First Time Stories

11,520 stories • Page 41 of 120

Stood Up 12
Stood Up 12

Stood Up 12

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 24,873
Shaving Rupert
Shaving Rupert

Shaving Rupert

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 7,696
Surfer Girl 2
Surfer Girl 2

Surfer Girl 2

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 2,557
Shy Lady Poses For Nude Photos Part 03
Shy Lady Poses For Nude Photos

Shy Lady Poses For Nude Photos Part 03

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 12,272
Shower At The Cabin Chapter 01
Shower At The Cabin Chapter 01

Shower At The Cabin Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 14,004
Shy Lady Poses For Nude Photos Part 02
Shy Lady Poses For Nude Photos

Shy Lady Poses For Nude Photos Part 02

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 13,441
Summer Love 4
Summer Love 4

Summer Love 4

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 13,382
She Loved Paris
She Loved Paris

She Loved Paris

by Anonymous
★ 4.3 10,779
Sports Massage 2
Sports Massage 2

Sports Massage 2

by Anonymous
★ 3.8 24,177
Seducing A Mature Virgin
Seducing A Mature Virgin

Seducing A Mature Virgin

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 2,505
Seduced 8
Seduced 8

Seduced 8

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 6,728
Snow Melts Chapter 01
Snow Melts Chapter 01

Snow Melts Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 1,880
Sams Love Part 05
Sams Love Part 05

Sams Love Part 05

by Anonymous
★ 4.3 18,262
Sarah S First Time At 19
Sarah S First Time At 19

Sarah S First Time At 19

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 2,321
Silly Little Whore
Silly Little Whore

Silly Little Whore

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 14,281
Starlet Gone Wild Chapter 01
Starlet Gone Wild Chapter 01

Starlet Gone Wild Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 4,402
Shy 2
Shy 2

Shy 2

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 24,936
Styxxx Studios
Styxxx Studios

Styxxx Studios

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 22,039
Seducing The School Janitor
Seducing The School Janitor

Seducing The School Janitor

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 3,302
Sir And His Sarah Chapter 01 First Encounter
Sir And His Sarah Chapter 01 F

Sir And His Sarah Chapter 01 First Encounter

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 7,166
Suzies Twenty Five Acts
Suzies Twenty Five Acts

Suzies Twenty Five Acts

by Anonymous
★ 4.3 11,086
Slaving Away Chapter 3
Slaving Away Chapter 3

Slaving Away Chapter 3

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 3,402
Summer At The River
Summer At The River

Summer At The River

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 21,479
Strangers On A Train 38
Strangers On A Train 38

Strangers On A Train 38

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 3,938
Selected For Sport Chapter 04
Selected For Sport Chapter 04

Selected For Sport Chapter 04

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 23,013
Sa E01v2 A Medieval Romance
Sa E01v2 A Medieval Romance

Sa E01v2 A Medieval Romance

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 14,658
Sallys First Three Way
Sallys First Three Way

Sallys First Three Way

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 5,867
Summer School 11
Summer School 11

Summer School 11

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 22,285
Swing Time Chapter 02
Swing Time Chapter 02

Swing Time Chapter 02

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 23,590
Sun And Moon 2
Sun And Moon 2

Sun And Moon 2

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 2,775
Summer With Michelle
Summer With Michelle

Summer With Michelle

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 20,088
Sophias Choice Part 08
Sophias Choice Part 08

Sophias Choice Part 08

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 2,496
Susie Chapter 15
Susie Chapter 15

Susie Chapter 15

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 595
So What Next
So What Next

So What Next

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 13,103
Schwanzchen Klein Blieb Allein
Schwanzchen Klein Blieb Allein

Schwanzchen Klein Blieb Allein

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 19,484
Straying For The First Time
Straying For The First Time

Straying For The First Time

by Anonymous
★ 4.3 11,696
Symposium Day Chapter 01
Symposium Day Chapter 01

Symposium Day Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 19,693
Sex Club For Nerds And Geeks
Sex Club For Nerds And Geeks

Sex Club For Nerds And Geeks

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 8,485
Sorry Max
Sorry Max

Sorry Max

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 14,289
Snow Storm And The Babysitter
Snow Storm And The Babysitter

Snow Storm And The Babysitter

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 17,689
Studs Chapter 01
Studs Chapter 01

Studs Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 3.8 13,927
Sex Ed With Jake
Sex Ed With Jake

Sex Ed With Jake

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 1,060
Schools Out Chapter 02 1
Schools Out Chapter 02 1

Schools Out Chapter 02 1

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 4,488
Schoolies Week 1
Schoolies Week 1

Schoolies Week 1

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 15,287
Saved 4
Saved 4

Saved 4

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 9,315
Solitary Passion
Solitary Passion

Solitary Passion

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 13,169
Sugarbee
Sugarbee

Sugarbee

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 8,995
Sosoni Chapter 01
Sosoni Chapter 01

Sosoni Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 24,987
Str8 Sex To Be Near Gay Dream Chapter 04
Str8 Sex To Be Near Gay Dream

Str8 Sex To Be Near Gay Dream Chapter 04

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 24,376
Summer College Surprises
Summer College Surprises

Summer College Surprises

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 6,327
Sex And The Office Chapter 01
Sex And The Office Chapter 01

