Dalton immediately set to work trying to bring Dinae over to his side. He had heard numerous stories of a better or more attractive man taking a woman easily with one love-making session. They both seemed oddly calm, however. Leam was standing back with his arms crossed, looking at them both and Dinae was merely removing her clothes since they were back at Dalton's place. He kissed her deeply, inserting his tongue. He could not help but turn to observe Leam's reaction to him kissing Dinae like that. It was too serene, almost cocky.
`Huh?` He wondered. He was feeling a bit lesser, just by the fact that he was paying more attention to the other guy out of performance anxiety than the girl. She identified that easily and addressed it.
"Where're you looking?" Dinae laid back and spread her legs tantalizingly before him. Her shaved pussy was there, waiting for him and her soft, perky breasts were just waiting to be touched and cupped as well. He climbed on top of her and began fucking her. His cock was bigger, he was stronger, he was bigger. There was no way Leam could compete. He also fixed his behavior and kept his attention solely on Dinae, even if his thoughts drifted.
`Dammit, I'm losing... The simple fact that this encounter is happening at the best of that guy is throwing me off and getting into my head. Get over it!` He inhaled deeply and started fucking the Beastfolk like they were the only two people in the room. After that it began to feel a lot better for both of them. He could tell. Dinae hugged him over his shoulders and moaned happily, her hips moving with his thrusts. He could feel her tightness. He was expanding her cunt so even if Leam had fucked her, Dalton was still shaping Dinae to his cock in the end.
Leam gulped, watching the large, curved cock push into Dinae's unprotected pussy. He could get deeper, and fill her even more. It made Leam anxious. It was a blatantly bad idea. He had no reason to believe Dalton would not make Dinae fall in love with his cock. It was a good cock, better than his. He felt regret and fear, but still wound up letting it happen. He was watching it as it happened and he got irrationally hard at the thought that the moment his love was permanently taken from him could be this one. Very easily, Dinae could decide that Leam wasn't good enough and Dalton's big dick was for her. Leam sat back and began to stroke himself while watching. His breathing became ragged even though he was not one of the two participating.
`What do I even have... This was a mistake.` He whined internally.
`I can't live without Dinae!` With that thought he came quickly.
Meanwhile, Dalton was still going strong. He stopped thrusting quickly and moved on to short, hard ruts as he felt himself getting close. Dinae squealed and muled, her back arching and her voice escaping satisfyingly as she came over his cock. Juices slicked his long, thick member as he pulled out one last time, then thrust all the way in. He cringed, thinking to much of her to spring it on her.
"You... Want me to pull out?" Dalton asked respectfully.
Dinae seemed to be thinking. Everything was put on hold with Dalton holding back inside of her. He was surprised to see her turn to Leam.
"Uhm... It makes sense to have a kid with Dalton right?"
"W-what!?" Leam gasped, holding his head in his hand.
She realized what she said. "I don't mean that I don't want your kid, too. What I meant to say is, what if I have Dalton's kid? Then I can have a kid with you after."
"That's... A little outside what we talked about Dinae. Do you like Dalton?" He felt confused and very close to being broken. Dalton felt very good about the direction things were going. Then things flipped with her answer.
She shook her head. "I like sex with Dalton and he's strong but I actually like you a lot more as a man. We got a lot of history and I think you're a bit better personality-wise. Especially now."
"I'm sorry?" Dalton gasped.
"What?" Dinae looked up at him. She was innocently fucking with both men at once, whether she realized it or not.
"He brings something different to the table." She stated pragmatically.
Leam felt conflicted. "It means I'd be taking care of and supporting his kid, then, Dinae."
"I guess so." She shrugged
"I mean... I only really wanna do it if you're okay with it."
"No." He gritted his teeth, balling his hands into fists for being so weak.
"You wanna do it, but you wont if I ask you not to. There's no 'wanting to do something only if I'm okay with it.' You either are or you aren't."
"Uh..." Dalton felt very caught in between.
Leam's face became bright red as he pointed. "Dalton! I'm begging you to cuck the shit out of me right now! As bad as this sounds... Make her pregnant with her first child so I got to wait."
"A-aren't you just forcing yourself now!?" Dalton asked, still incredibly hard and incredibly desperate to cum, somehow.
"No!" Leam announced.
"I genuinely want whatever Dinae wants, no matter what. That means if she asks for it I'll even beg on my knees for you to take her from me. As contradictory as this sounds, this is how we're going to work now. Humiliate me, fuck my girl, cuck me and steal her from me permanently, Dalton." Leam gulped. He was asking so eagerly for something that was so awful. To his surprise, Dinae moaned and tightened, triggering Dalton to cum inside without being able to stop himself.
"He's filling me up..." She mewled, rubbing over her womb affectionately.
"So exciting." Once she was done she climbed off of Dalton and walked happily over to Leam while she was still leaking down her thigh. She straddled his lap.
"Can you do me a favor, love?"
