First Time Stories
11,520 stories • Page 119 of 120
Pushing Buttons 2
Pushing Buttons 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
23,387
Personal Growth Chapter 02
Personal Growth Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
4,583
Pool Party Leads To First Swap
Pool Party Leads To First Swap
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
15,649
Professor Remis Creamy Appetiz
Professor Remis Creamy Appetizer
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
20,705
Pams First Virgin
Pams First Virgin
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
8,781
Pete The New Guy Chapter 01
Pete The New Guy Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
14,911
Paris France 1
Paris France 1
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
9,786
Pouring Love
Pouring Love
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
5,114
Pledging Virginity
Pledging Virginity
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
1,862
Pink 11
Pink 11
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
9,969
Playtester Is Being Tested
Playtester Is Being Tested
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
3,939
Playing Doctor 7
Playing Doctor 7
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
15,923
Pete And Leah Learn The Ropes
Pete And Leah Learn The Ropes Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
12,246
Pulling Strings
Pulling Strings
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
10,633
Preparing For Halloween Part 0
Preparing For Halloween Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
16,509
Plastic Knickers Spank And Wan
Plastic Knickers Spank And Wank
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
2,524
Pizza Delivery 1
Pizza Delivery 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
8,378
Peggy Sanford The Early Years
Peggy Sanford The Early Years Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
22,375
Patricias Sexual Adventures Ch
Patricias Sexual Adventures Chapter 10
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
22,773
Priestess Chapter 01
Priestess Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
7,761
Painting A Lion
Painting A Lion
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
11,614
Prima Nocte Chapter 02 Homecom
Prima Nocte Chapter 02 Homecoming
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
2,018
Practice Makes Perfect 18
Practice Makes Perfect 18
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
7,964
Playing Doctor With Sandy
Playing Doctor With Sandy
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
19,971
Peggy Sanford The Early Years
Peggy Sanford The Early Years Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
19,220
Popcorn 2
Popcorn 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
9,366
Physical Checkup
Physical Checkup
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
3,418
Providence Chapter 01 1
Providence Chapter 01 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
24,498
Prof Johnsons First Frat Party
Prof Johnsons First Frat Party
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
16,215
Painters Delight
Painters Delight
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
22,678
Playing With Fire Chapter 01 2
Playing With Fire Chapter 01 2
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
894
Prom Night For The Misfit Club
Prom Night For The Misfit Club
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
18,612
Phone Fun Chapter 01
Phone Fun Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
2,999
Psych Credit
Psych Credit
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
13,279
P O R N
P O R N
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
6,873
Pete And Leah Learn The Ropes
Pete And Leah Learn The Ropes Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
22,608
Prom Night Chapter 1
Prom Night Chapter 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
22,274
Pipestone Bible Camp Chapter 0
Pipestone Bible Camp Chapter 02 College Reunion
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
5,719
Pure Heart Tangled With Tech P
Pure Heart Tangled With Tech Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
1,369
Play Time 4
Play Time 4
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
13,991
Pauls Journey
Pauls Journey
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
10,722
Porn Stars Daughter Chapter 11
Porn Stars Daughter Chapter 11
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
21,222
Poolside 15
Poolside 15
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
7,279
Psychology 1 Virginity 0
Psychology 1 Virginity 0
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
22,923
Pams First Mmf
Pams First Mmf
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
14,691
Pam My Fantasy Girl
Pam My Fantasy Girl
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
23,436
Problem Student Chapter 03
Problem Student Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
11,943
Pool Reversal Part 01
Pool Reversal Part 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
6,183
Payback 38
Payback 38
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
22,791
Paige Teaches Perversion Part
Paige Teaches Perversion Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
966
Penny 10
Penny 10
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
16,075
Paradise Island Chapter 07
Paradise Island Chapter 07
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
5,627
Prom Virgin
Prom Virgin
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
3,768
Problem Student Chapter 01
Problem Student Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
20,554
Personals 1
Personals 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
9,056
Passion Soaked Summer Night
Passion Soaked Summer Night
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
6,700
P01 Birthday Rubdown
P01 Birthday Rubdown
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
7,917
Pimping Angel
Pimping Angel
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
7,515
Point Hollow Chapter 03
Point Hollow Chapter 03
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
7,239
Party Dress 1
Party Dress 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
11,923
Professional Excellence Chapte
Professional Excellence Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
4,459
Precious Jules
Precious Jules
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
9,724
Perfect First
Perfect First
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
20,627
Pining For Madison
Pining For Madison
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
16,730
Putty In Their Hands
Putty In Their Hands
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
9,800
Penelope 1
Penelope 1
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
8,989
Poker Night 14
Poker Night 14
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
2,236
Pictures From An Exhibition El
Pictures From An Exhibition Elaine
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
6,212
Problem Student Chapter 02
Problem Student Chapter 02
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
14,271
Pleasuring My Timid Friend
Pleasuring My Timid Friend
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
12,582
Pippa Chapter 08
Pippa Chapter 08
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
13,702
Patience Loses Her Virginity
Patience Loses Her Virginity
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
24,385
Prima Nocte Chapter 03 The Bes
Prima Nocte Chapter 03 The Best Laid Plans
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
7,931
Prenuptial Doctor Visit Part 0
Prenuptial Doctor Visit Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
10,561
Paybacks A Bitch But Its Fun P
Paybacks A Bitch But Its Fun Part 02
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
22,594
Providing A Service
Providing A Service
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
18,503
Parts Of Desire Chapter 04
Parts Of Desire Chapter 04
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
9,288
Patty My First
Patty My First
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
7,426
Petes Adventures Through Time
Petes Adventures Through Time
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
9,031
Playing After The Pool
Playing After The Pool
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
11,360
Plump And Plain
Plump And Plain
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
17,520
Prickly Hedges
Prickly Hedges
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
17,765
Papi Chapter 01
Papi Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 3.9
16,450
Playing In The Woods
Playing In The Woods
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
4,308
Pete And Leah Learn The Ropes
Pete And Leah Learn The Ropes Chapter 03a
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
8,795
Paradise Found And Lost
Paradise Found And Lost
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
6,774
Part 1 Her 18th Birthday
Part 1 Her 18th Birthday
by Anonymous
★ 4.6
1,095
Popping Her Cherry
Popping Her Cherry
by Anonymous
★ 4.0
806
Pining For Madison The Favour
Pining For Madison The Favour
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
9,754
Play Time With A Friend
Play Time With A Friend
by Anonymous
★ 4.7
12,520
Public Peep Trainstation Bathr
Public Peep Trainstation Bathroom
by Anonymous
★ 3.8
5,255
Push It Hard
Push It Hard
by Anonymous
★ 4.5
4,396
Projekt L Chapter 01
Projekt L Chapter 01
by Anonymous
★ 4.1
22,916
Painters Delight 1
Painters Delight 1
by Anonymous
★ 4.4
11,399
Practice Makes Perfect 9
Practice Makes Perfect 9
by Anonymous
★ 4.3
13,325
Passion In Holy Orders
Passion In Holy Orders
by Anonymous
★ 4.2
8,915