This is, of course, the continuation of Jim and Tricia's story, which I just broke up because of the length. If you do not read part one, part two probably won't make any sense. This is also being submitted before any comments were posted about part one, so nothing was changed to appease anyone. While I do read the comments, and take any constructive criticism seriously, I do not tailor my plots for popularity points – or unpopularity points as I've been accused of deliberately 'trolling' with my plot decisions. Once again, huge thanks for rnebular for editing and giving suggestions to one really long story, which I then split into two. I do plan on bringing Sonia back as a protagonist at some point – probably not in Loving Wives, but another category. I hope you enjoy.
****************
After a restless night from their discussion at Sonia's Club, Jim and Tricia both took the following day off. They spent the day looking for a counselor and coming up with tentative guidelines for them to follow moving forward. While it was clear a majority of them, like never drinking without the other spouse present or never being alone in a house with a member of the opposite sex, were for Jim to get over the trust issues he was having, he didn't want to ask Tricia to do anything that he wasn't prepared to do. That came into play, when after a heated discussion about Tricia no longer going out with girl friends for a meal and having just a few drinks, she offered Jim a hall-pass to 'even things out' as long as it wasn't with Lillian or Sonia. Jim, of course, refused and eventually things calmed down to a civil discussion again.
While Tricia still agreed to severe ties with Geoff and Lillian, she felt that she should contact Geoff first so he wouldn't be blindsided by Lillian having all the details. Jim actually wanted that to happen, but he wanted to be there when she called him. Tricia agreed, but wouldn't put the call on speaker. She said she didn't trust Jim to not lose his temper and speak out.
"Hi Geoff, it's Trish," Tricia said cheerfully, though she looked anxious, "Yes, Jim came back home. Look, I told him everything – everything."
Tricia listened and took a breath before she said, "That's not a good idea; don't come over. Look Geoff, for obvious reasons I've been thinking back a lot on that night... No, not for that reason. Can you please just tell me the truth? That night, did you just talk me into going to the RV with you so we would have sex? I know you didn't take whatever you gave me after we snorted some coke, even though you said you would. It kept me up for a full day and you fell right asleep that night. Did you talk me into taking a drug just to seduce me?"
Jim watched as Tricia's face went red and looked angrier and angrier, while her eyes started to water.
"No," she said vehemently, "That definitely wasn't 'what I wanted' that night and you fucking know that. Here I thought it was as much a stupid mistake for you as it was for me, but thanks for clarifying that... And how the fuck do you not get the hint when I've told you fifty times, no? Yes, I was scared you'd tell my husband, that's the only reason I didn't kick you in the balls when you tried to kiss me the last time...
"Well, fuck you Geoff. I can't fucking believe it took me this long to see you for what you really are. You are no longer welcomed in our home and we don't want anything to do with you. Oh, and since you and Lillian still have that open marriage thing; I'm letting Jim spend one full afternoon fucking her here whenever she's next available. I might even videotape it for you to watch. I'm calling her right away. It's the least I can do for Jim after all this. Bye forever, asshole."
As soon as she hung up, the waterworks started, and Jim went and hugged her.
As she cried against his chest, Tricia said, "He said I always gave him signals and he just gave me an excuse to do what really I wanted. I never wanted him, ever. He called me a cock tease for leading him on and that I'd be calling him to hook up as soon as you divorced me for being a slut."
"Shhh, he's lying. We're done with him," Jim said, really tempted to jump in his car and drive to the school, "I better invite Lillian over."
"No, I wasn't serious. I just said that to hurt him," Tricia said her eyes wide.
Jim kissed her forehead. "Yes, I know. Remember, I don't want a hall pass. We fix this as a family. We also said it would be best to tell Lillian together, right?"
Tricia nodded and Jim picked up his phone.
About twenty minutes later, Lillian was walking up the driveway looking nervous. Her usual flawless make-up wasn't done and her hair was still wet.
Jim opened the door to let her in.
Lillian looked worried about something. "Jim, is Trish here too? Geoff just texted me that if I fucked you, he was kicking me out for good. I never told him what you said to me yesterday, only that you knew."
Jim sighed. "Come in, Lil. Tricia is waiting in the living room. We need to talk."
Lillian walked in and sat in the couch across from Tricia. Jim went and sat beside his wife and held her hand.
"So, you two are dealing with things? That's a good sign," Lillian said, still looking a little anxious.
"Lil, I just told Geoff that Jim was going to fuck you all afternoon," Tricia said quickly.
"You what!" Lillian said looking both surprised and angry.
Jim held up her hand. "Please, wait. Let her explain why. I'm sorry, but you need to know some things."
Lillian crossed her arms and nodded.
"First, you know your husband and I lied to you about Jim knowing about that New Years, and I'm really sorry about that like I said last night. But, that's not the only lie." Tricia took deep breaths to keep calm. "What Jim heard from Rory was exactly what happened, though I didn't know until last night who the other man was in the RV. While I was super drunk, your husband talked me into doing some coke with him. After, he talked me into taking this pill. Once it kicked in, Geoff convinced me that my husband was there with us and I had a threesome with him and a man I believed to be my husband. I was hallucinating, couldn't think clearly at all, and fully went along with what I thought was a sexual experience with Jim and Geoff that really felt like a dream. I didn't know until after you helped clean me up and I went downstairs that it wasn't Jim.