[Hey there Literotians. Well that took way longer than expected. Had a bunch of real life stuff get in the way but the story is now totally, finally complete. It'll definitely help to read part one, but I won't say it's strictly necessary. Once again, we've got horrible people doing wonderful things to each other. Or is that the other way around...
In any case, expect to see (read) some masturbation, voyeurism, incest, light bondage, oral, girl/girl, reluctance, first time, and group sex.
If you were wondering why the first part ended up in the Incest/Taboo category, well, this one should certainly help explain why.
As always, everyone here is over 18.
Good times.]
*****
We're wrapped around each other, skin to skin. Tongues and hands. Cock and cunt. I keep pumping as hard as I can - just driving and driving and driving. Nothing comes. The woman beneath me moans and reaches. Writhes as I pound her.
Who am I fucking? Unattainable Kate? Ardent little Ashley? Chaste Kristen? Unbelievable Emma? Am I fucking my little sister, Em?
The girls keep shifting beneath me, one then the other. All of them at once.
I feel a hand on my shoulder.
I need release so bad. Driving so hard I can barely feel anything except...
Someone is shaking me.
Come on.
Come on.
Come on!
*
I woke up with a million dollar hangover and a ten cent dick.
I was so spent, I felt flaccid from top to bottom. Covered in sweat and... well, probably all sorts of fluids. I looked at my crotch, so sure it had just been engaged in something elicit. But no. Just a dream. My little man looked how I felt - joyous, remorseful, tired, energized. Embarrassed. Emboldened.
Someone was rubbing my shoulder. I sat up.
Kate. My high school best friend. My all time number one crush. My best friend's girlfriend. The woman I'd fucked just... hours before, if the clock in the cabin was right. Fuck.
I groaned.
"Ohhhh, Kate. I can't do this right now. My head is killing me."
She smiled at me patiently, like an overburdened mother. Full of love and exasperation.
"I need a ride back to shore," Kate said, "Before everyone else gets up."
"Oh. Oh, yeah. No problem. Look...I...I'm sorry. I shouldn't have..."
"Listen," Katie interrupted me, "I've had a lot of sex in my life. Some ok. Some bad. Nothing like what we did. Nothing even close. So there's lots of stuff you get to say now, but sorry isn't allowed. Understood?"
I smiled.
"You want me to get Ashley?" I asked.
"No, she told me she wants to stay a bit longer."
"Oh. OK. Just let me just get some clothes on and we can get going."
*
It took a couple of pulls for the dinghy's engine to turn over. The shout of combustion seemed like sacrilege in the soft pink of early morning. I almost shushed it out of habit.
Kate stepped into the little boat like someone who usually stays on shore. She smiled as she settled. The engine was so loud, we had to stay quiet. Kate's blue eyes seemed brighter than I remembered. Her arms and shoulders loose. I was a bundle of nerves, all coiled up and haphazardly wrapped. Someone had done poor wire work on me. My plumbing felt fairly fucked, as well.
I throttled the boat back to silence as we edged toward the shore. Just a low hum and the dripdrops of the water - the accusing tweets of the early birds.
"Look, Kate. Katie, I really... Last night... That wasn't what I wanted. I really am sorry."
"You tell me you're sorry again and I'm punching you right in that perfect penis," Kate said.
"Sorry."
Kate made a show of making a fist.
"You know I had fun. You just don't want to admit it," Kate said.
"If it was so much fun, why are you sneaking out so early?"
"I'm pretty sure you know why."
I stared off across the ocean. The sun was barely up, dripping yellow over the calm cool water. Gulls called in the distance. I wanted... I wasn't sure what I wanted.
"You're worried about me," Kate said, "Don't. Maybe the thing I liked about you most last night is that, for once, you weren't worried about me. I'm fine. I'm not going anywhere. Well, I'm going to CVS. But after that, not anywhere."
"Are we..."
"We're fine. Nothing more, nothing less. You don't owe me anything. Except, well, maybe another go round? On a bed this time? I promise I'll make it worth your while."
Kate leaned forward on the boat and kissed me. Pressed her lips to mine. Then sat back. Nothing more. Nothing less.
We bounced against the dock and I tied the boat off. Kate stood and started to step off.
"You and Ashley, eh?" I asked.
Kate smiled, sheepishly.
"Just... Not a lot. Just roommates," Kate said. She shrugged.
"She seems like a nice girl."
"That girl is anything but nice. If you haven't seen it by now, you will soon."
