The Letter Part II--More fun & games
After breakfast the next morning, Benny and her daddy listened to Maria's second tape.
Much like her first tape, this second tape too contained a naughty surprise of a most delicious sort.
So guys I have this wicked idea of what you two can do for an encore. Honey, do you remember that summer, my last one, the one after Benny graduated from high school and near the end of it I told you I knew a big secret about our darling little eighteen year old daughter. As you may recall, I told you I would spill her secret to you one day, when the time was right, but... well thanks to my little bout with cancer the time never was right for me to tell you... until now.
John looked at Benny who, although she was smiling, still looked a bit uncomfortable as she sat across the small table from him sipping on a glass of grapefruit juice.
John, you can pause the tape now to see if Benny wants to spill her secret or should I be the one. Just so we are clear Benny, darling, your secret involves that sweet little cousin of yours Peggy and what happened between you two that summer before you went off to college.
Looking at his daughter, she was clearly appeared anxious now, John gave her a smile. "So you wanna spill your secret to your daddy, honey or should we let your mom tell it."
After a brief pause, Benny answered quietly, "Let Mom tell it."
John hit the play button on the recorder again, yearning to hear about his daughter's secret.
If she told you John then hearing my version will only confirm what you already know, but you need to listen anyways because I have a secret of my own to spill to the both of you. So here is Benny's secret, mine will come later. One night during that summer when Peggy was coming over nearly every day, I woke up feeling thirsty and went downstairs to get myself a glass of water. As I passed our daughter's bedroom, it was real late, maybe one in the morning, I could hear the two of them giggling like a pair of school girls. Curious what was making them giggle so I crept up to her door and carefully, ever so carefully, pushed it open just wide enough to see inside the bedroom.
What I saw John was more than a little titillating. The girls were facing each other on the bed and Peggy and Bennie were exchanging some rather hot little kisses. I only stayed long enough to watch Peggy, quite eagerly I might add, tell our daughter how nice her kisses were. I... ahh... didn't want to stop watching as honestly the whole scene was, as I said earlier, quite salacious.
When his wife paused in her narrative, John glanced across the table at Benny, who looked at him with a sheepish little grin, before shrugging her shoulders and saying, "So we both had a few wine coolers that night and were feeling... curious I guess you might say."
Anyways I stole downstairs and got my glass of water but the truth is watching my darling daughter with my sweet little niece brought back some fond memories of when I was younger and used to play naughty with my best friend Lisa. This was before me and you started actually dating honey, but the honest truth was, considering how much me and Lisa used to play around and flirt around with each other so much, I thought for a minute back then I might actually had been a lesbian.
Giving her daddy a wide grin Benny said, "Wow, Mom a lesbian? I can't really imagine that... but I bet you can Daddy."
John said nothing in his defense, probably because it was deliciously true.
Now are you ready to hear my secret guys because here it is. I spent the rest of that summer flirting with my niece. Flirting and plotting that is. I just couldn't get the image of her and Benny kissing out of my head so yeah, I started flirting with my young niece and well, I must say, Peggy was rather... hmm receptive to my flirtations. In fact, I do believe the poor girl was in the process of developing a bit of a crush on her Aunt Maria and I did everything in my power to encourage said crush. Now let me say right here and now, nothing ever really transpired between me and Peggy but given enough time I do believe my plans would have borne some rather delicious fruit. Instead, she went off to college up north at Ferris State and then the stupid cancer hit me and well you know the rest but what you don't know is this... John, at some point, I was planning on fulfilling every man's fantasy... by allowing you to have a hot little threesome between me, you and your adorable niece. My plan was simple at this point... I would invite her up to the cabin here on some pretense, maybe even a surprise birthday party and then I would have thought up of some excuse why she was the only one that showed up. Basically then the three of us would have gotten a little tipsy and well, together we would have led Peggy down a much forbidden path, but only if she seemed willing to travel it. After all she was only a few months younger than Benny and a consenting adult so... Now for the best part, I would have considered it not cheating on your part if you fucked your niece, with my help, of course, and with me fully participating. In fact, I do believe it would have served the purpose of fulfilling two fantasies at once, yours of being with two women at once, I mean what guy doesn't have that fantasy, and mine of being with a woman and going all the way. So I am wondering if I could still make it possible would the two of you be interested in pursuing that same little fantasy of mine here and now.
"Wow is about all I can say," John said as he reached over and hit the pause button.
"Yeah, me too. So... ahh daddy would you have done it, you know, if Peggy was willing... fucked her with mom's help?"
"What do you think, sweetheart?"
"Well, Peggy is adorable and she has a great body, nice full sized tits... just a bit smaller than mine maybe and so I would say yeah, you would have fucked the shit out of her
"I plead the fifth," John said after a brief pause.
"So does that mean you don't want to pursue what mom was suggesting?"
"I didn't say that. Hit the play button. I mean, I'm game if you are."
Biannca hit the play button. Yeah, she was definitely game.
So obviously if you guys are still listening to this you must be interested so Benny, sweetheart, I still want to give your daddy that fantasy of being with two girls at once and since I am not here, well, guess what... once again you must serve as my proxy. I don't think it should be too difficult for you considering what I witnessed in your bedroom that summer before you went off to college. Now as far as Peggy is concerned, well I already took the liberty of speaking to her seriously a few weeks before I passed and was completely honest with her. She was a bit shocked at first, what I had been planning before the cancer screwed everything up, but as I explained things to her she eventually came around to the idea what I had been planning might have been fun. So with that in mind, I invited Peggy, on our very last phone call, to come up to the cabin the day after your 50th birthday today at around noon.
She said she would think about it, but I sensed in her heart she had already agreed... unless she changed her mind between now and then as it has been a few years. If she does show, she will be very much, just as you two were last night, under my control and the fun and games will begin. Just before dark, after you guys have had a nice bit of time for small talk and to enjoy a comfortable meal one of you go fetch the recorder and turn it back on, allowing me to be back in charge as I have a real exciting adventure for the three of you to embark upon.
The tape went silent again indicating Maria was done for the moment.
Benny reached over and clicked the stop button on the tape. After a brief pause, she asked her daddy, "So what do you really think?"
"I don't know. Your mother, Jesus, she and that wicked imagination of hers."
"Yeah, I always sensed she had a dark side."
"Do you think Peggy will show up? Have you two stayed in contact since your naughty little summer adventure all those years ago?"
