"All right, Julie. Spill!" Ellie said as soon as we sat down at the table.
I'd called Ellie the day my sister, Donna, left to go back to school. I had some big news I couldn't wait to share with the woman who'd introduced me to lesbian intimacy.
"So, if I tell you this, you have to keep it a secret, okay?" I said, setting my coffee on the table and taking a seat.
"Ooh!" Ellie said. "Now I'm even more intrigued. Your secret's safe with me, Julie!"
"OK. Good! So, you know much I changed after we got together, right? I was the shy girl consumed with tennis 24/7 and you were the sexually confident girl who loved tennis but also loved making love?"
Ellie laughed. "That's a hilarious description, but, yeah, I get it. And yes, you totally came out of your shell. After your first orgasm I could hardly keep my clothes on around you!"
"Well," I said after taking a sip, "Donna noticed it right away. I mean, she saw the way I dressed was different and even the way I carried myself was different."
"That makes sense, though," Ellie said. "She
is
your identical twin, right?"
"True," I said, tossing my head to the side so my auburn hair would be out of the way. "She knows me better than anyone. So, as we got to talking, she asked about whether I'd met anyone and I, well, told her about us!"
"That's great!" Ellie said. "I think you told me that she'd had sexual partners?"
"Right. But just guys," I said. "She got really intrigued when I described what it was like to make love to a girl."
"I'm sure she'll make a fantastic lesbian lover, since she's just like you!" Ellie said.
I paused. Here was the secret part.
"She is," I said, coyly.
"Huh?" Ellie said.
"She is a good lesbian lover," I said.
"Are you fucking kidding me?" Ellie said, her eyebrows lifted high.
"It happened so quickly," I said. "We were trying on that sexy underwear you and I bought, and we started touching each other, and before I knew it, we were making love!"
Ellie sat there, stunned. "You fucked your twin sister?"
Maybe I'd gone too far.
"Do you think I'm awful?" I said, crestfallen.
Ellie shook her head. "No, not awful at all. I actually think it's incredibly hot. I just got this picture of you, and someone who looks exactly like you, eating your pussy, and it turned me on!"
"Whew!" I said. "That's a relief!"
"Shit!" Ellie said. "Julie and Donna - lesbian twin lovers. I love it!"
We both laughed.
"Yeah, after having a grand total of two lovers, I'm pretty much sold on having sex!" I said. "Which brings me to my question."
"You said on the phone that you had a request," Ellie said.
I nodded. "I love having sex with women. But you and Donna have both experienced sex with guys and I, well..."
"You'd like to know what it feels like for a cock to enter you?" Ellie said.
"Pretty much that," I said, smiling. "This is a little awkward but... you said your brother Peter is really special."
Ellie smiled. "Oh, he is. My big bro."
"Do you think?" I asked. "I mean, I'm wanting my first time with a guy to be gentle and special - not just some rando cock, you know?"
"Do I think that Peter might be willing to be your first?" Ellie asked, frank as usual.
"It's probably presumptuous of me to even ask," I said, now embarrassed.
"Well, you're going to think this is sort of funny, but I talked to Peter about our experience and showed him your picture."
"You did?" I said.
Ellie nodded. "He thinks you're super hot. I even told him you had never had a cock before and he told me he would absolutely love to make love to you."
"I can't believe that!" I said. "Wait, I didn't realize you and Peter talked about that kind of thing. It's a little odd for a brother and sister."
Ellie smiled. "I guess it's time I got totally honest with you as well."
"Okay," I said, hesitantly.
Ellie looked around to make sure no one could hear us. "The reason I know Peter would be a good first time for you is because he was my first time."
"What?" I said, my jaw dropping.
"Uh huh," Ellie said. "When you said you'd had sex with your sister, I finally realized it was going to be okay for me to tell you my secret. I've had sex with my brother - lots of it. And loved every second!"
I laughed. "Wow! Aren't we a couple of pervs?"
"Maybe in some people's minds," Ellie said. "But fucking my brother has just deepened my love for him."
"Like with me and Donna," I said. "I love her now more than ever!"
Ellie and I just stared at each for a bit, adjusting to this new normal.
"So wait," I said. "I thought you told me Peter goes to Florida State. How would that even work?"
"Turns out," Ellie said, "that he's on quarter break too. He just got home last night. And since my folks are out of town, we have the whole place to ourselves."
"Oooh!" I said. "Sounds like maybe last night was pretty hot?"
