Inexperienced And Unprepared
Inexperienced And Unprepared
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
17,654
It Started With A Snog
It Started With A Snog
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
10,594
I Want To Get Laid
I Want To Get Laid
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
16,982
Imperfections 2
Imperfections 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
6,366
It Had To Happen 3
It Had To Happen 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
2,484
I Thought We Were More Chapter
I Thought We Were More Chapter 09
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
17,829
I Took Her Advice Chapter 01 1
I Took Her Advice Chapter 01 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
3,548
In Praise Of Older Women 3
In Praise Of Older Women 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
1,495
I Secretly Fuck My Best Friend
I Secretly Fuck My Best Friend
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
13,455
Intrusive Neighbour Chapter 01
Intrusive Neighbour Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
1,328
Indian Summer Chapter 2
Indian Summer Chapter 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
16,480
I Can See You Too
I Can See You Too
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
20,147
Interlude 20
Interlude 20
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
14,153
Indian Delite
Indian Delite
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
11,707
I Receive The Ultimate Gift
I Receive The Ultimate Gift
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
13,350
I Just Sucked My First Dick At
I Just Sucked My First Dick At 29
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
21,074
I Smoked Way Too Much
I Smoked Way Too Much
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
10,574
Intimidation By The Big Blue R
Intimidation By The Big Blue Rabbit
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
1,336
In Deep 1
In Deep 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
20,727
In Loving Memory Part 09
In Loving Memory Part 09
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
18,132
In The Light Of Fire
In The Light Of Fire
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
1,735
I Call On Janet And Ashley
I Call On Janet And Ashley
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
17,063
Introduction To A New Daddy
Introduction To A New Daddy
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
14,154
Incel Creampie Cheating Teen
Incel Creampie Cheating Teen
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
12,685
Innocence Has Its Secrets Chap
Innocence Has Its Secrets Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
17,648
I Sucked A Married Mans Cock
I Sucked A Married Mans Cock
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
17,967
It Was Destiny Part 01
It Was Destiny Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
8,220
Ive Never Done Anything Like T
Ive Never Done Anything Like This
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
24,486