So it was great to get back to school. Kayla and I made love my first night back. I couldn't wait to see her and she just attacked me when I got to her dorm room. It was even a little hotter than normal, but still not what I was used to. I actually spent the night in her dorm room because her roommate didn't come back that night from winter break. I was so happy. Classes started the next morning and that sucked, but so far I enjoy my professors.
On Monday I talked a while with Jessica about us having sex with my mom and she told me she hoped we could do it again, but she agreed with me that we probably shouldn't tell Denise.
I started hanging out a lot more often with Lyndsey also and I could tell she was really unhappy with her boyfriend. I just flat out told her to leave him and she asked me why I was telling her that. I think she wanted me to say that I wanted to be with her, which of course I do, but I just said because you deserve someone who makes you happy.
Ok so that weekend something crazy happened. Jessica and Denise went home to Denise's house and they got caught having sex by Denise's mom. So that was insane. They came back on Sunday and they both told me everything and I was so shocked and I could tell Denise was still very upset about everything, but when Denise left Jessica said that Denise's family actually handled it a lot better than Denise had thought they would. Still it was not good I guess.
During the next week I was with Kayla a lot in the evening, but when I came back to my dorm I was spending more and more time with Lyndsey. In fact a couple nights Denise wanted to sleep in my dorm room with Jessica so I slept in her bed in Lyndsey's room. The first night was no big deal. We stayed up late and talked, but nothing really happened. But the next night, which was Wednesday we ended up kissing and I slept in her bed with her.
We didn't have sex, but I did rub her breasts some and I got so horny for her, but strangely enough I was picturing being with my mom. It was so weird, but her breasts are so much like hers. So the next morning she had a serious talk with me and asked me how I still felt about her.
I told her that I still had feelings for her, but that I was dating Kayla. She asked me if she broke up with her boyfriend if I would give her another try. It was kind of adorable and I wanted so bad just to say yes, but I also wasn't sure. I mean I was really starting to have feelings for Kayla, plus I was a little afraid to be hurt by her. So I just told her the truth. She completely understood and even apologized for how she sort of sucker punched me with dating the guy when we were becoming so close. I explained that I understood that she was afraid she would upset her parents and she admitted that having her parents find out about Denise actually took away a lot of her fears. In fact she had even talked to her mom on the phone that week about it and Lyndsey had stoke up for Denise and admitted to her mom that she had also had feelings for girls before.
I was just amazed at how brave she had been, and I told her I really wanted to give us another try. She was so happy and she kissed me so unbelievably sexy that I just melted. It was so great, but I made sure she understood that I didn't want to get serious yet, and she was totally ok with that.
That night she promised me that she would break up with her boyfriend that weekend, and she did. I on the other hand didn't mention a word to Kayla until I was sure it was going to happen.
Ok I have to admit I am in a stage where I am just wanting to have fun and I want to leave all my options open. At the same time I know I have feelings for more than one girl, but I have no interest in making the same mistakes I have made, so I have no intention of getting Kayla and Lyndsey together for any threesomes or anything like that. Now that said, I had sex with Jessica one night as I was masturbating in our room while on the computer with some girls. She just came over and watched me, which I loved and soon we were having sex.
We both made each other cum and we even fucked each other with a double dildo, but the hottest part was what we talked about during sex. She likes it when I talk about my mom and so I did quite a bit. And she even talked about her mom just to get me excited. But then she asked me if I thought Denise and Lyndsey had sex. I actually was a little taken aback by that and said I didn't think so. But it seemed to really turn Jessica on to think about that. She even said she wondered if they were right now.
To be honest it does turn me on to picture them together, but at the same time I was really thinking it was a bad idea. In fact I wasn't sure I would date Lyndsey if she was having sex with Denise. Still the fantasy was hot and we had amazing sex thinking about other girls.
