We relaxed that Saturday evening, watching television with Mom and Dad. We did that both because we liked to watch television and because we thought it would allay any suspicions anyone might be developing from the way we were spending so much time alone with each other. After all, we'd told them we'd been studying—studying quite a bit more than they were used to having either of us do.
And, after that afternoon, neither of us felt pressure for a "study session." We thought, too, that we were pretty much on top of our math, so we figured we would need just one study session on Sunday afternoon (and, of course, one "study session" on Sunday evening).
As always, the parents called it a night and went upstairs around ten. Madison and I remained in the living room with the television on—saying that we were going to watch Saturday Night Live, or a least some of it. I reckoned that around 10:30, when they'd had a chance to get to sleep, Maddie and I could fool around a little—maybe even eat each other. Even though my need wasn't as pressing as it had been that afternoon, I didn't want to let an opportunity to go to waste.
Maddie seemed to have another idea. Not that she was averse to a little hanky-panky, or that her sense of timing was all that different from mine.
Just before I was about to suggest that she do so, she got up from the chair where she'd been sitting and sat down on the couch right next to me. I put my arm around her, and she snuggled close to me. But then, as my hand found and cupped a tit, she derailed my plans by asking, "How are we going to work this out, Mase?" But, after she asked, and, before I could answer her, she rested her own hand on my thigh.
"I guess we've got to quit carrying on with each other," I said, reluctantly.
"That would straighten things out," she replied. She paused; she didn't remove my hand from her boob. I didn't mention how good she was at "straightening out" one thing in particular.
I still hadn't answered her when she continued: "But I don't want to quit. I don't think I
can
quit—touching you and having you touch me, at least."
That admission sent a thrill through me. I made my own admission: "I don't want to quit fooling around, either. And I don't think I can, either."
We sat there in silence for a few minutes. I kneaded the tit I'd been cupping. There was no bra, as usual at home; I felt her nipple stiffen under her sweatshirt—which she also usually wore around the house because its loose fit meant Mom wasn't as likely to complain about what wasn't underneath it.
She said, "We can't keep fucking each other, though. We shouldn't have done it this afternoon. We said we weren't going to do that any more."
"I guess that was my fault," I admitted. "You looked so hot that I just had to fuck you."
"Well, I had something to do with it," she said. "You instigated it, but it isn't
entirely
your fault. You're hot, too; and I needed it. But we've got to stop."
"I guess it really wouldn't be a good idea for us to keep on fucking each other," I agreed—more or less.
"Oh, Mase," she said, "you know it isn't. We just can't be fuck buddies. We've talked about it. You're my brother. We're
twins.
Fucking each other is
so wrong.
" She squeezed my thigh as she spoke; squeezed and released, squeezed and released. She did that repeatedly, and threw in an occasional stroke.
"Yeah, I know," I answered after a bit. "It's really wrong. But it's so good!"
She snorted. "Don't say that, Mase," she said, looking me in the eye. "We can't say that it's good."
"Why not?" I asked, looking back. "Fucking with you
is
good! It's
really
good!"
She smiled up at me. "Yeah, it is," she agreed. "But we have to stop fucking, Mase. Even though I like it, too. Like you just said, it's
really
good! But we have to stop thinking that way."
I reached for her other tit with my other hand. "Who's thinking?" I asked.
She reached for a kiss, but before our lips touched, she said, "Not me. At least I'm not thinking about how good your cock feels when I fuck you." She reached for my zipper. She reached into my pants when she'd worked it down, and she added, "I'm too busy thinking about how good your cock feels when I suck you," as she pulled my boner out into the open.
We didn't fuck. But Maddie seemed to think coming when I tongued her was nearly as good as coming when I fucked her, and I thought coming into my sister's mouth was pretty good. It was sure better than jacking off, even if it wasn't nearly as good as coming into her pussy.
