Warning: this story is a fantasy and details sexual behaviour that is, at best ill-advised. But it is pretend, so so long as you aren't a doofus, you should be ok. All sex-acts described are within ages of consent in the country it's written in (England, for the record).
This is also an introduction, and the next part is already conceived and can be out soon if I get some positive comments that anyone wants to read it!
For the third time in the last five minutes, Penny silently scolded herself and tried to focus on the movie on TV. Ok, so they were actually only step-sisters but she'd known Natalie since she was five, and the way she'd been looking at her across the sofa was all wrong. Apart from anything else, Penny had never looked at any girl that way – she may've been single at the moment, but she'd had a reasonable share of men at uni, and they'd had a reasonable share of her. But Natalie was fascinating her...
As she tried to ignore her desire to look, Penny's mind puzzled at why she was looking at a girl she considered a sister in such a weird way. Maybe it was how different they now were. When they met thanks to Natalie's dad and Penny's mum, they were five and nine, and both kids. Besides, Penny's actual sister was there too, and they formed a close family unit and were all basically kids. Sure, as they grew the fact that Penny and Hannah (her elder sister) were slim with glossy, black hair and pale skin, whilst Natalie was a more tubby kid with tumbles of deep, auburn hair, made it clear that they were not blood relatives, but they behaved as if they were. Now however, at 19, Natalie had very much grown into her body. Penny (23) and Hannah (25) were almost exact replicas of each other, and were often mistaken as twins at a glance. Penny had C-cup breasts to her sister's Ds, but also had an eye-catchingly spankable bottom compared to Hannah's more slender butt, but they were both a slim size eight and shared clothes between themselves. Natalie, though a similar height and still with a slim frame, was altogether more voluptuous. Though her waist was slim and toned, her hips flared out to a full, curvy bottom necessitating size 12 jeans, and despite her slender back, she'd grown big, soft, F-cup boobs. And it was at these, or more specifically the deep cleavage formed by the way she was splayed on the sofa, that Penny found herself staring.
Dragging her eyes once more from her sister's breasts, and trying to put the strange thoughts out of her head (What would Natalie look like naked? What did she like in bed?), Penny downed the remainder of her glass of white wine and poured both girls another, smiling at Hannah as she walked in from the kitchen. Both Natalie and Penny were staying with Hannah over the Easter holiday. All were single, as it happened, and were enjoying spending time together, shopping, drinking and spending time together. Resolute now, Penny gave all her attention to the movie and clamped down on her odd thoughts – she needed to forget all about this as she'd be sharing Hannah's spare bed with Natalie in an hour or two!
Hours later, Penny woke up. She'd always been a light sleeper, and slept even less well in unfamiliar surrounds. The clock-radio told her it was a little after 5am. Rolling over, she found herself looking again at Natalie. It was warm in the house, but modesty had led both girls to sleeping in flannel pyjama bottoms and tank tops. The pre-dawn light in the room was enough for Penny to see that Natalie had thrown back the duvet in the night. The younger girl was laying on her back, legs twisted towards her step-sister, with her head on one side. Her deep, even breaths made her big boobs rise and fall as she slept soundly. She seemed to be dreaming, though, as Penny watched her. Natalie was frowning in her sleep, and stirring gently.
Almost without conscious thought, Penny reached out with her left hand and carefully, almost imperceptibly, cupped Natalie's right breast. She left her hand still, to see if Nat would stir further, but when she didn't she slowly grazed her palm and fingers over her younger step-sister's chest, feeling the swell of the big breasts beneath the thin fabric of Natalie's top. As Natalie remained sleeping, Penny grew bolder, softly cupping and stroking the big, soft tits. Natalie's nipples began to respond, stiffening in the tight top, raising two hard points in the material. Penny assumed this was involuntary and continued to gently fondle her step-sister's boobs with her left hand, whilst her right slipped under the waistband of her pyjamas and began to stroke her own sopping pussy. She was scandalised and terrified almost as much as she was excited by how wet she was, somehow more turned on by this almost incestuous lesbianism than she ever had been by a boy.
Penny rubbed herself off in no time at all, turning her face into her pillow to stifle her moans as she came, and making sure that she didn't clutch at Natalie's breasts in her excitement and accidentally wake the younger girl.