Casey sat brooding. He never let a whore have the upper hand and he knew Brook and Will were having disgusting fuck fests every chance that they got. He wasn't sure who he needed to teach a lesson to more. Brook was a fucking whore who dared lead him on and play him as a fool. But Will! Will was half the man he was! He let girls walk all over him, baby him, dominate him. What a damn pussy!
Casey had it all figured out. A way to punish both in the most royally embarrassing way possible. It was so simple he nearly laughed. He felt joyous over his little plan.
********************************
Brook and Will were the picture of sublime happiness. They were having sex like bunnies and when they were exhausted from it, they spent time doing all the wonderful things perfectly happy couples do all the time. The played tennis, socialized with friends, watched movies, stayed up all night laughing; Brook was on cloud nine.
They decided to go out one night to a fancy dinner just to celebrate a Thursday. It was a perfect little place that still had something to prove. The food was delicious, the portions huge, the ambiance surreal. They held hands over the dinner table with whispered conversations. After much hushed conversation and delicious food they decided to head home.
Driving home, they held hands and enjoyed each others' company. They laughed and talked about everything from music to movies to future plans. Eventually, Will noticed a pair of headlights following too closely, but he assumed he was driving too slowly because there was yet another set of headlights behind that one. Will accelerated a bit and kept conversation flowing with Brook. She had gotten a little sleepy from the wine but was clearly still focused on him, gauging the way she was massaging his arm.
Suddenly, the car behind knocked Brook and Will's in the rear.
"What the hell?!"
Both of them looked back to see a car swerving back and forth behind them, flashing its headlights and honking.
"Will, what do you think is happening?" Said Brook alarmed.
"I don't know, but I'm stopping. If they're in trouble I'll try to help, if it's an asshole, well let's just hope he's not carrying a gun."
As soon as Will began slowing, the car behind him backed off. He eased onto the shoulder and was followed by the rear car.
"Will, are you sure this is a good idea? I mean, this isn't exactly normal. If they need help they can just go to a police station or something."
"I dunno...I'm just going to check and see what's up."
Both Will and Brook exited the car and Brook waited anxiously as Will tentatively waved to the car behind and began walking towards it. Suddenly, Casey gets out of the car and slams the door behind him.
"Will, I am sick and tired of playing games with you over that nasty whore!"
Will stopped in shock. "How dare you talk about her like that you insignificant, narcissistic asshole. You're just pissed because she thought for one second you might be worth her time and quickly learned exactly how worthless you are. You were just hoping it would take her more time, but you're damn easy to peg. Now, leave us the hell alone, or I will kick your ass, call the cops, and claim self-defense!"
Casey was pissed, but he just had to remind himself to maintain control. He quickly, purposefully walked towards Will. Will braced himself for a fight, he was so focused that he never saw it coming. Casey's hand emerged from hidden behind him and he quickly brought it to Will's abdomen and let the taser loose. Will's eyes rolled, he convulsed, and fell like a rag doll onto the ground. Brook screamed in horror but before she could run from Casey, he grabbed her by the hair, shoved her hard onto the cement and bound her with twist ties and gagged her. He picked her up and brought her to his Jeep and placed her in the front seat as Will was starting to come to. He walked back over to Will and tased him again, getting not so secret joy from it, he bound and gagged him, and dragged him to the back of his Jeep. He drove off into the darkness to a secluded cabin, never noticing the vehicle following him at a distance.
Casey was thrilled with how easily and smoothly everything had gone. Literally perfect. The most that he could hope for is that the rest will go just as perfectly. He was getting hard just thinking about it, he'd better rein that in or he'd ruin his own plans. After he managed to drag both of them inside, they twisted and groaned more than he cared for, he placed Brook on the bed and sat Will in a chair, aimed just so with a view of the bed. He strapped Will down with more twist ties. The fury in Will's eyes excited Casey; Will knew something awful was going to happen and there was nothing he could do about it.
Now Casey moved his attentions to where they were more needed, Brook was doing her damnedest to get out of her restraints. It warmed Casey's heart seeing how excited she was for him. He touched her face lightly as she tried to yell at him.
"Don't worry, baby. I know you had some reservations about me, but I'll make it feel so good. And it'll be perfect, cause Will will get to see that we are meant to be together."
Casey pulled out a knife. At the sight of it Brook started feeling faint. She thought she knew what was coming till she saw that. Casey smiled, "Don't worry, sweetheart, I wouldn't put this in you, but I think you know what will be ripping into you." He slowly cut her tight skirt up from the bottom as she began to panic. "Now, if you keep wiggling, I might nick ya."
Just at that moment, when all seemed lost, the door slammed open and in rushes in Abby...with a gun?!