===||<>||===
I woke up earlier than usual on Monday morning and claimed the bathroom right after Mom and Dad finished, even before Maddie did. I heard Mom and Dad going downstairs together just as I was finishing up, so I didn't bother wrapping my towel around myself when I opened the door. As I might have expected, Maddie was waiting for me—wearing nothing but a huge grin. I grinned back and reached into her crotch to caress her slit as she grasped my already half-hard cock and stroked.
She moaned, quietly, so it wouldn't carry downstairs. Reaching up with her mouth, she pleaded, "Kiss me."
I did, and she pressed her naked body against my own. My fully hard cock throbbed against her. I stroked up and down her body and then, grasping her hips firmly, I pulled her against my swollen cock. "No, Mase," she said, after breaking off the kiss. "No. We can't. We don't have time to make out now."
"I know," I said. "I wasn't planning to. Not that I don't want to." I kissed her again; and reached to stroke her pussy again, as, not especially wanting to, I pulled away from her naked body.
"I'd like it, too, but there isn't time," she responded with a shiver as a finger found her clit. Then, smiling dirtily, she added, "Be patient. I'm going to suck your cock when we get home from school."
"Right," I said. "I'll get you off, too."
She smiled. "Deal," she said. "But no fucking. We've got to be more careful about the Pants Rule."
I smiled back. "Deal," I agreed, "we'll get together, but we can't fuck. " I gave her clit a last flick as she gave my cock a final stroke.
And we went about what remained of our morning routines.
===||<>||===
As we'd promised each other, we fooled around after school, very much as we'd been doing for a couple of weeks now. But we enforced the Pants Rule; we didn't fuck. We fooled around some more after supper, too, during our standard Monday evening "study session."
We'd reached an equilibrium, I thought. The week passed much the way Monday had gone, though Madison got to the bathroom before I did each morning. Always, she waited for Mom and Dad to go downstairs before exiting to my appreciative gaze. We'd mess around a bit there in the hall. Then, after school but before anyone else was home, we'd take turns eating each other to orgasm. When Mom and Dad watched their TV shows after supper, we'd study in Maddie's room. Generally, our afternoon activities meant that neither of us felt a lot of pressure to come in the evening—though we did spend some of that study time exploring each others' bodies, and we did get each other off during that session on Wednesday evening. Always, we observed the Pants Rule. I was pretty rigid about that. (So to speak.)
Maddie was adamant that we weren't going to fuck any more. I wasn't so
determined, but I figured that arguing with her might cost us the interesting activities we were sharing with each other—so I kept quiet. What I was getting wasn't all I wanted, but keeping that was better—a
lot
better than the nothing that pushing her too hard in a direction she wasn't sure she wanted to go might lead to.
===||<>||===
That Friday evening, Maddie went out to meet with Gene. But this time, she told me, she'd arranged it; and she borrowed Mom's car instead of having Gene pick her up. She was, she said, going meet him to tell him it was over. She left the house a little after eight, in a rather somber mood.
She hadn't said where they were going meet, only that she'd told him that they needed to talk. I couldn't guess what he thought of that. I would have known—even without having known how dissatisfying a girl found our relationship—that having her tell me, "We have to talk," probably meant I was in for the let's-just-be-friends talk. (Especially, I figured, if she didn't want me to pick her up to get together for that talk.) Not, I guessed, that Gene had ever really seemed to want more than to be just friends. Still, I was sure that he would find it painful.
So I wasn't surprised when she got home early—a little before eleven. Mom and Dad, as usual, had gone to bed; they were probably asleep by then. I was watching something on TV without really paying much attention, and I don't even remember what it was.
The garage door alerted me when Maddie got home. A minute later, she came in quietly, and I shut the TV off. I saw that she'd been crying.
She sat down next to me without saying a word—she sat right against me, in fact—on the couch. I put my arm around her, and she leaned into me, putting her head on my shoulder.
"I'm sorry," I said, not knowing what else to say.