Nice Guys Finish Last
Reluctance/nonconsent Story

Nice Guys Finish Last

by Aimenigmaclic 18 min read 4.8 (6,800 views)
femdom romance bitch boy novella love story drama
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

Chapter 23

A warm sensation filled my soul as her words ran through my head.

"I love you..."

How could she say it with a straight face? How could she stare at me with such conviction?

"I've always loved you," she continued, showing no change in her serious demeanor. "Since we were young, I've been pushing you away. I've been trying to protect you. But no matter how hard I try, I can't keep you out of my life. I can't deny that I love you."

Suddenly, I came to a stop. "You've been protecting me?"

Julia pushed a strand of hair that had fallen out of her bun behind her ear. Appearing slightly less confident, she explained, "I didn't think I deserved to be with you... I didn't want you to suffer..."

My heart pounded as I noticed the innocence coming from her. She wasn't manipulating me like she used to when we were younger. And as I reflected on the way she had always acted towards me, how secretive she was, how cryptic she was... it all started to make sense.

"How would I have suffered?" I asked, hoping to learn what she had been withholding from me for so long.

"My mom always wanted me to be with you. She wanted me to end up marrying you because she knew you'd probably become a doctor, like your father. She wanted us to rely on you, like she's always relied on other men for money."

"She... what...?"

"That's right; She never cared about you or your family. She never cared about me either. All she ever cared about was herself. I just thought I'd never get rid of her... I thought I'd always be stuck with her... until..."

"Until...?"

Once again, Julia looked deep into my eyes. And with the most serious look I had ever seen on her face, she continued, "Until... I gave her the rest of my money in exchange for her walking out of my life forever... That's why I'm no longer bound by her chains. That's why I can no longer afford tuition. But most importantly, that's why I was able to confess my love to you today."

I was frozen solid, and yet, my heart felt like it was going to burst out of my chest. I could see the conviction in her eyes, and I wanted to believe her, but after everything that just happened, and everything she had just explained, I couldn't help but wonder if she was just having some sort of emotional reaction.

Showing no sign of wavering on her feelings, Julia then shared some more details about her difficult upbringing. I felt sorry for her, of course, learning about the trauma her mother brought her. However, she seemed to have no intentions of seeking empathy. She simply wanted me to know why she had taken certain actions up to this point.

Although she wasn't seeking any comfort, I couldn't help but notice the coldness in Julia's eyes as she explained the lack of love she had received. Unfortunately though, I was still unable to see how she could seek comfort from me in the midst of her darkness.

Though she wasn't searching for affection, I could hear the pain in her voice from her next statement.

"I love you, but I wanted to prove to her that I didn't need you..."

Nodding my head, I responded, "I think I understand..."

"I wanted to prove to her that I could stand on my own two feet, and not have to rely on others like she did. I felt that unless I could do that, I was no different from her..."

Seeing the struggles she had been dealing with for so long, my heart started to ache for her. "But Julia... you

are

different from her..."

"I am," she agreed, allowing the pain to disappear as she was suddenly overcome with an aura of calmness and relief. "But I was wrong about one thing... I can't do this on my own... I can't do this without you, Phillip..."

Those words... I don't know what it was about them, but they caused my heart to skip a beat. I suppose I just never expected anyone to say them to me. I never thought of myself as anything but a nuisance in Julia's life.

"But how?" I asked, watching her become emotional. "How could you possibly need me? What could I ever provide you?"

Surprisingly, she threw her arms around me and embraced me in a tight hug. "You've always been there for me," she whispered into my ear. "I could feel her body shaking, as she continued, "I just need you to keep being there for me... as long as you can... I'll take whatever I can get..."

I never understood it, but it was moments like this that I felt the closest to her. Despite all the sex we had, despite her practically touching every inch of my body, it was always the little things, such as hugs and simple smiles, that made me feel a real connection.

Wrapping my arms around her waist, I held her tightly as I buried my head into her shoulder. "I want to be there for you," I whispered, feeling her calm a little.

She then pushed herself away, not far enough to break the hug, but just enough so that she could stare into my eyes. "You need me too," she said, showing a more serious glare. "We should at least help each other for the time being..."

