A totally fictional story, with fictional characters. This is the chapter 2 of the story. Main characters are Carlee, who Jeff had babysat, when they were younger, they are 4 years different in age, they reconnected after Carlee had become an adult. All characters are over 18. Proofed with software, and self edited, so I already am aware I likely missed something. Comments on story are always appreciated.
Carlee, Jeff, Gina and Peggy...
My life was now a delightful mess, I had a hot MILF fuck buddy that was available to fuck me on my lunch break, I also have her hot young daughter that I had babysat when she was young, now she is through High School and nearly 19, and has confessed her love to me. I was still confused, but my feelings for her were deeper, and different from what I have ever felt for a girlfriend.
It was a little harder for Carlee and I to get together with her mom and I on the same work shift. To make things even more complicated, I had not let on to Carlee that her mom and I were regular sex partners. She was OK with the fact that she had caught us in the act once, but I don't know if she thought it was a one time, or even an infrequent thing, it just did not come up that we were abusing each other almost every work shift on breaks.
My relationship with Carlee was different, we seemed to be always horny, and wanting sex, but we also just wanted to be together, and as much as possible.
Our sex was so over the top even when it was brief, or in an uncomfortable, and sometimes public place. We would go places together I would pick her up, and we would go to a park to hike, and would end up fucking in the woods, or sometimes after an outing, we would park somewhere and have old-fashioned teenage car sex.
I was back home at my parents house, but with us being neighbors it was difficult to not be seen together excessively. Peggy had hinted that her little girl had a crush on me, but Carlee did not think she suspected we were lovers, based on what she told her. She told me that her mom kept telling her, "don't over do things, you don't know if Jeff is having fun hanging with you, or just putting up with you, he may not share the same feelings you have for him, you may still be the little girl he used to babysit, not the grown up sex crazed teen you have become since you graduated from High School."
We found a solution that we figured would work for a while. Since her mother, and her were both home during the day, Carlee would come over to my place to play video games, when my parents were at work, at least that's what we told our parents anyway. My mom thought it was really sweet of me to spend time with the little girl I used to babysit. I couldn't believe she still considered her that little girl, I was worried her eyesight was fading.
I was being overworked sexually, and I came to realize why married guys that were cheating tended to neglect their wives. I am a young guy, and had trouble maintaining the sex life I was having with both Carlee and her mom, I imagine an older guy might lack the stamina, and would have to neglect one partner.
We almost got busted one day, Peggy came over to my house to check if Carlee was there, she is like most teens with her phone, does not always know where it is, or if it is charged etc, so she could not reach her. Carlee and I were at my house playing a game. We had made up a sex game, it really did not have a formal name, lets call it, Top This. Simple rules, we would challenge the other one to find a new place to, or a new way to have sex. I have tried to nix my backyard pool area, we did not have a solid fence around the pool, it is white vinyl slats, only 6 ft. We have tried to make it more private with vegetation, but it's just not that private, in fact it is hardly private at all.
My mom used to lay out and take her top off for a better tan if I was not home, once when I was away, she got the nerve to remove her bottoms, and my dad noticed a neighbor boy about Carlee's age, Jimmy, peeping on her, he was standing at his bedroom window cock out, his balls resting on the sill, and jerking off to my mom. She is pretty hot, but to me, she is mom, how can I judge him though, since I have been fucking Carlee's mom at work.
There has not been much skinny dipping since the peeper incident, it's a shame because it's fun, and daring. I had done it there with a girl on a dark warm night once but that is about it. Problem is, it is a nice but older neighborhood with a lot of two-story houses, we have several adjoining our yard that have a direct view, especially from their upper floors.
It was a hot day, and I had been swimming, and Carlee my sexy little rebel, was sunning nude, she is not very modest, and has at the least, exhibitionist tendencies. She had shed her bikini for a better tan, and was trying to talk me into shedding my suit. Well, after swimming a few laps, her gorgeous naked teen body caught my attention, she knew what she was doing. She was laying on her back with her legs open putting lotion on herself, first on her breast, getting herself excited, then working between her legs. She was sitting up, so I could see her breast, and her pussy, when she worked between her legs, she made sure to get her slit.
I could not resist anymore, I just had to assist in rubbing lotion all over her. Well, I might have got a little overzealous, and rubbed too much in some sensitive places. I should have stopped when she started cooing, and my fingers were getting wet, and it was not lotion. She let me know it was too much by reaching for my trunks, well actually my cock. I resisted her pulling down my trunks, I really did not think it was a good idea us both getting naked out there, I knew what it would lead to, us fucking in broad daylight. She was relentless, and managed to pull them down far enough to allow her to grab my cock, then she grabbed my ass to pull me close. Once she had my cock in her mouth I put up the white flag on the nudity, and I pulled off my trunks for her. I was getting my cock sucked in my backyard in daylight. Us both being naked, I should have just let her finish me off, and dressed, but by then I wanted more, more of her and more of the thrill of being out there naked with her.
I got her to let go of my cock, by offering to make sure her backside was covered well too, she loved me rubbing her butt, and so did I, what man wouldn't like rubbing a hot teen's naked ass. Still resisting us fucking out there, and thinking we could go inside for that, I started at her feet and up her legs, spent a lot of time at her ass, between her legs, that was when my cock became totally hard again. When I got to her upper back, my cock was pressed against her slit, and felt my knob touch her wet opening, and soon, when I felt it line up, I could not help but push it in her vagina, she liked it there. Liking it there as well, my reluctance was replaced by lust, so I figured we might as well just fuck, get it over with, and then dress.
I fucked her from behind, I fucked her from the side, I finished by fucking her from the front, with one of her arms around my neck her other on my back reaching for my naked ass. I just completely blocked out the fact that my naked ass was in view for any neighbors that might be looking our way.
What we were not aware of was, is that Carlee's mom Peggy, who was looking for Carlee, could not get us at the front door. She came around to the pool, and she tried getting us from the gate, just as I was busy pumping a nice load of cum on Peggy's cute little girls perfect breast. Peggy did not give up, tried knocking, and made a vocal inquiry that we finally heard, and that put us in a state of panic. I was able to get to my trunks, and get them on right away, and was heading to the gate because it was not locked, while hoping she did not just try it, and come in. I thought I gave Carlee enough time, but string bikinis take a little longer to put on, then a pair of trunks.
As I headed to the gate, I answered Peggy with, "Just a minute, that gate is probably locked, and it sticks, I will get it."
Well, I thought things were under control, but Carlee did not have enough time. After I let Peggy in, and turned around, Peggy and I now had a good the view of a topless Carlee standing there, hands over her tits, and poorly tied bikini bottoms barely covering her. She was a short distance away, just across the width of the pool, and I was wondering if this was our day of reckoning, or if Carlee could come up with something to keep our carnal relationship secret from our parents?
Fortunately, she thinks pretty quick on her feet, and said, "Hi mom! No, I am not sunning topless in front of Jeff, I know how your mind works. Jeffy used to be my babysitter, that would be just weird. I had white lines around this new bikini top, because it covers less than my other ones. I told Jeff I was going to remove it, and you know he is a gentleman, and turned away first, so I could put lotion on that area. I did not want to chance getting any on it, and ruining it, so that's what was happening when you got here, great timing mom."
I was impressed, she does not call me Jeffy anymore, just when she was little, she was trying to sell it that things haven't changed with us.