"Don't think I'll be seeing much more today. Maybe ever."
"Oh please," Kate said, still turned halfway on the dock, body twisted away, eyes right on mine, "You keep acting like last night was some sort of... I dunno. Catastrophe. I hate to break it to you - people had fun last night.
You
had fun last night. Acting all guilty isn't fooling anyone. If anything, it's probably pissing people off. I can promise you - somehow, someway - even if you can't see it, someone is gonna get things going again. Because everyone wants to. Yourself included."
I smiled, despite myself.
Kate pressed forward. "I know you think you're gonna go back to the boat and, I dunno, help people pack up and leave. It's not going to happen. Things are gonna... ramp up again. Trust me. And that's ok. Have fun. Go ahead and get yours, Jay Bird. Whatever. Just promise me something."
"OK?"
"Well, two things. The first is, y'know, what we talked about. Me. And the bed. Boston isn't so far from DC. You can even take the train."
"Yeah. I mean, of course."
"But here's the other thing... Look, I saw you and Emma. I see how she looks at you. How you look at her."
"Kate, I..."
"Don't. Just don't. We
all
see it. There's nothing wrong with it. OK, no, there's a LOT wrong with it. I'm not gonna judge. Everybody goes through phases, or whatever. Hell, I have a friend at college who still trades 'favors' with her older brother."
I cocked my head.
"No, not Ashley. Jeez. Anyway, look, I'm not gonna tell you how to live your life. But Jason. You can't fuck her, OK? You just... you just can't."
"I never..."
"Little Emmy wants you really bad, Jay. And I think if you would just be honest with yourself for once you'd see you really want her, too. You can't. I know, I know. I'm like, the last person Em wants you to listen to. But I'm saying this for her sake. You could really fuck her up, like, in all senses of that word. You could destroy her. Her whole life. Everything. You need to be the big brother here. You need to keep her safe."
"Yeah. No, I... Yeah. I know. I just... OK. Thanks Kate."
"Oh no," Kate said and wiggled her bum ever so slightly, "Thank you."
*
Emma was waiting for me when I got back to the boat, sitting on deck and squinting in the still-early sun.
"I knew your magic sword would slay the wicked witch," she smiled. She grabbed my cock as she said 'magic sword.'
"Oh," she whined, "he's all sleepy. Well don't worry, I have ways to wake him up."
"Em," I placed my hand between the two of us, "Let's... Can we talk for a sec?"
I lead her downstairs to her cabin. Kristen was already up and in the shower. I imagined all of us would need a good washing after last night. I shut the door, both on the girl and on my urge to sneak a little peek. I mean, I'd already seen the buxom beauty naked, held her enormous and wonderful breasts in my hands. Did I really need to sneak a look at her through the tinted glass and steam of the shower? Apparently yes, yes I did.
Emma sat on her bunk, staring up at me. I sat next to her and held her hand - both for support and to keep it out of my crotch.
"Look. Em..."
"Don't say it," Emma said, "Just don't."
"I have to. This... it can't go on."
"That bitch! What did she say to you?"
"Nothing I didn't already know."
I felt Emma's hands try to escape mine. I heard her start to sniffle.
"I can't... Look. Imagine it. OK? We're together. Now, what do you do when Mom and Dad ask if you're seeing anyone? Or when they ask to meet him? What about when your girlfriends want to hook you up? Or ask about that mystery guy you're seeing? You'd have this secret life... your whole life. And that's if everything works out perfectly."
"I'll make new friends," Emma said. She was crying now. Really crying. The shower shut off in the distance. I hardly noticed.
"And when they ask how we met?"
"I'll lie," Emma said.
"Your whole life will be a lie," I said, "Our whole lives... What if we had kids?"
"So what?"
"What would we tell them? This is your Dad? This is your Uncle?"
"You don't want to be a Duncle?" Emma asked, she laughed a little. Then she started crying even harder.
"I love you, JJ," she said, "I'm not... stupid. I know I'm not supposed to. But I do."
"I know. I love you, too."
"Then WHY?"
"Because I love you."
She shoved me off the bed. Pushed me out of the cabin. Slammed the door. Her sobbing echoed all over the boat.
*
I found Sam above deck. He was on one of the benches on the prow, shirtless, wearing pilot-style sunglasses. He looked like an American Eagle ad.
"Emma?" he asked.
"You heard?" I sat next to him.
"The fucking Ukraine heard."