Despite the conviction in her eyes, and the serious tone in her voice, I still couldn't help but feel like I didn't offer her anything. However, despite my insecurities, I could sense how emotional she was underneath the determined exterior she was wearing.

I still had many questions, and even more insecurities that I needed to deal with. However, as I looked back into her deep brown eyes, I felt, for once, she was even more vulnerable than I was. I couldn't even imagine what she was going through, now that I had a brief glimpse of her past.

Instead of burdening her with my own doubts, I chose to simply enjoy the moment by allowing our hearts to be vulnerable together. I squeezed her tighter, allowing her to rest her weary soul against me. She held me tight, and we didn't speak a word until our restless minds could finally enjoy a moment of peace.

We held each other for what felt like an eternity. I even started to notice the sun setting from over her shoulder. But as the light started to fade, signaling an end to this tumultuous day, I knew deep down inside that our emotional journey was only beginning.

***

She needed me...

I still couldn't wrap my head around those words. How could it be that the woman I once considered my childhood bully was now dependent on me?

As I thought back to my upbringing with her, I couldn't help but be reminded of the pathetic little boy I used to be. And as I thought about the course my life had taken, I started to wonder if I had even changed at all.

Perhaps I was right. Maybe I turned out to be just as pathetic as I was in high school. Sure, I had gotten further with women than I ever expected, but at the end of the day, Tina left me for another man. Who was to say Julia wouldn't do the same once she was no longer dependent on me?

It brought me back to the question I had always asked myself. Do nice guys finish last? Unfortunately for me, that question hadn't been answered yet.

In a strange turn of events, after spending my childhood hating Julia, not only did she confess her love to me, but she also came to my rescue once she realized Tina was cheating on me.

Of course, I could have taken this as a victory. However, no matter how courageous Julia was for me, it didn't change the fact that I was a loser and an idiot for allowing it to happen in the first place.

Yes, Julia came to my rescue, but who was to say she wouldn't have done the same if she were the one in Tina's shoes? I appreciated her confession. I appreciated her admitting that she needed me. However, the more I thought about it, the more I realized that I was the one that needed her...

Regardless of the hypothetical scenarios, there was one thing I couldn't deny. No matter what happened in my life, Julia was always there. She had seen me at my best, and she had seen me at my worst. And no matter how bad her life would get, she'd always find a way back to me.

***

Eventually, we wound up back at my apartment. I still wasn't over the heartache of being left for another man. No matter how much I appreciated Julia's actions, it still hurt knowing that I wasn't good enough for someone that I was giving my all to.

Julia was patient with me. She sat quietly as I continued to sulk in my own self-deprecation. She handled me delicately; a far cry from the woman I knew in high school.

"Why are you being so nice to me?" I asked, breaking the silence. I looked into her eyes, and she looked into mine. "Is it because I'm spiraling?"

She shrugged her shoulders but didn't change her expression. "How did you expect me to treat you?"

"I don't know," I said, shaking my head. "This is all so much for me right now. And I get what you're saying about your past... but you almost don't even seem like the same person anymore..."

Kneeling in front of me, Julia placed her hands on my lap while I sat on the edge of the bed. "I'm not going to hide behind the excuse of my mother for treating you so poorly," she explained in a flat tone. "I abused used you, just like she abused me.

"I'm not a perfect person, but I'll try to be better... I know I shouldn't have been dishonest with you. I know I shouldn't have put that abuse on you. I'll try my best... not to be that crazy woman anymore..."

Suddenly, I was left staring at her as a strange feeling entered my heart. I didn't know what it was at the time, but something that she said just didn't sit right with me.

Staring deeper into my eyes, she tried to figure out what was going through my mind. "I apologize, but... I understand if you're hesitant to trust me... I promise I'll try my best to never be that person again..."

Unfortunately, though my brain was working at a hundred miles an hour, my mouth couldn't quite articulate what was on my mind. I would begin to speak, but no words would come out. Julia was left making her own assumptions about what I was feeling.