"Oh yeah!" Ellie said whispered. "I'm still tingling from having Peter's cock explode in my pussy!"
"Does that mean you guys want me to come over?"
"Absolutely!" Ellie replied. "Peter just wanted to make sure you knew about us because, well, he'd love to have a threesome together!"
"Wow!" I said. "My first guy and first threesome. Sounds fucking great, though I must admit I'm nervous too."
"It'll be great, Julie. I promise!" Ellie said, laying her hand on my arm.
All afternoon my nerves grew. I still considered myself to be a total newbie when it came to sex. Would being with a guy be as good as with a girl? Peter sounded great, but I'd never even met him before, and now I was going to jump into bed with him and let him fuck me?
I tried to push my anxiety away by concentrating on what I was going to wear. I wanted to look and feel sexy without advertising it. I put on a red sheer bra and thong that Ellie and I had picked out. The mostly see-through lacy fabric held in my D's but showed my ruddy areola and nipples pretty clearly. The thong covered my wispy red bush, but just barely. The fabric was so thin that it outlined my hairy pussy and lips perfectly. I finished it off with a sleeveless red contour-shaping zip-up mini-dress that accented my figure, but left a little to the imagination.
I stood in front of my bathroom mirror to make sure my appearance would attract Peter. Long red hair brushed out, bright blue eyes all made up, Big boobs, flat tummy, long legs smooth and bare, and sexy high-heeled shoes. It was the best I could do.
When I arrived at their house, Ellie answered the door and ushered me in. She lived in Santa Monica, not too far from me. The house was beautiful, with a sunken living room that looked out on a large patio and pool, surrounded by bamboo and bougainvillea - giving it a jungly sort of look.
"Come on in!" Ellie said. "Peter, this is Julie."
Peter had come up beside Ellie. Okay, so his picture did not do him justice. About six feet, dark wavy hair, and an open, clean-shaven, face. Big muscular arms and chest. Basically a hotty!
"So great to finally meet you, Julie!" Peter said, giving me a hug.
Okay, those arms felt really strong.
"Nice to meet you too, Peter!" I said. Maybe this wasn't going to be so bad after all.
We stepped down into the living room and what I hadn't seen before was an attached dining room. It was all lit up with candles with soft music playing from some hidden speaker.
"Hungry?" Ellie said, offering me a seat in between her and Peter.
I smiled at the inference and sat. "Always!" I said.
Peter disappeared to get the plates while Ellie poured a cabernet. Apparently her parents were pretty lax when it came to wine in the home.
"Cheers!" Peter said, lifting his glass to clink with ours. "To a fun evening!"
The pair had gone all out. Filet Minion, asparagus, and roasted potatoes. It was great. We made small talk and I learned a lot about Peter. He seemed like a great guy.
After dinner, we left the dishes and Ellie brought us into the spacious living room, where we sat on a big couch, setting our glasses on the coffee table. I sat on one side, and Peter and Ellie sat next to each other. Someone had lit candles in here. The sunset outside, combined with the glow of candles inside - made the place look downright romantic.
"Julie, I just want you to know that you're in charge here," Peter said, putting his hand on Ellie's bare thigh.
She also wore a mini-dress, white, with black high-heels. Peter had on khakis and a nice boat neck cotton shirt, unbuttoned halfway down his hairy chest.
"And if I didn't already say it," Peter continued, "you are one of the most beautiful women I've ever laid eyes on."
I blushed.
"Thank you, Peter. I'll admit I've been pretty nervous," I said, putting my hand on Ellie's other thigh. "You know you'll be my first guy."
"I do," Peter answered, smiling warmly. "But as Ellie can tell you, a first time can be wonderful."
"And you've got both of us to love on you," Ellie said, moving a strand of red hair away from my face.
I lifted my hand to Ellie's cheek, leaned in, and kissed her lips. She was wearing a mango-flavored lip gloss which I recognized and loved.
"Mmm, mango!" I said, breaking off the brief kiss.
"I know you love it!" Ellie said as she turned to face me, kissing me back, both of her hands going around my neck.
I felt her tongue push against my mouth and I opened, allowing her full access. Her tongue felt warm and wet as it glided across my tongue and over my teeth. I felt a surge of excitement between my legs.
Ellie and I continued to make out, her hands caressing my arms and shoulders. My hands went around Ellie's back and wandered down to her ass. Her dress was short enough that my fingers touched the satin of her panties. I squeezed and massaged her butt cheeks, and felt her move closer to me in response.
