During my freshman year of college, I started dating my girlfriend Alexa. Alexa lived in my dorm on another floor, and we met through some mutual friends.
Alexa is one of those girls that almost any guy would have a crush on or at least really want to fuck. She's 5' 4", cute and bubbly, athletic, with long black hair, hazel eyes, and huge tits. She wasn't the biggest girl, but had these massive DDs that caught a lottttt of stares. Seriously, she was very popular amongst dudes in the dorm.
My close group of friends consists of 6 guys. We all live on the same floor in our dorm, so we hang out in each other's rooms a lot. Our rooms are not directly next to each other, but you can walk to each of our rooms in 30 seconds.
When Alexa and I started dating, she would come over and hangout with my friends all the time. All of my friends took an immediate liking to her. She was funny, cool, cute, and she was nice eye candy to have around when we were hanging out. She would always wear these super tight bralettes and booty shorts, and her big tits and ass would just hang out for all of us to stare at. My friends were even bold enough to make comments here or there, along the lines of "damn Alexa you got a sister that looks like you that we could talk to?" It was all in good fun.
She would also lightly flirt back with my friends, teasing them about their dating lives or muscles or how good they'd be at sex or something similar. It never bothered me, and honestly, it kind of turned me on. It turned me on to know that all my friends probably went back to their rooms and jerked off to the thought of titty fucking my girlfriend or cumming in her mouth.
One night, while my roommate was out, Alexa and I were chilling in my room and I started asking her a few questions.
"Babe, do you think any of my friends are cute?" I asked casually.
"Ummmm, yea I mean you definitely have attractive friends. You're a very attractive guy so I guess it makes sense." she responded sweetly.
"Well who specifically do you think is cute?"
"Uhhh... I think Adam is pretty cute. He kind of reminds me of you a bit. Ben is also pretty cute. Oh and Mark too probably."
"Why do you think they're cute. Give me some specific reasons."
"Specific reasons? Ok...I think Ben has a nice face and his body is pretty nice. Mark is friendly and really sweet to me, it seems like he actually cares about me. And Adam kinda looks like you so I think he's honestly kind of sexy..if that's ok to say..."
"Nah haha babe I'm the one asking. Don't worry. What about my roommate Sam?"
"Yea Sam is definitely an attractive guy. I guess attractive guys also always get attractive roommates. But yea he's definitely handsome, and he's also cool and friendly."
"Alright, so now another question for you babe. Would you fuck any of these guys if we weren't dating?"
"Why are you asking me this?"
"I'm just curious babe. So who do you think you would fuck out of these guys you listed?"
"Ummm...if you really really want to know...I guess, if we weren't dating obviously, I would be interested in hooking up with Adam and Ben. I mean honestly I said all of them are cute so I guess I'd be interested in hooking up with all of them. Remember, you asked me this!"
"No no babe haha I know. I know I asked this. Very interesting, very interesting.."
"Is there something you're not telling me? Why did you ask?"
I thought for a few seconds and then responded.
"I could probably give you a super roundabout answer babe and not tell you exactly how I feel, but I just figured it'd be better if I was just honest with you."
She nodded for me to continue.
"I notice the way you interact with my friends. You always come over in these super tight sexy clothes, and you're always flirting with them and teasing them and...I don't mind at all. Honestly I don't. In fact, the reason I'm bringing this up is because I actually find it so fucking hot that you do that. Knowing that all of my friends probably want to fuck you and think about fucking you just turns me on a lot for some reason."
"Babe, I'm not flirting with them..."
"Again Alexa, I promise you I'm not lying to you! I'm being honest when I say I really don't mind at all and it genuinely turns me on. So..do you flirt with my friends or not?"
"Ok fine, I probably do flirt with your friends.."
"Probably?"
"Ok fine! I definitely flirt with your friends! Like I said earlier, you have a lot of cute friends and they're all so nice and friendly and like me so much. I can't help myself, but I would never ever do anything to hurt you babe, I hope you know that."
"I know that babe, trust me, I truly know. But...what if I told you that what you think would hurt me actually wouldn't hurt me? What if I told you that what you think would hurt me would actually be the hottest thing I could ever imagine in the fucking world?"
"You can't be serious babe please stop."
"I am serious. I'm actually very serious. I'm the most serious I've ever been. I've kept this totally to myself, but I've thought of...sharing you...with my friends so many fucking times. Like soo many times. Every time I'm jerking off I'm thinking about sharing them with you. And it's not because I don't love you babe. It's just because I think you are so fucking sexy, and I want everyone to appreciate just how sexy you are."
"Well I hope not... Wow..you're actually serious. Well at least I hope you are because I believe you. So is that the point of this conversation? You just wanted to see which of your friends I'm attracted to so you have more material to jerk off to?"
I laughed, and then looked at her for a few seconds. "No babe. It's because I actually want to do it... And I know that might seem crazy or whatever but like I said I've thought about this a lot and I just know it's what I want. It's my ultimate fantasy, you could say."
"Ok babe...well I don't know if I would want to do that."
"I know I know, and I completely completely understand that. But can you just please do me the biggest favor and just think about it? I'm not going to bug you about it, I'm not going to keep pestering you about it, everything is going to be normal. But just think about this for a little bit, and once you've made your decision, just let me know. And even if it's not the decision I want, I promise promise promise you that I'm not going to be mad or butthurt at all. I love you very much and that's what matters most."
"Ok babe, if it matters to you that much I'll think about it. Similar to what you said, don't have any expectations about what I'm going to say. And give me some time to think because this is NOT the conversation I was expecting to have tonight."
"Haha babe, will do. Love you."
"Love you too."
Satisfied with the conversation, I started getting ready for bed and we called it a night.
A few days went by and I hadn't heard anything from Alexa. We were still hanging out all the time, business as usual, but it hadn't been brought up by me or here since. Then 2 weeks went by, still nothing. Then, a few days later, right when I was tempted to ask her if she had a decision yet, she came to my room one night and brought it up.
"So babe, I know you've been waiting anxiously to hear my response to the conversation we had a few weeks back. Thank you for being so patient baby."
"Of course babe. And honestly, I was just about to ask you so thank you for finally bringing it up hehehe."
She smiled "Oh you little horny boy. Ok so...I guess I'll just say it..I'm down."
I opened my mouth in shock. "Oh my...for real??"