Kirsten Vinter was happy in her job as a cook for a wealthy man and his wife even though it was in the city. Every morning she thanked God for the help the pastor of her church had given her in finding the job. Kirsten's parents were Swedish immigrants who lived on a farm outside of Chicago where her father was a sharecropper. When he and her mother both contracted cholera and died in January of 1866, the owner of the farm told Kirsten that she had to leave because he needed the house for another sharecropper.
Kirsten was just eighteen at the time, but thanks to the pastor at her local church she was able to find work as a cook for Mr. Robert Hines and his wife, Ester. Mr. Hines was a banker and he and his wife lived in a huge house in Irving Park. Kirsten's job paid only fifty cents a day, but included a room of her own and three meals a day.
Kirsten's job was to cook the meals Mr. and Mrs. Hines ate and to prepare food for any parties they might have. Another young woman, an Irish girl named Alice, did the cleaning and laundry. Kirsten found Alice to be not very mature in her thoughts and very spontaneous in her actions. That proved to be a valid assessment one night the third week in September after Kirsten had served Mr. and Mrs. Hines. She and Alice sat down in the kitchen to eat, and Alice asked Kirsten if she thought they should be paid so little when Mr. Hines had so much.
"I've talked to other girls who work in the houses on this street, and they are paid seventy-five cents a day and more if they have to cook for a party and clean up afterwards. I think we should both go to Mr. Hines and ask him to pay us more. What do you think?"
Alice was just happy to have a job. She'd never really thought about how much she was paid. Fifty cents a day was enough to buy what she needed and she had a little left over to buy materials for a new dress every other month.
"Alice, what if he decides to send us into the streets? You know where women in the streets end up, and I don't want that."
Alice shook her head.
"He won't do that. He won't be able to find any other girls who will work this hard without paying them the same as the girls in the other houses get paid. He might say he won't pay us more, but if that happens, what will we have lost? If he says he will, we'll be making more money. You just come along with me. I'll do all the talking."
That conversation took place at dinner the next night. After Mr. and Mrs. Hines had finished their dinner, Kirsten took them the cake she'd baked for dessert. Alice followed her into the dining room.
When Kirsten sat the plates in front of Mr. and Mrs. Hines, Alice spoke up.
"Mr. Hines, I have been talking to the other girls in the houses nearby and they are all paid seventy-five cents a day. We would ask you to raise our pay to the same. If you do, we'll work even harder for you."
Mr. Hines had put his napkin back in his lap and then smiled at Alice.
"So, you're saying that if I don't raise your pay, you won't work as hard?"
Alice shook her head.
"No. I'm just saying if you do, we'll work harder."
Mr. Hines smiled again.
"I'm satisfied with your work and I believe Mrs. Hines is as well. She has never said anything to the contrary to me. What would you do differently that would make me want to pay you more?"
Alice didn't say anything, and Mr. Hines laughed.
"I see by the look on Kirsten's face and the fact that she has not said anything that she is not party to your request even though she is here. Her pastor told me she is a hard worker and a nice young lady and I believe him so I shall not hold this against her. You do not have anything more to say, but I expected as much. You're not smart enough to have thought this out."
Mr. Hines' frowned and then raised his voice.
"You little Mick bitch, I pulled you out of a boarding house where you worked for your room and board, and this is how you thank me. I should send you into the streets. Men like girls with red hair, so maybe you can make a living on your back. How would you like that? Maybe you'll make some real money then.
"On second thought, you probably couldn't. You aren't pretty enough to get more than two bits a time, and after a year of laying on your back for five or six men every night, you'll look like you're forty instead of twenty-one. An old colored whore could make more money than you will.
"Now, both of you, go back to the kitchen where you belong and do not bother me and Mrs. Hines any more about this."
Alice was in tears of rage when she and Alice got back to the kitchen, and she turned to Kirsten.
"I'm not pretty enough? Did you hear him say that? I suppose I'm not pretty enough for what he does to me when Mrs. Hines goes to visit her mother or her friends. He never says that then."
Kirsten gasped.
"You mean he...he makes you...with him?"
Alice nodded.
