First Time Stories
11,520 stories • Page 112 of 120
My First And Second Time 1
My First And Second Time 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
11,269
Ms Rich 01
Ms Rich 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
24,216
My First Blowjob 25
My First Blowjob 25
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
16,282
My Best Friends Mom 15
My Best Friends Mom 15
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
817
My Sisters Friends Chapter 03
My Sisters Friends Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
16,462
My Muscleman Roommate Part 01
My Muscleman Roommate Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
6,369
Mistress Liz Part 01
Mistress Liz Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
11,354
Madonna Chapter 05
Madonna Chapter 05
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
21,305
My Beginning Part 01
My Beginning Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
11,599
My First Hotwife
My First Hotwife
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
21,360
Meeting A Stranger
Meeting A Stranger
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
2,573
My Cousin My First Time And Mo
My Cousin My First Time And More
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
12,571
Mwm Bisexual Musings Chapter 0
Mwm Bisexual Musings Chapter 05
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
4,230
My Twin Sister Is A Cheerleade
My Twin Sister Is A Cheerleader Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
24,407
My Sisters First Fucking Orgas
My Sisters First Fucking Orgasm
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
10,204
Mary 5
Mary 5
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
2,739
My Fascinations
My Fascinations
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
14,595
My Sexual Awakening 5
My Sexual Awakening 5
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
5,895
My Bi Sexual Awakening Part 02
My Bi Sexual Awakening Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
2,639
Marian Grows Up
Marian Grows Up
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
12,189
Meeting Larry
Meeting Larry
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
12,205
Massage Chonicles Chelsea My 1
Massage Chonicles Chelsea My 1st
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
24,802
Mutual Sex Education
Mutual Sex Education
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
8,699
More Than Just Friends 5
More Than Just Friends 5
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
5,535
My Mortal Enemy Chapter 02
My Mortal Enemy Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
13,136
My Birthday Feast For My Boyfr
My Birthday Feast For My Boyfriend
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
9,638
My First Nudist Experience
My First Nudist Experience
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
15,094
Making It Happen 3
Making It Happen 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
7,192
Mos Visit To America
Mos Visit To America
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
16,527
My First Chub
My First Chub
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
12,807
My Cock Sucking Stories Chapte
My Cock Sucking Stories Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
16,281
Making Music With Nick Chapter
Making Music With Nick Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
20,566
My Friend Ashley Chapter 01
My Friend Ashley Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
16,052
My First Bisexual Experience 3
My First Bisexual Experience 3
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
7,054
Mr Jones And My Virginity
Mr Jones And My Virginity
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
19,352
My Young Neighbor The Stealth
My Young Neighbor The Stealth Hottie
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
15,532
My Sisters Friends 2
My Sisters Friends 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
5,466
Memories Of Our Babysitter Cha
Memories Of Our Babysitter Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
8,343
My First Time 152
My First Time 152
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
22,569
My First Real Sexual Encounter
My First Real Sexual Encounter
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
4,159
My Sorority Slut Chapter 02
My Sorority Slut Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
1,390
Maria And Joe Part 02
Maria And Joe Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
8,058
Mile High First Time
Mile High First Time
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
6,041
Mature Touch
Mature Touch
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
21,360
Margo A Virgin
Margo A Virgin
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
8,884
Madison Wasnt A Virgin
Madison Wasnt A Virgin
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
15,233
Moms Panties 13
Moms Panties 13
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
9,831
Metamorphosis Part 01
Metamorphosis Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
5,870
My Student My Lover
My Student My Lover
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
8,007
Mellow Yellow Next Generation
Mellow Yellow Next Generation Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
8,925
More Than This
More Than This
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
17,845
My Brothers Keeper Chapter 01
My Brothers Keeper Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
13,850
Mutual Benefits Chapter 08
Mutual Benefits Chapter 08
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
2,927
My Goth Girlfriend
My Goth Girlfriend
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
18,905
Mind Games Lead To Body Games
Mind Games Lead To Body Games
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
21,517
My Valentine 8
My Valentine 8
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
12,487
Mandy The Pta Mom
Mandy The Pta Mom
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
5,827
Mistaken For A Fluffer Chapter
Mistaken For A Fluffer Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
19,434
My First Hot Threesome
My First Hot Threesome
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
18,245
Merry Christmas To One And All
Merry Christmas To One And All
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
17,426
Memoirs Of A Baby Boomer Acade
Memoirs Of A Baby Boomer Academic Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
11,842
My Blonde Goddess
My Blonde Goddess
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
4,135
My First Chapter 02
My First Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
4,637
Marooned Chapter 03
Marooned Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
22,702
My Muse 14
My Muse 14
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
19,504
More Fun With My Friend Laurie
More Fun With My Friend Laurie
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
7,070
My First Virgin 2
My First Virgin 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
1,283
Meadow Spring Brook
Meadow Spring Brook
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
7,948
My Comfort Zone
My Comfort Zone
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
10,395
My Fantasy 26
My Fantasy 26
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
11,701
My Straight Best Friend Chapte
My Straight Best Friend Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
3,989
My Best Friends Wife 16
My Best Friends Wife 16
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
21,955
My Wild African Princess
My Wild African Princess
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
13,867
My Wifes Best Friend 8
My Wifes Best Friend 8
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
18,590
My Wife Jada And The Gloryhole
My Wife Jada And The Gloryhole
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
13,452
Marriage Or The Surprised Wife
Marriage Or The Surprised Wife
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
14,850
Mother In Law Fun
Mother In Law Fun
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
1,803
My First Time I Sold My Pussy
My First Time I Sold My Pussy
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
22,322
My Wife Lily
My Wife Lily
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
13,202
Mountains And A Coincidence
Mountains And A Coincidence
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
9,388
My Best Friend Stacie
My Best Friend Stacie
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
11,945
Mrs Bridges
Mrs Bridges
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
3,795
Mutual Benefits Chapter 06
Mutual Benefits Chapter 06
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
9,827
Miley And Me
Miley And Me
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
14,488
Mary On Her Way Back Home
Mary On Her Way Back Home
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
23,156
My First Cock Bbc Chapter 05
My First Cock Bbc Chapter 05
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
24,756
My First Lover Ten
My First Lover Ten
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
4,424
Miaw The Life Of The Party
Miaw The Life Of The Party
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
15,042
My Milf Seduction
My Milf Seduction
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
11,291
Murphys Law 3
Murphys Law 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
22,717
My Childhood Tuition Teacher
My Childhood Tuition Teacher
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
20,451
My First Time 228
My First Time 228
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
4,706
Margaret My First
Margaret My First
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
7,358
My First Orgasms
My First Orgasms
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
14,529
Manasvi First Encounter
Manasvi First Encounter
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
10,863
My Second Time 4
My Second Time 4
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
21,101