"I'm sorry for dumping all this on you at once, especially after all you've been through today," she said, getting back up to her feet. Then, as she took a seat in my chair, she made a suggestion. "Why don't you get back to work on whatever you were doing before? Being productive always made you feel better in the past."

Shaking my head, I explained, "That's okay... I had some stuff I needed to go over... but I don't feel like it right now... I have too much on my mind..."

"I understand... I was just making a suggestion. You're smarter than me, so I trust your judgment."

After listening to those words, I needed a moment to gather myself. Hearing her compliment me in such a matter-of-fact way was still something I just couldn't get used to.

Shrugging my shoulders, I looked back at her with a curious face. "Well... what do

you

want to do?"

She didn't even have to think about it for a second. "I just want to stay here with you for now..."

I paused for a moment. "That's not what I meant..."

"Oh...?"

"I meant... What do you want from here on out?"

"From here on out?"

"Yeah... You said you're no longer bound by the chains that once trapped you... So what do you even want in life now that your mother is out of the picture?"

Julia didn't even hesitate to give me yet another jarring answer. "I want you to be my boyfriend."

Of course, I reacted like any nervous and pathetic boy would. With my jaw on the floor, I asked, "What?! Just like that?!"

"Well, yeah... but that's only contingent on you. I understand if you're not ready to be my boyfriend yet, considering you just went through a breakup. As for me... I no longer see any purpose in wasting time, pretending I'm not devoted to you."

"Oh..."

"So, that's what I want," she affirmed, looking at me as if she didn't just make another extremely bold confession. "What's most important to me is that we help each other out. But in the meantime, I also want you to be my boyfriend."

I was left struggling over my own words. I usually needed time to think about such life-altering moments. Hell, in the past, Tina didn't even let me decide. She was the one that let me know we were dating.

Of course, I had so much compassion for Julia. After everything she and I had been through together, I was practically drawn to her like a moth to a light. However, that didn't mean that I was over my insecurities, and it definitely didn't mean that I was ready to rush right back into a relationship after my previous one crashed and burned.

Just as I was about to come up with a response, Julia spoke up and advised me to take some more time.

"I know you feel obligated to give me an immediate response," she explained, oh so correctly. "I know how you are, Phillip. You probably want to think this over, and I agree with that. You should take as much time as you need so you can come to a well thought out conclusion."

"Julia... it's just... this is all so sudden... And you know I've always had issues..."

"I know, Phillip. That's why I'm telling you to take your time. Don't give me an answer until you know what you want out of life. Like I said before, I trust your judgment."

Feeling guilty, I looked down at the floor for a few seconds before returning my gaze to the woman in front of me. "Can I ask you something, Julia?"

"What is it?"

"I know I've always been there for you... but how could you possibly think I'm good enough for you?"

Suddenly, the expression on Julia's face changed, as if she were worried about me. "Did you not believe the stuff I told you earlier?" she asked. "Remember how you've shown me love that I've never experienced anywhere else?"

Although I was starting to believe her sentiment that I had shown her the type of compassion she had always longed for, I couldn't help but let my insecurities creep into some of the more physical aspects of our relationship.

After taking a second to gauge the differences in our appearances, I dropped my head in shame before confessing, "That's not exactly what I was talking about..."

She perked up now that there was yet another issue of mine to deal with. "Oh? Then what did you mean?"

Growing red, I expressed, "I just... I always pictured you with... someone... more attractive than me..."

Although I was avoiding eye-contact, I could tell she was staring a hole right through me. Then, she surprised me with her unfazed tone. "I think you're attractive..."

"Yeah, but... wouldn't you rather be with someone that wasn't so short? What about all those tall guys on the swim team?"

After appearing to ponder my question for a moment, Julia simply shrugged her shoulders. "I like that you're short. It's really cute. And about the guys on the swim team... I'm just not interested in any of them..."

"Really...?" I asked, hopefully wishing that she was telling the truth.

"Yeah... I guess when I really think about it... I've never considered myself attracted to them, because I never wanted to be with them."

Suddenly, I was suspicious. "Are you being serious?"

She shrugged her shoulders once again. "Yeah... I mean, you can ask them... The entire team knew I was in love with you, including the guys."