"It started after the first month. It was a Saturday afternoon and he came into their bedroom when I was changing the sheets. He smiled and said I was a good housekeeper, and then said he thought I'd be better at some other things. I didn't know what he meant so I asked him.
"He didn't say anything at first. He just put his hands on my breasts and smiled. I was so scared I couldn't move. That's when he said I could earn some extra money if I took off my dress.
"I wouldn't have done it except I did need some extra money. My mother and father are still in Ireland and I need money to bring them to America. I asked him if that was all I had to do and he said we'd talk about it after I took off my dress.
"Well, I did, and when I was standing there in my chemise, he touched my breasts again and then my hips, and then said he'd always dreamed about having a woman like me.
"I asked him what that meant, and he just smiled and said I was old enough to know what he meant. Then he took a silver dollar out of his vest pocket and showed it to me and said it could be mine if I took off the rest of my clothes and then laid down on the bed.
"Kirsten, I want to bring my mother and father here, and I thought, well, maybe just this once. I did what he asked."
Kirsten was standing there with her hand on her mouth.
"You let him...you let him put his...in you?"
Alice nodded.
"Yes. It didn't take him long and it didn't hurt because I had already done it with the stable boy from next door. He gave me the silver dollar after he pulled up his pants and said there was more where that came from. He's been doing it to me almost every Saturday since then unless I couldn't.
Kirsten shook her head.
"Alice, you can't keep doing this. You'll get with child."
Alice frowned.
"I asked him once what he would do if this happened and he just laughed and said it would be my fault if that happened. I've been making sure that doesn't happen because I know what he'd do if it did. I would end up like he said tonight."
Alice then looked up at Kirsten, and her face was a mask of rage.
"I'm not going to let him do this to me. You'll see. He'll get what's coming to a man like him."
That Sunday afternoon, Kirsten was preparing Mr. Hines' favorite Sunday supper of roast beef, potatoes, carrots and onions when Alice came into the kitchen. Kirsten didn't give a thought to that. Alice didn't have much to do on Sunday afternoons and often joined her in the kitchen while she prepared the evening meal.
Kirsten had also baked some fresh bread, and as she carried it out of the kitchen, Alice said she would dish up the main course. When Kirsten came back into the kitchen, Alice had a large piece of beef, several potatoes and carrots, and a small serving of onions on two plates. Kirsten picked up the plates and took them to the dining room, then came back into the kitchen. She and Alice ate their meal after which Kirsten went back to the dining room to pick up the dishes.
It was as she was walking back to the kitchen with the plates that she heard Mr. Hines say he was feeling rather tired and thought he'd go upstairs to read a bit before going to sleep. Kirsten smiled at that comment because that was Mr. Hines' normal reaction to any heavy meal. She was a bit surprised that Mrs. Hines said she'd go with him. Mrs. Hines was not a big eater at all, and usually had a glass of wine before going to bed.
Alice said she was going to go for a walk before bedtime and left Kirsten to do up the dishes and put away the remaining food. Kirsten did so and then went to her room. After reading her Bible for half an hour, she blew out her lamp and went to bed.
The next morning, Kirsten was up, dressed, and in the kitchen at six because Mr. Hines always wanted his breakfast at seven. She fried potatoes and when they were nearly done, put sausage and eggs in with them, stirred the pan, and left them to cook while she made coffee.
When the coffee was done, Kirsten filled the silver pot, put it on a tray with two cups, cream, and sugar, and carried the tray into the dining room. She was surprised that Mr. Hines was not sitting there drumming his fingers on the table like he usually was. Mrs. Hines often came downstairs later than Mr. Hines, so Kirsten figured they had just slept a bit later than usual. She went back to the kitchen and moved the frying pan to the back of the stove to keep the food warm until Mr. and Mrs. Hines came down for breakfast.
After half an hour, they were still in their bedroom and Kirsten began to wonder if they were ill. It was not her place to wake them so she went to Alice's room to ask her to do so.
Alice was in her nightgown and wiping her eyes when she opened the door. Kirsten explained that she thought Alice should wake Mr. and Mrs. Hines for breakfast. Alice smiled, an expression Kirsten thought odd, but said she would do that as soon as she dressed. About fifteen minutes later, Alice went up the stairs to Mr. and Mrs. Hines' bedroom.