The next day Lyndsey and I decided to tell Denise about us. So when I was in Lyndsey's room that night we told Denise that we were dating. She hugged us both and said she was happy for us. It was awkward though and I had this feeling that Denise was a little sad, but by the next day she seemed better and I felt better too. All that week we hung out even more together and Denise seemed to want to be with us even more, so Jess of course was with us too. The four of us get along so great anyway, it was actually really fun. Though Denise does flirt a lot and not only with me, but she also flirts with Lyndsey right in front of me, but not in front of Jessica. So I thought that was weird.
One night I was talking with Lyndsey about Denise and Lyndsey told me that Denise crawled in bed with her one morning and said she was freezing and she snuggled up next to her to get warm, but that Denise started rubbing her breasts and Lyndsey told her to stop, but then Denise tried to put her hand between Lyndsey's legs. I was like numb listening to it, and so mixed up. I was incredibly turned on and yet part of me was horrified. I didn't know what to say and just listened.
Lyndsey told me that they sort of wrestled a bit, and that Lyndsey didn't let Denise touch her, but she admitted that it had turned her on and that she pictured me with my mom afterwards. I suddenly felt very guilty and almost told Lyndsey about Sydney and my mom, but I didn't. I wanted to keep my mom separate from now on and I could see that Lyndsey might be falling into lustful thoughts with Denise and my mom.
The next week we got caught. Denise walked right in on us. And we were doing a sixty nine above the covers and couldn't even get hidden before she saw us. I am so happy no one else was with her or saw us from the hall. We were into it so much we didn't even know she was there until the door was opening.
Denise didn't leave. I wasn't surprised, but I was a little pissed actually. She thought it was funny and I swear she was waiting for us to uncover so she could see us naked. The two of us were laying under covers as Denise sat on her bed and talked to us. Lyndsey was behind me and with her arm around me she put her fingertips on my clit and started rubbing me. It was very sexy, but I was afraid what might happen. I knew if I got too horny I might make the mistake of having sex with both of them.
Mostly Denise just talked about how she was happy for us, but she also asked us if we would come out to her mom so it would take some of the pressure off her. Lyndsey and I agreed we should and I was happy to not have to hide it from her, but was more nervous in the fact that Lyndsey's mother would know that I had made love to both her daughters.
Denise was thrilled and she jumped over to us and gave us a hug together, then she kissed us both on the forehead and then finally left us alone. Lyndsey and I had such amazing sex after that. Afterwards though Lyndsey started asking me about Kayla and I felt so uncomfortable. She admitted that she was nervous about losing me and I told her I wasn't going anywhere and that I wasn't going to leave her.
Still I knew what we had wasn't going to last forever and that sooner or later I was going to have to chose between them. It was insane that this was happening at all and Kayla was also starting to get inquisitive about Lyndsey.
The next weekend Lyndsey and I went to her house, but just for Saturday afternoon. We told her family about us and they actually didn't even seem too surprised. In fact Lyndsey's mom said as soon as I walked in the door with her they had their suspicions. We had a good talk and Lyndsey and her mom cried a bit, and hugged and it was a good day for us. They actually invited us to spend the night and were sad when we didn't, but I was happy to leave.
Nothing much happened the next week although I did have sex with Jessica again. She came back from Denise's room after I had been chatting on-line and I was so horny. She could tell right away too and she started undressing in front of me and I just attacked her. We slept in the same bed that night and when we woke up for class we kissed for the longest time and neither of us really said anything until later that day. Then she asked me if I still had feelings for her. I felt like such a bitch, because I of course did but told her we were better as friends. I could tell she was really hurt and I regretted having sex with her and told myself I would try not to ever again.
The very next day I had a talk with Denise about Lyndsey. She was talking about how they almost kissed that morning and I told Denise I was glad they didn't. She was surprised at first and then asked me if I was in love with Lyndsey. I told her I wasn't in love with anyone right now, but that I thought I had a future with Lyndsey and I wasn't sure if I wanted them to have sex together. Denise then asked me if I still had sex with my mom. It was like she was saying if I could so it then she could too, and I suddenly realized she was completely right.