This story was written for the following prompt: "You probably should have realized the intimate connotations of giving your Wolf Girl friend a collar. Even if it was clearly part of a joke, she's still awfully flustered."
Contains: dominant/submissive, a woman with wolf ears and tail, a bit of mild petplay.
I probably apologized about a dozen times over the course of the party, and each time she waved me off, muttering it was nothing while not meeting my eyes. I felt genuinely bad about getting her so flustered in front of everyone, especially the other wolves who had teased her mercilessly. The humans laughed it off after a couple minutes and probably forgot about the whole thing, but there was obviously a level of context to my gift that her mumbled explanations didn't get across. Having come by myself, I ended up staying late as everyone else filed out in little groups, going out to their cars or calling rides. I started clearing party debris off the kitchen table as a small way to help out, and by the time I was nearly finished, I realized the birthday girl and I were the only ones still in the house. She came in to dump a bunch of ribbons and shredded wrapping paper in the trash, then turned around and started when she noticed me.
"S-Sam!" She put a hand on her chest, her fluffy ears unflattening as her surprise faded. "Oh, you scared me... I thought everyone was gone."
"Yeah, I just thought I might... help out." I wiggled the paper plates I had been about to throw away. "Sorry to startle you."
"No, it's fine," she said, and added under her breath, "Not the first time tonight..."
"And, um, sorry again about the collar, it was really thoughtless of me..."
"It- It doesn't bother me," she muttered, looking away from me as another blush rose to her pale cheeks.
"No, you know what?" I said, suddenly determined to make this right. "Hold on a second."
I went to the living room and searched through the mess of presents, finding the black leather dog collar I had presented her with. Clutching it in my fist, I hurried back to the kitchen and held the wretched thing over the trash.
"Renno, you keep saying it's fine, but I feel like I did something stupid that really hurt you. So, please forgive me, if you can."
Before I could drop the collar, her hand closed around mine, soft and warm. I stared at her in surprise as she tried to find words.
"Sam..." She squeezed her eyes shut, sighing as the pinkness returned to her cheeks and she released her grasp on me. "Sam, I appreciate the gesture. But... I don't... You... You didn't know what you were doing, okay? It was just a joke. It wasn't what I thought it was. Don't throw away a perfectly good collar."
"Oh... what did you think it was?" I asked, curious despite my relief. "I didn't get most of the explanation. Just that it's an... intimate thing."
"It's not much more than it sounds like," she muttered, looking down. "Put a collar on a wolf, what does that mean? A dog. And a dog mumble mumble mumble."
"Sorry?"
"And a dog has an owner," she repeated louder, blushing furiously. It took me a moment to process what she meant.
"Oh.
Oh.
Like they... Oh." I was pretty sure I was blushing too now. "Is that... a common thing?"
She shrugged slightly, still staring at her feet. "More than humans would think. So when you gave it to me, for a second I hoped..."
She trailed off. After a few moments, she clamped a hand over her mouth. A small whine escaped her as I stared at her now bright-red face.
"You 'hoped'...?" I said slowly, not quite believing my ears.
She shifted her hand enough to whisper, "That was not the word I meant to use."
I knew she was in a molten crucible of embarrassment right now, but I had to know. I couldn't live without asking the question. "Is it... inaccurate?"
It felt like my heart stopped until she, very slightly, shook her head. Then I just felt faint.
"Oh." I swallowed hard and realized I could think of absolutely nothing to say to that. My head spun as the extent of what she had just revealed became apparent. She... She thought of me that way... and she was into that kind of thing... and she wanted me to be her... and I... I mean I always thought she was cute... really fucking cute... and we were both single...
I sat on the edge of the kitchen table, finding that my heart was pounding. What the hell could I say? There were so many things fighting for my attention, half of them conflicting and the other half requiring far more coherent thought than I was capable of at the moment. What...
There was a slight pain in my hand. Looking at it, it turned out to be the buckle of the collar pressing into my skin as I made a tight fist. The collar. The thing that had started all this. Maybe... actions spoke louder than words...
I held it out to her, managing to mumble, "If you- really want to..."
It was a moment before her trembling hand reached out to take it. She slowly raised it to her neck, giving me a nervous, questioning look. I nodded, my mouth dry, and she fastened it on herself, quivering uncontrollably. The next thirty seconds felt like thirty years as we just stared not quite at each other.
"Wanna watch Netflix?" I blurted.
"God yes," she breathed, relief rising off her like steam. I stood up too quickly and followed her to the living room, throwing everything in my mind on the backburner as she fumbled with the remote. We both needed time to process what had just happened.
She ended up picking a documentary about the pack dynamics of wolves - the four-legged kind. I would have found it incredibly on the nose, but it was already half-watched. Maybe this was just something she was interested in. No subtext whatsoever. Especially not with how she squirmed a little bit on the couch whenever the deep-voiced narrator talked about the relationship between the dominant and submissive members of the pack.
I wasn't sure how long it had been by the time I found the will to speak again. As some wolves raced through the snow on screen, I cleared my throat and muttered, "Um... so... what... what do you want me to do, exactly?"
In my peripheral vision, I could see that she was still staring straight ahead when she answered. "Um... Just be... in control. W-Whatever you want... me to do... I will."