The next day I was sore in places I didn't know could be sore. Horace had used me like he said he would. I had enjoyed it a lot, but still felt apprehensive about my status with all of them.
What woman really wants to become what I had? Even soiled doves had once been innocent girls.
I was surprised when I woke so late, but I couldn't help but be relieved that Horace and the boys were already out working. For such a momentous night, it seemed that today would be like any other for them. I tried not to think of what and who I would be doing that night.
I did my customary chores, mindful not to move too quickly; lest I cause an ache to sprout up and remind me of how many times Horace had taken me the night before. Even so, sometimes a sharp reminder would ghost up inside of me, a fleeting feeling of abused flesh that would settle into a hot ache for more.
I made lunch for the men, and when I realized they wouldn't be coming in, I took it out to them. Horace was easy to find. He was plouwing the fallow field in preparation for winter. He smiled almost shyly at me as I approached, and thanked me nicely for the food. He didn't say was anything much, but he did more to put me at ease than any pretty words he had said the night before.
I looked for Josh and Reuben, but couldn't find them where Pa had said they'd be, working on the fence by the pig pen, though I did see that it had been repaired. Usually when no one could find them, they were up in the loft doing heaven knows what. I tried not to see them too often. But, since that was about to change for me anyway, I marched into the barn with my basket of goodies a looked around for them.
I mounted the wood ladder that led above, and was heartened to hear some whispering. Once I had my head above the plank floor, I stopped. I couldn't speak because of what they were doing to each other.
Josh lay sprawled on a pile of loose hay, his head thrown back in the same expression of abandon that Pa had shown me so many times last night. What I couldn't comprehend was why Reuben was sucking and licking his brother's cock like it was a stick of horehound candy. I watched as Reuben bobbed his head up and down, taking time to bring his tongue around the tip of Josh's cock and then plunging back down, his nose touching the pale hairs at the base of his brother's manhood. He did this several times before I noticed that Reuben had his own trousers open, his dripping member standing hard and proud, jumping each time his brother moaned.'
Josh moaned as Reuben latched his swollen lips around his cock and suckled. As Reuben's bobbing and suckling picked up speed, Josh began to buck and thrust into his brother's mouth. Reuben stopped his head's motion, even while he pulled on his own cock, and let Josh use his mouth like Pa had my cunt last night.
I don't know how long I stood there, transfixed by what they were doing, the now familiar heat and damp beginning to pool in my now sodden pantalets. Suddenly, Josh pulled on Reuben's hair, jerking the darker brother up with a brutal movement. He said, "Don't. I want to fuck you since you get her tonight."
Reuben gave that lazy smile of his, before he said, "I think little sister wants to join us, Josh."
Before I could move, both of them had risen and they pulled me up by my arms into the loft. Reuben asked, "Did you like the show, little sister?"
"No... I ... I mean...." I stammered, but couldn't finish before Reuben was plundering my mouth as Josh deftly undid the remaining buttons on my dress. I hadn't got around to sewing back the few that Horace had torn off in his haste the night before. Warm afternoon air bathed my heavy breasts as both of the boys deftly stripped me bare. Reuben picked me up as if I was a rag doll and told Josh, "Lie down on that straw. We're both gonna get what we like the most. You know I like to share."
Josh scurried to obey Reuben, his expression wicked. "Fuck, I'll bet she's tight."
"Well, she won't be after you loosen her up, now, will she?" He laughed and swung me around in front of him, carrying me like I was a small child, my legs straddling his gut. His cock bobbed under me, slapping my soaking cunt as he took the few steps to his brother.
Before I knew what he was about, he lowered my bottom over Josh's face. I squirmed against Reuben, aware that my juices were smearing his stomach as I did. I was ashamed that such a private area as my fanny would be seen by anyone. I felt Josh part my cheeks further and I cried out. "No! Please don't!"
Reuben's grip tightened and I knew I would have bruises on my legs where he held me. He said, "Yer making little sister wet, Josh. I can feel her juices on my stomach. I can't wait 'til she feels we work our magic."
To my shame, when Josh's tongue snaked out and ran over 'that' spot, I screamed, but not in outrage. It felt so good, so forbidden. When he did it again, I writhed against Reuben, and the third time, when his tongue went past the ring of muscle into me, I screamed, "More! Sweet Jesus, I want more!"
Josh set about giving me more as he slipped a spit-slicked finger after his tongue. It was an aching kind of pleasure. I was too dry for him to go far, so he ran his other hand up between Reuben and me. He diddled me with his questing fingers and then brought the moisture he collected back up to my anus. This time two fingers slipped into me, and I couldn't help myself, I gave into the sensation as he fucked my backdoor, scissoring his fingers as he did. His tongue entered me again, and again, until I could feel the moisture on my skin. Josh finally broke away long enough to say, "I think that's enough. She's ready."
Reuben put me down, right on top of Josh. I rose as he pushed me forward. I didn't know what he meant to do, or I might have tried to run. As I leaned forward, I felt something much harder, larger and blunter pushing at where Josh' mouth had been only seconds before.
I tried to get away, but Reuben was firmly in front of me. He had taken his cock in hand and was milking it. It was hard, red and glistening at the tip. He said with a little smirk on his face, "Act like yer shittin' little sister. It'll go better for you."
I tried to push past the smirking bastard, but he caught me by my hair just as I felt the head of Josh's cock go past that ring of muscle and into my gut. He surged upward, and suddenly I was full of his cock, panting from the pain of it going in so fast. Josh said, "Goddamn! She's so tight I can't hardly move."
"Fuck him." Reuben commanded. "Get on your knees and ride him like you did that mare your whore of a mother stole when she left."
God help me, I did as I was told, the bruising presence of Josh's cock in my anus becoming an agonizing kind of pleasure. Josh bucked underneath me, pushing my face into the dripping end of Reuben's cock. I thought Reuben might expect me eat him like he had been eating Josh, and so I opened my mouth, my tongue out. "No, little sister, not right now, after I come, I just may let you lick it clean for me."
At that, he pushed me back towards Josh's supine body, and knelt between my legs. I thought he might be going to taste me like Pa had the night before, and the idea made me embarrassingly wetter. Instead, he spread my legs further, opened my nether lips and eased the tip of his cock past my entrance. Josh stopped bucking into me as his brother breached me.
I screamed from the pleasure and pain as he moved back and then sank further into me. I was so full, being fucked by both of them in each hole. I didn't know how I could stand the sensation. I thought I might go mad. They began stroking their cocks inside me, each one alternating, and each one driving inside me as the other pulled out and the other pushed in. I was so full of sensation, of shame, of dirty pleasure, tears leaked from my eyes. I was their whore, and they knew that whatever they did to me was allowed because they owned my body. That thought freed me to know that I had no choice, and so I began to seek all the pleasure I could from this strangely fulfilling situation.