Top Rated First Time Stories
Top 100 highest rated stories in this category
Emmys Adventures Part 02
Emmys Adventures Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,075
Ethan And Carrie Chapter 08
Ethan And Carrie Chapter 08
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
2,883
Early Education
Early Education
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
5,590
Easy Like Saturday Morning
Easy Like Saturday Morning
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,384
Explorations Chapter 08
Explorations Chapter 08
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
1,690
Erica My College Virgin
Erica My College Virgin
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
4,612
Emily Chapter 01 7
Emily Chapter 01 7
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
1,176
Educating Mel
Educating Mel
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
8,484
You Are Definitely Going To He
You Are Definitely Going To Hell
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
14,596
Young Claudia And The Prophet
Young Claudia And The Prophet
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,203
Young Innkeeper
Young Innkeeper
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
24,191
Yearning With Anticipation
Yearning With Anticipation
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
24,367
Young And Hard Help Chapter 02
Young And Hard Help Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
9,683
Father Damian
Father Damian
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
626
Fun Night In San Francisco
Fun Night In San Francisco
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,768
Fall 1970 Chapter 02
Fall 1970 Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
6,914
Finding Home 6
Finding Home 6
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
5,346
First Swinger Experience
First Swinger Experience
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
3,082
First Experience 5
First Experience 5
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,853
First Bi Guy Friend
First Bi Guy Friend
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
2,883
From Boy To Man Part 7 Double
From Boy To Man Part 7 Double Act
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
16,990
First Time Story
First Time Story
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
13,981
Free Ride 1
Free Ride 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
14,806
For Lane Chapter 02
For Lane Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
12,285
First Massage At A Nude Beach
First Massage At A Nude Beach Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
16,248
French Kissing For Girls And B
French Kissing For Girls And Boys
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
24,858
First Loving
First Loving
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
18,286
Fun With The Au Pair
Fun With The Au Pair
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
16,970
First Day On The Job 3
First Day On The Job 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
5,648
First Encounter With Anna Part
First Encounter With Anna Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
19,861
First Times 8
First Times 8
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,973
First Time With A Man 5
First Time With A Man 5
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
15,481
First Experience Sister In Law
First Experience Sister In Law
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,157
First Time 81
First Time 81
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,801
Friends Finally Connect
Friends Finally Connect
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
15,540
First Love 17
First Love 17
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
6,312
From Virgin To Stud My Evoluti
From Virgin To Stud My Evolution
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
20,432
Finding Out Who I Am
Finding Out Who I Am
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
17,829
For You With You
For You With You
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
16,903
First Time At Gloryhole
First Time At Gloryhole
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,294
From Tyro To Lothario Part 02
From Tyro To Lothario Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
651
Finding True Love At A Party 1
Finding True Love At A Party 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
20,159
For The Very First Time Chapte
For The Very First Time Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,939
Firsts Chelseas Story
Firsts Chelseas Story
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
16,079
First Time Bi Curious
First Time Bi Curious
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,018
Fake Sex
Fake Sex
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
9,296
First Time 173
First Time 173
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
24,274
Falling For Jenny
Falling For Jenny
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,051
First Time 2026
First Time 2026
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,582
First Time And Heat Rhymes Par
First Time And Heat Rhymes Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
22,969
First Time Excitement
First Time Excitement
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
12,548
4 Seasons Of A Life Chapter 04
4 Seasons Of A Life Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
8,465
College Days Chapter 01 5
College Days Chapter 01 5
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
20,617
Crickets Calamari Catharsis
Crickets Calamari Catharsis
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
13,757
Cherry Chaser
Cherry Chaser
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
12,294
Car Buff Chapter 03
Car Buff Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
9,722
Cinnamon Rolled
Cinnamon Rolled
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
4,650
Cute Girls Next Door
Cute Girls Next Door
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
18,217
Clovers Cocksucking Lessons
Clovers Cocksucking Lessons
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,530
Cross Country Coach
Cross Country Coach
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
4,954
Cold Beer Boiled Shrimp New Lo
Cold Beer Boiled Shrimp New Love
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,295
Caught Seduced And Caught Agai
Caught Seduced And Caught Again
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
17,222
Consolation Prize
Consolation Prize
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
16,890
Cult Of The Eternally Young
Cult Of The Eternally Young
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
13,253
Checkmate 3
Checkmate 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
21,576
Cross Dresser At Convention Pa
Cross Dresser At Convention Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
21,869
Camping Fun 03 Year Of The Sis
Camping Fun 03 Year Of The Sister
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
17,859
Caught Skinny Dipping
Caught Skinny Dipping
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
14,078
Coachs Cutie Chapter 04
Coachs Cutie Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,995
Comic Con
Comic Con
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
3,519
Clover Watches Take Miss Akins
Clover Watches Take Miss Akins Ass
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
21,886
Christopher And Valerie Part 0
Christopher And Valerie Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
1,502
Cum Again 1
Cum Again 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
3,585
Courtin Aint Easy
Courtin Aint Easy
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
5,461
Cute Model
Cute Model
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
12,348
Quiet Girls Are Always Easier
Quiet Girls Are Always Easier
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
24,514
Diary Of A New Relationship
Diary Of A New Relationship
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
1,093
Davy Knew A Tainted Dove
Davy Knew A Tainted Dove
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
8,608
Decision Night
Decision Night
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
5,172
Dont Stand So Close To Me Chap
Dont Stand So Close To Me Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
3,604
Do You Think You Can Handle Th
Do You Think You Can Handle This
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,114
Daughter Of The Revolution Cha
Daughter Of The Revolution Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
12,077
Dormmates Support
Dormmates Support
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,559
Dressing Room Tryst 1
Dressing Room Tryst 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
13,822
Discovering Amy Part 03
Discovering Amy Part 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,506
Double Fantasy 4
Double Fantasy 4
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
20,341
Dana A First
Dana A First
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
20,797
Dinner And A Limousine
Dinner And A Limousine
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,511
Dreaming About Candy
Dreaming About Candy
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
20,543
Dear Diary My First Swing Part
Dear Diary My First Swing Party
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,829
Desert Moon
Desert Moon
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
10,310
Introduction To Sex Chapter 01
Introduction To Sex Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
22,349
It Started With A Unicorn
It Started With A Unicorn
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
1,214
International Relations Chapte
International Relations Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
23,148
Isnt Technology Great
Isnt Technology Great
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
13,372
I Am The Night
I Am The Night
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
4,759
I Am A Cum Slut
I Am A Cum Slut
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
2,432
Illegal Immigrants
Illegal Immigrants
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
24,045
In The Light Of Fire
In The Light Of Fire
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
1,735
Introduction To A New Daddy
Introduction To A New Daddy
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
14,154