Katie always wanted to have a man who could make her think she's the only lady in his life and his bed. At 25, she was shy, and plain. While her twin sister, is a beautiful, outgoing, and sexy. The men are always calling the house or stopping by. She stayed away, because Sally said the guys were uncomfortable when she came into the room, they couldn't believe that she was so ugly, and Sally was so beautiful. So she stay away when the men came over. At night Katie would leave the house and walk out by the lake. On this night she decided to take a blanket and some food, she wasn't coming back for a while Sally had a man spending the night.
Laying the blanket out, she put the food on the edge and lay down to watch the night sky. Closing her eyes, she didn't hear him come up. "I haven't seen you out here in a while." he said. She look up, but didn't know who he was. "I only come out when I need a break." she told him. He sat down next to her on the blanket. "Do you mind if I join you?" he ask her. "No not at all, uh, Who are you?" she ask him. "Oh, I'm sorry, My name is Ben. I live next door to your dad." he said. "Hello Ben, I'm....." she said. "I know your Sally, right" he said. Before she could tell him she wasn't he pull her to him and kiss her.
Laying down he pull her on top of him and his hands explore her body, pulling her clothes off one by one. Taking one tit in his hand he lower his mouth and lick and suck on her nipple, rolling her under him he made his way down her body and back up to her lips. Taking her mouth in a deep passionate kiss he move his hips in line to enter her pussy with his cock. She felt his cock pushing inside of her, trying to move away, because she knew that he would find out that she wasn't Sally. He grab her hips to hold her in place and he plunge into her. "AAAAAAAAAGGGGGHHHHH!!" she scream.
He was to far gone to notice he had just entered a virgin. He pump his cock into her hard and fast. He slip his hand down to slip a finger between them rubbing her clit, he could feel her muscle tighten around his cock. Lowering his mouth down on her nipple again, he suck on it, then change to the other nipple. When he was ready to cum he thrust deep in side her pussy and left his cum there. Pulling out, and standing up, he hope he gotten her pregnant with his child. Figuring it would be the only way to get her to marry him, cause she would never believe that he wanted her Katie, and not Sally.
Katie open her eyes when he had left. Packing up her stuff she went home. Walking into her room, she told Sally to get the hell out of her room and go fuck her boyfriend in her own room. After they left, she slam the door and went to bed. The next morning she went about her business as usual, leaving for work at 8 and coming home after 5, fixing dinner then going to bed. This was her life for the next three months, that is until she got sick, and went to the Doctor. What she didn't know was that Doc. was also Ben's brother.