This is the second part in the series with the final part coming out in a week or so. Please read the first part for context but here's a short recap. Chris is a metalhead high school dropout who's helping his cousin Nancy with her prom.
She introduces him as her boyfriend to make her ex jealous. Her best friend Ali knows the truth but decides to help sell the lie. Chris discovers he is hot for both girls and struggles with their advances. We pick up the story the next morning after they have shared a bed.
This story contains mild drug use, incest, and mild lesbian sex. All characters are over eighteen.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I woke up with another headache and a severe cotton mouth. The girl lying on top of me felt soft and warm in my arms. I smelt a familiar sweet scent coming from her hair near my face. I vaguely recalled having sex last night. Nancy's friend Ali had been giving me the eye all evening and I remembered going to bed with her.
My eyes stayed closed to shield against the blaring sun as I reached blindly for her face. Tilting her chin up I searched for her lips with mine. Kissing her nose and cheek before finally tasting her soft lips. I knew she was awake when her tongue slipped between my lips and we kissed tenderly.
My fingers stroked down her side skating over her silk nightgown. Her bare thigh was rubbing against my morning wood as my hand reached for her rear. My fingers stroked her cheek as the passion between us grew. I opened my eyes braving the sunlight to look at the beautiful brunette in my arms. But it wasn't her. My cousin Nancy had her eyes closed and kissed me hungrily as her hand reached for the back of my neck.
I pulled back panting slightly as adrenaline shot through me.
"Fuck Nancy what the hell!" I yelled in shock as the full magnitude of the situation hit me.
My cousin's eyes shot open with shock as she fully roused from sleep.
"Chris!" she said still lying entwined in my tight embrace.
I let go of her quickly and moved to the other side of the bed, wrapping the covers around my naked body.
"What the hell's going on?" I said my brain not functioning.
"Oh, Christ! Did we?" Nancy breathed as her hands reached for her lips.
I knew she could still feel the lingering ghost of our kiss because I could.
"No, no, shit I don't think so. I was with Ali last night," I spluttered hoping my rational brain would kick in soon.
"That's right I remember now. You and Ali fucked. It's fine Chris, we didn't do anything wrong," Nancy said laying on her back and breathing hard.
"Except kissing just know!" I groaned as the realisation hit me.
"It's fine that was just a mistake, you thought I was Ali," Nancy said through deep breaths.
I wasn't about to ask who she thought she had been kissing. Needing to get away from this awkward situation I rolled out of bed and quickly chucked on my jeans. My cousin stayed in bed staring in the opposite direction. I glanced at her and was struck by how gorgeous she looked. Her silk nightgown clung to her body, accentuating her perfect tits. The way her ruffled air was strewn on the pillow around her. The way her sweet lips were flushed with arousal. Simply gorgeous.
God, I needed to get out of here. I mumbled something about getting a drink and bolted for the door. I hadn't found the rest of my clothes and saw why when I reached the kitchen.
"Hey sleepy head," Ali said in a croaky voice. She was standing at the kitchen island drinking a pink smoothie through a plastic straw.
Her brown hair was in a messy bun with delicate strands framing her face. She wore my baggy Van Halen vest that drowned her thin frame. It looked hit as a short dress. From the side, the gapping arm holes gave me a tantalising few of her naked tits.
Her thighs were covered in my plaid shirt tied at her waist as a skirt. She looked like if Phoebe Cates from 'Fast Times as Ridgemont High' became a rock goddess. I felt my morning wood returning with a vengeance.
"Hey. I was wondering where they went," I said leaning against the door frame and folding my arms.
Ali looked down at the clothes which looked so good on her.
"Oh yeah. Sorry, couldn't resist," Ali said before her lips sucked hard on the straw.
I rolled my eyes as I closed the distance. Resting my forearms on the countertop next to her.
"Last night was fun," she said as I felt the soft skin of her arms brush against me.
"Was it?" I said trying to play it cool.
After my mistake with Nancy, my mind hand finally woken up and remembered every detail of last night. The way Ali's body felt on top of me. Her smell and the sweet taste of her lips. I grunted as she thumped me on the chest and turned towards me.
"That wasn't very nice," I said turning so we were a few inches apart.
Ali smirked and leaned forward to kiss me. Her hand snaked around to clasp my neck as I enveloped her in my arms. The image of my cousin Nancy lying in bed upstairs flashed in my mind. Moments ago I was kissing her just like this. With as much passion and heat as I with Ali. Her tongue flicked across mine before we broke apart.
"That's better," I said cuddling her tight before letting her go.
"What you up to today?" she asked before turning to make breakfast.
"I don't know. What are you offering?" I said pushing my luck a little.
I would love nothing more than to take her upstairs to repeat last night's performance.
"You'll have to wait for that. First, we need to go shopping," she said as she passed me some jelly toast.
"Huh?" I said confused.
"Well you can't go to prom in this, silly," she said pitching at her top.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
