Doug had not said a word about continuing swapping for about a month. I sensed he was afraid to try again. For Doug, our first two tries had been less than what he had expected as both women had strong personalities, taking control over Doug.
I, on the other hand, had a good time fucking other men and had to admit to myself that I didn't want to quit. Sex with Doug had gotten better since our first swap but my thoughts were often going back to Jim and Dan and how different their cocks felt inside me. A potential solution came when Rachel called me. Rachel and Jim had gone to swap party a couple of times and the host asked them if they knew any other couples that might like to partake.
Rachel told me that it was a key party where we all mingled for an hour or so then the guys put their keys in a bowl and the girls pulled out a key. The girls would then go home with the guy for the night. If we went, there would be five couples. I asked Rachel if there was any way to pre-choose who Doug would go home with. I told her Doug was a little overwhelmed having been with two strong women and I would like to see if I could pick who he was to be with, without him knowing.
Rachel was not surprised; I think she knew Doug did not have a great time with her. "I felt that I might have overwhelmed him on his first time. Kari, I think I can do this for you but you might have to make a sacrifice. Take one for the team so to speak."
She continued, "There is this one wife Debbie. She is a cute little thing that Jim told me is quiet and submissive. From what Jim told me about her, I think she would be perfect for Doug. Jim said she gives a great blow job. I think I can talk the host into rigging the draw so Doug gets her but you will have to take John."
"What's the deal with John?" I asked.
"John is okay, he is loud and full of himself. He talks big but he is not if you know what I mean. However, his wife is hot, so the guys all want them at the party." Rachel said.
"For Doug, I will do it. I would only have a one in four chance to get him anyway right? How do we do it?"
"I will figure it out with the host and let you know at the party, you just have to convince Doug to go," Rachel laughed.
I told Doug that night at dinner that Rachel had called. "Rachel called, she wanted to invite us to a party this Saturday night."
Doug gave me a sceptical look.
"She said it was a key party. I guess we have some drinks and snacks meeting everyone then the guys put their keys in a bowl. The girls then pick out a set of keys and take the owner of the keys home, except it can't be their own husband. I told them that I would ask you if you were interested."
Doug was looking hard at me to see if I was excited to go or not. I had my best poker face on, showing no emotion either way.
"What do you think honey? I'm not sure this is for us," he said.
"Doug this is your thing, I'm good with going if you want to, but if you don't want to go, I don't either." I knew that was the answer he was looking for.
He smiled to my response; I knew he wanted to try again.
"Do you know who is going to be there? Is Dan and Heidi part of this?" Doug asked.
I could tell he was hoping they were not. "Rachel didn't say there were and she did say that we would not know the other three couples, so I would say no."
"I know you were reluctant at first about swapping but you don't seem as reluctant now," Doug said with hesitation.
"This was your idea for us to have sex with other people. You said it would spice up our sex life and I think it has. I feel bad for you that your experiences with Rachel and Heidi were not what you wanted. But if you are asking me if I enjoyed having sex with Jim and Dan. I would say that I did enjoy fucking them. It hasn't changed my love for you. It was just physical sex. I want you to have the experience that you want."
I knew using the word fucking would get my point across. "I just hope you will find what you are looking for fucking one of these other women."
Doug looked at me a little stunned, "I guess we could try it again."
"Alright, I will call Rachel and tell her we will be there."
I decided that I was going full slut to this party. I found a short black dress that had a deep "V" cut in front. My plan was to go without a bra or panties. My tits would be free bouncing in my tight dress.
"Holy shit, you look great Kari," Doug said when he saw me.
"Not too slutty?"
"We're going to a swinger's party, you look perfectly slutty. I just hope I'm as lucky as the guy whose keys you pick," Doug said kissing me.
"You just remember that when your keys are picked it is just for the night then you are coming home to me."
We arrived at the party and I immediately picked out John before he was introduced to us. He was a little overweight and very loud. He was not bad looking but his personality was over the top. Next to him was his wife Charlotte, who was stunning. She was tall, blonde and had a great body. I could understand why the guys wanted her at the party.
Across the room, I picked out Debbie too. Standing at barely five feet tall, she was cute, with glasses. She stood quietly next to her husband who I later found out was Terry.
We were introduced to the hosts Angie and Frank. Angie winked at me and said she would talk with me later before the draw.
We mingled and met everyone including Debbie and John. I played a little with John telling him to try and keep his eyes off my tits at least some of the time.
John laughed loudly, "if you pick my keys those big tits will get my full attention."
Angie finally pulled me aside telling me her plan. Out of the five girls at the party, Debbie and Charlotte were not in on the plan. John's keys had a Mercedes emblem on the ring and ours had a big "H" so both were easy to distinguish in the bowl without looking. Angie was going to have Charlotte go first.