Sex And The Office Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 24,649
She Didnt Expect It
She Didnt Expect It

She Didnt Expect It

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 20,294
Suzies Little Sister
Suzies Little Sister

Suzies Little Sister

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 14,047
Sara And Darrens First Meeting
Sara And Darrens First Meeting

Sara And Darrens First Meeting

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 13,471
Summer Chores 1
Summer Chores 1

Summer Chores 1

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 16,141
So Cold So Hot
So Cold So Hot

So Cold So Hot

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 16,653
Sea Cruise 1
Sea Cruise 1

Sea Cruise 1

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 3,334
Ski Weekend Road Trip
Ski Weekend Road Trip

Ski Weekend Road Trip

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 2,095
Steamy My First Time Chapter 01
Steamy My First Time Chapter 0

Steamy My First Time Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.3 9,189
Save World Get Girl
Save World Get Girl

Save World Get Girl

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 2,438
Steve Meets A Cougar Chapter 01
Steve Meets A Cougar Chapter 0

Steve Meets A Cougar Chapter 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 8,279
Sometimes It Gets Complicated Part 01
Sometimes It Gets Complicated

Sometimes It Gets Complicated Part 01

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 9,424
Senior Year A Year To Remember
Senior Year A Year To Remember

Senior Year A Year To Remember

by Anonymous
★ 3.8 14,748
Sun Sea And My Girlfriends Sister
Sun Sea And My Girlfriends Sis

Sun Sea And My Girlfriends Sister

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 5,950
Singapore Bliss
Singapore Bliss

Singapore Bliss

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 5,547
Sonya Loses Her Virginity
Sonya Loses Her Virginity

Sonya Loses Her Virginity

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 20,543
Starbucks Booty In About 1000 Words
Starbucks Booty In About 1000

Starbucks Booty In About 1000 Words

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 11,772
Shivering 2
Shivering 2

Shivering 2

by Anonymous
★ 3.8 24,686
Sharing Is Caring Part 01 4
Sharing Is Caring Part 01 4

Sharing Is Caring Part 01 4

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 6,913
Steamy Jerusalem
Steamy Jerusalem

Steamy Jerusalem

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 9,424
Saturday Afternoon At The Pool
Saturday Afternoon At The Pool

Saturday Afternoon At The Pool

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 7,224
Sudden Sex
Sudden Sex

Sudden Sex

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 23,060
Secret Santa 5
Secret Santa 5

Secret Santa 5

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 18,554
Savita My Dream Maid
Savita My Dream Maid

Savita My Dream Maid

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 7,833
Santas Little Helper 1
Santas Little Helper 1

Santas Little Helper 1

by Anonymous
★ 3.8 14,913
Slightly Once Chapter 07
Slightly Once Chapter 07

Slightly Once Chapter 07

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 13,324
Sallys First Pilot
Sallys First Pilot

Sallys First Pilot

by Anonymous
★ 4.1 7,652
Special Tutorial
Special Tutorial

Special Tutorial

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 3,918
Sexily Ever After Chapter 02
Sexily Ever After Chapter 02

Sexily Ever After Chapter 02

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 845
Summer Job 17
Summer Job 17

Summer Job 17

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 7,490
Simon Pendleton Chapter 03
Simon Pendleton Chapter 03

Simon Pendleton Chapter 03

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 12,868
Symposium Day Chapter 03
Symposium Day Chapter 03

Symposium Day Chapter 03

by Anonymous
★ 3.8 16,346
Stealing My Neighbours Husband
Stealing My Neighbours Husband

Stealing My Neighbours Husband

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 11,324
Stephanies Lust
Stephanies Lust

Stephanies Lust

by Anonymous
★ 3.9 18,571
Spin The Bottle Party
Spin The Bottle Party

Spin The Bottle Party

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 11,983
Speechless 10
Speechless 10

Speechless 10

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 24,887
Sex Worker Corps 02 Breaking In
Sex Worker Corps 02 Breaking I

Sex Worker Corps 02 Breaking In

by Anonymous
★ 4.0 6,109
Sailing Into The Unknown 1
Sailing Into The Unknown 1

Sailing Into The Unknown 1

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 16,311
Seducing Jennifer Part 05
Seducing Jennifer Part 05

Seducing Jennifer Part 05

by Anonymous
★ 4.2 11,080
Skylar And Rose Chapter 01 The Beginning
Skylar And Rose Chapter 01 The

Skylar And Rose Chapter 01 The Beginning

by Anonymous
★ 4.7 18,431
Susan Finds Her Place Part 04
Susan Finds Her Place Part 04

Susan Finds Her Place Part 04

by Anonymous
★ 4.3 540
Stacked
Stacked

Stacked

by Anonymous
★ 4.5 20,732
Summer Of 69 3
Summer Of 69 3

Summer Of 69 3

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 19,206
Shweta Fucks Her Tailor
Shweta Fucks Her Tailor

Shweta Fucks Her Tailor

by Anonymous
★ 4.6 10,684
Seducing Jennifer Part 06
Seducing Jennifer Part 06

Seducing Jennifer Part 06

by Anonymous
★ 4.3 24,339
Sharing 23
Sharing 23

Sharing 23

by Anonymous
★ 4.4 23,990