Author's Note: This is an edited version of a story I wrote and posted on Literotica in 2016.
*****
Chapter One
Mark was almost surprised at how happy the couple seemed. As he sat at his lunch table, he watched the guy and girl laughing and holding hands across their table. Other than watching them at lunch every day, Mark didn't know the pair. Just the previous Friday, they could hardly look at one another. Now they acted as if they were the only people in the cafeteria.
"Maybe I'm too much of a cynic," Mark thought to himself. Either way, he was glad the couple had worked things out.
Forgoing his contact lenses, Mark had spent the previous couple days wearing glasses and a baseball cap. After everything that had happened to him on Monday night, he longed for the anonymity. He also worried about the mystery girls from the movie theater. They could be in the dining room with him that very minute, sitting at the next table and joking about how they had mercilessly teased and tortured him.
The hat and glasses didn't provide much of a disguise, and Mark was well aware of this. For the time being, it was the best he could do. At least he had survived the entire day Tuesday without anyone asking him to strip naked or jerk himself off in public. By current standards, that had to be at least a minor victory. His privacy was to be short-lived, though. In just over six hours, he was to report to the sixth-floor study room and prepare for his evening with Monica.
Mark's time with Monica was to be the second of three nights he was to spend doing whatever his hosts told him to. Lucy, his ex-girlfriend, had referred to his subjugation as 'nights of service.' It was all part of an arrangement the former couple had made after Janice, Lucy's roommate, caught Mark spying on Lucy in the shower. Mark had spent Monday evening entertaining Emily, and he would finish his week on Friday with Alison. For now, he had to prepare himself for Monica, his former high-school classmate.
Ironically, most guys would have killed for an evening with Monica. She was tall with a curvy yet toned body. Her jet black hair and big blue eyes were the perfect complements to her soft tanned skin. Her face was perfectly proportioned with striking features and nary a blemish. She was so much more than beautiful, though. She was smart, driven, and carried herself with unmatched confidence. Only the boldest of men would dare proposition her. Less confident suitors wouldn't even bother.
As nervous as Mark was about his reunion with Monica, he was just as concerned about his own stepsister learning of his subservience. Mark's stepsister, Alicia was best friends with Monica's sister, Tina. Monica did promise Mark that she would never tell the two younger girls about his evenings of service. Even so, he wasn't sure he could trust Monica.
Hoping for a few extra minutes to review his notes, Mark had opted to head out of the cafeteria a little earlier than usual. Since he wouldn't have much study time after dinner, he intended to take advantage of any available time. However, just as he was about to get out of the cafeteria, he saw Brooke making her way to his table.
"Seen any good movies lately?" Brooke joked throwing her backpack on Mark's table and helping herself to a seat.
"Oh, hi." Opting against responding to her taunt, Mark continued gathering his belongings. "Sorry, but I was just leaving. I have to get to class." He started to get up from the table.
"Oh well," Brooke said. She leaned her chair back on two feet while holding onto the table's lip for balance. "You're going to want to sit down for a minute and hear me out. This is important."
"Important?" Mark stood behind his chair awaiting Brooke's explanation.
"Please," Brooke said motioning for Mark to sit back down. "I really am trying to help you."
Mark looked around the dining area as he considered Brooke's request. He still wasn't sure what the young blonde wanted from him and why she was even mixed up in his arrangement with Lucy and Janice to begin with. "I only have a minute," Mark said as he reclaimed his seat.
"Thanks for gracing me with your presence," Brooke responded waving her hands in the air sarcastically.
"I'm sorry," Mark relented. "It's just that I have to get going. You know what I'm dealing with this week, right? Well, I still have class work too."
"I do know what you're dealing with," Brooke answered sternly. "I also know you played a pretty big part in digging that hole."
"I'm sorry," Mark conceded. "Really. Please, tell me what you needed."
Brooke paused momentarily before continuing with her planned debrief. "There's something you need to know," she said. She dropped her chair back to all four feet and leaned forward across the table.
"Something else?" Mark queried. He leaned back slightly retreating from Brooke's advance.
"Yeah," Brooke answered. "It's a pretty big deal too."
Mark settled in curiously.
Brooke continued. "Remember the other day when I told you Janice would get tired of you, that she would move on to someone else?"
"I do," Mark said. "That's good. Right?"
"I guess so," Brooke returned. "It's good in a way. At the same time, do you really trust her with all those videos?"
"I don't know," Mark answered curiously. He leaned into the table. "It's not like I have much choice. Do I?"
"What if you did have a choice? Would you take it?"
"Sure. I guess so."
Brooke looked around the table to make sure no one was listening to their conversation. She extended her torso across the table toward Mark and continued with her story. "This all started with my father," Brooke said.
"Your father? What does your dad have to do with this?"
"I'm trying to tell you," Brooke continued. She explained to Mark how she had first met Janice. Brooke reminded him that Janice used to belong to a sorority but had been kicked out. It had all started a few years back when Brooke's father, a former professor, had visited the sorority house to assist a couple of students with a homework assignment.
A group of the sisters, inclusive of Janice, had agreed on a wager as to whether one of the younger girls could get the professor naked. The girl whose challenge it was to strip their teacher succeeded without much difficulty, and her exploits, of course, were all caught on video.
At first, Janice had used the video to leverage better grades for herself and her sorority sisters. Then once the girls finished the professor's class, Janice continued using the video against Brooke's father. She didn't ask for large sums of money, at least not at first. She just used the professor for her own amusement having him perform stunts such as wearing a thong to class and taking more incriminating photos of himself.
Eventually, Brooke's father had transferred to another school, and Janice moved on to harass other boys. Janice was finally kicked out of the sorority for humiliating their president's boyfriend.
Mark was shocked. He leaned back in his chair and rubbed his hands furiously through his sandy hair. "So your father had to quit his job?"
"He did," Brooke said. "Then when Janice found out I was going to school here, she sought me out."
"You? What did she want with you?"
"She wanted me to help her find another guy," Brooke said. "Janice told me she was going to contact my father again unless she could find someone else she could 'teach a lesson to.'"
"Teach a lesson to?" Mark asked. "What does that even mean?"
"I don't know exactly," Brooke answered shaking her head. "I do know that she has a serious problem with men."
"But, I don't understand," Mark returned. "I never even met you before Janice caught me...you know."
"It wasn't supposed to be you," Brooke said. "The plan was to drill the hole in the wall and spread the word around one of the fraternities. When the frat boys showed up, Janice would record them spying on the shower."
Mark's jaw dropped open, and his eyes expanded. "How did she end up catching me, then?"
"Well, you beat the other boys to it," Brooke responded. "I never even had to tell anyone. You found the hole on your own."
Mark was flabbergasted. Somehow, he got caught up in Brooke's sting operation. "So what do we do?" he asked.
"That's why I'm here," Brooke said. "We need to get on Janice's computer and erase all of her pictures and videos. We need to get the videos of you, of my father, and of anyone else she's blackmailing."
"But how?" Mark asked. "She used her phone to take the video."
"You're the computer guy," Brooke reminded Mark. "Janice is in class now. I have the key to her room and her computer password. I was hoping you could help me."
"But if the files are on her phone..."
"They're on her computer," Brooke interrupted. "I was in her room the other day when she was organizing them. Trust me. They're all on her laptop."