First Time Stories
11,520 stories • Page 115 of 120
My Indian Summer Part 04
My Indian Summer Part 04
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
12,147
My Gf Fulfilled My Darkest Fan
My Gf Fulfilled My Darkest Fantasy
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
12,179
Mother And Daughter Bbws Share
Mother And Daughter Bbws Share
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
22,694
My First Time 310
My First Time 310
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
15,950
My Student Lover
My Student Lover
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
7,318
Mormons Fuck
Mormons Fuck
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
20,308
More Than A Nap
More Than A Nap
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
6,687
My First Time 320
My First Time 320
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
9,681
My Biggest Ball Bust Ever
My Biggest Ball Bust Ever
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
18,589
My First Gay Handsome Boyfrien
My First Gay Handsome Boyfriend
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
1,166
Moving Day 25
Moving Day 25
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
23,151
Making Of A Male Slut Chapter
Making Of A Male Slut Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
933
My Best Friend And I Part 02
My Best Friend And I Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
11,079
My Dog Sitter Chapter 02
My Dog Sitter Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
15,184
My Getaway With Gabby
My Getaway With Gabby
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
13,165
Making Chemistry In Chemistry
Making Chemistry In Chemistry Lab
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
24,797
My Seduction Of Steve Perilli
My Seduction Of Steve Perilli
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
13,198
My Girl Friends View Of Our Fi
My Girl Friends View Of Our First Fuck
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
16,596
My First Threesome With An Old
My First Threesome With An Older Couple
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
5,043
My Dirty Talking Girl
My Dirty Talking Girl
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
15,416
Memoirs Of A Gentleman
Memoirs Of A Gentleman
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
17,515
Mona 3
Mona 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
22,567
My Girl Ronnie
My Girl Ronnie
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
17,201
My Pants Please
My Pants Please
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
18,270
Mailroom Girl
Mailroom Girl
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
10,366
My First Orgasm In The Mens Do
My First Orgasm In The Mens Dorm
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
19,514
My Best Friend Kaytlin
My Best Friend Kaytlin
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
18,318
Magic Problems
Magic Problems
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
8,102
Mrs B Chapter 01
Mrs B Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
22,083
My First Time With Rachel
My First Time With Rachel
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
6,560
My Friends Daughter Part 02
My Friends Daughter Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
6,407
Maid To Serve 1
Maid To Serve 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
23,298
Midnight In Italy
Midnight In Italy
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
15,390
My New Gym Friend
My New Gym Friend
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
7,293
My Straight Best Friend Chapte
My Straight Best Friend Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
18,542
Motorcycle Trip
Motorcycle Trip
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
3,308
My Best Friends Mother 7
My Best Friends Mother 7
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
24,807
Marissas Lesson
Marissas Lesson
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
19,800
Mandy Part 05
Mandy Part 05
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
3,087
My Renaissance Chapter 14
My Renaissance Chapter 14
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
12,824
Mothers Turning Point
Mothers Turning Point
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
16,286
Mrs Jones Meter Reader
Mrs Jones Meter Reader
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
1,875
Meant To Be Together Im The On
Meant To Be Together Im The One
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
6,580
Midnight Swim 4
Midnight Swim 4
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
18,395
Making The Team 1
Making The Team 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
22,775
My Cousin My First Lover
My Cousin My First Lover
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
563
Making The Grade In Biology
Making The Grade In Biology
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
13,695
My Best Friend Stacie Chapter
My Best Friend Stacie Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
11,345
My Teacher My Angel
My Teacher My Angel
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
18,545
My First Time 295
My First Time 295
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
9,184
Making Love To The Greek Woman
Making Love To The Greek Woman
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
7,199
Ms Singly Takes Me In Class
Ms Singly Takes Me In Class
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
10,306
Ms Jones Punishes Joey
Ms Jones Punishes Joey
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
17,478
My Teacher Ms Miller Chapter 0
My Teacher Ms Miller Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
8,159
My Sisters Friend 7
My Sisters Friend 7
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
16,921
My Bff Jenny
My Bff Jenny
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
10,897
My Buddys Gf Takes My Virginit
My Buddys Gf Takes My Virginity
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
14,321
Mutual Benefits Chapter 01
Mutual Benefits Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
2,718
My Lovely Unsophisticated Wife
My Lovely Unsophisticated Wife Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
4,486
My Second Penis
My Second Penis
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
24,920
My Thoughts On Handjobs 1
My Thoughts On Handjobs 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
13,115
My Second Sex Teacher
My Second Sex Teacher
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
19,625
My Brothers Best Friend Chapte
My Brothers Best Friend Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
7,596
More Confessions
More Confessions
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
22,004
Mountain Bachelor Chapter 02
Mountain Bachelor Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
11,604
Meeting Gaby
Meeting Gaby
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
8,926
Mrs Ls Swimming Pool
Mrs Ls Swimming Pool
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
23,680
Mrs T And Me
Mrs T And Me
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
20,691
My First Time 305
My First Time 305
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
4,434
Mercy Fuck 1
Mercy Fuck 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
16,935
Models Of Perfuction Chapter 0
Models Of Perfuction Chapter 05
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
9,889
My Beginning Part 03
My Beginning Part 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
20,153
Mutual Service Chapter 03
Mutual Service Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
6,573
My First College Experience 2
My First College Experience 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
3,541
My Lovely Unsophisticated Wife
My Lovely Unsophisticated Wife Part 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
21,147
My First Sexual Experience Cha
My First Sexual Experience Chapter 02 3
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
9,313
Massage A Lot More Than I Expe
Massage A Lot More Than I Expected
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
20,010
Memories Pleasure And Pain
Memories Pleasure And Pain
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
5,235
My Bestie Also A Girl Touched
My Bestie Also A Girl Touched Me
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
19,413
Making Her First Time Memorabl
Making Her First Time Memorable
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
18,611
Manny Chapter 01
Manny Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
537
My First Experience With A Chu
My First Experience With A Chub
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
14,510
My Best Friends Girl Chapter 0
My Best Friends Girl Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
16,680
My Maxs First
My Maxs First
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
1,690
My Sons Best Friend
My Sons Best Friend
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
5,618
Making Love With An Angel
Making Love With An Angel
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
22,354
My Cousins Gymnastics Trainer
My Cousins Gymnastics Trainer
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
21,889
My First Time I Sold My Pussy
My First Time I Sold My Pussy 03
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
1,260
Massaged Into Submission
Massaged Into Submission
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
22,886
My First Time 136
My First Time 136
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
18,943
My First Time 121
My First Time 121
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
16,335
Menage A Trois Plus One Chapte
Menage A Trois Plus One Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
13,034
My Sexy Wife Jennifer Chapter
My Sexy Wife Jennifer Chapter 06
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
5,333
Mums Boyfriend My Teacher 1
Mums Boyfriend My Teacher 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
7,112
My Wet Hot Spring Break Part 0
My Wet Hot Spring Break Part 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
11,604
My First Real Bisexual Experie
My First Real Bisexual Experience Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
6,866