My eyes grew wide with shock, and my body started to tremble. "It wasn't just Valerie and Marissa?!"

"The rest of the team knew that I was in love with you... but only Valerie and Marissa knew the details of our sex life..."

Although her explanation made me feel better, it brought up yet another thing I was insecure about. "Speaking of our sex life," I started, growing red all over again. "Am I even good enough... in that department...?"

Julia stared at me curiously before blinking twice. "Good enough? Did you not find it exciting?"

My eyes grew wide as I suddenly felt the need to defend myself. "That's not what I meant?!"

"Then what did you mean?"

"Well... it's just... you're so attractive... and you do so many kinky things to me... It's like.... what do I even bring to the table?"

A confused look came over Julia's face. "Phillip... I like having sex with you... I wouldn't have done it so much if I didn't enjoy it."

"Yeah, but... you always had to be in control because I didn't know what I was doing... And I'm so small..."

"But I like all that," she interrupted, causing a warm sensation to fill my body. "Besides, you're not that small... I just kept saying that because it turns you on..."

"No, it doesn't!" I reacted in a defensive manner, even though I could feel a slight hard-on building up in my pants. After collecting myself, I was forced to put my head down again as I brought up something I never wanted to talk about. "You can tell me the truth; You probably enjoyed having sex more with people who weren't as small and pathetic as me..."

An awkward moment of silence passed as my own words rang through my head. I was just waiting for Julia to confirm what I knew was true. I was never good enough for her. She would only ever be settling for me.

Then suddenly, that magical voice of hers broke through the tense air with one of her most shocking revelations yet.

"I've actually never had sex with anyone except you," she said, causing my eyes to almost pop out of my head. She then stared at me and smiled. "That's right, Phillip... I'm a virgin outside of you."

The warm sensation inside suddenly felt like a fire had been lit in my heart. Adrenaline rushed from every inch of my body as the words she spoke echoed throughout my brain.

"I'm... the only one... you've ever had sex with...?" I asked, stuttering over my own words.

"Well, yeah..." she answered, still appearing unbothered. Then her face changed as she realized what was so worrisome in my mind. "Oh... do you think I care that you've had sex with someone else, but I haven't?"

I looked down in shame, twiddling my fingers. "Yeah, I guess... it's like... we're not even..."

"That doesn't bother me at all," she explained, still looking unfazed. Then, with a slight smirk, she continued, "If you really want us to be even, then I guess that means... I'll have to have sex with your ex-girlfriend..."

The fire inside me was still lit, but it suddenly felt like an explosion had erupted as well. And although we were having a serious moment, I embarrassingly had an erection out of nowhere, as inappropriate images appeared in my mind.

"I'm just joking," Julia explained with a slight giggle. She then sat next to me and patted me on the shoulder. "I was going to tease you about being a little pervert, but I guess I should leave that all in the past..."

Immediately, I looked up at her, feeling flustered. I didn't know what it was that I wanted to tell her, but she had made yet another comment that just didn't feel right in my heart.

Before I could put my confused thoughts in the words, Julia spoke up again. "If you really think about it... you've technically done stuff with Valerie and Marissa as well," she explained, making me feel even guiltier. "But you know what? None of that really matters to me."

"It doesn't..."

She shook her head. "Of course, not... As a matter of fact... I kind of take blame for any of that even happening..."

Raising an eyebrow, I asked, "How so?"

For the first time in my life, I noticed Julia blushing a little. She even looked away from me, like she was a bit nervous.

"I don't know..." she said, almost as if she were hiding a smile. "You probably never would have done that stuff with them if I hadn't pushed you... It makes me wonder... what would have happened... if I had just trapped you all to myself from the very beginning..."

As a little smile started to show, I immediately became red, and also noticed my boner getting even stiffer. It had been such a tumultuous day, and Julia was showing her emotions for the first time, but even so, there was something about her that always aroused me...

She quickly shook it off before going right back into her more serious state. "I would never want to trap you though... But I guess in the end... it's nice knowing that you experimented with other women but still preferred me..."

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like