"No, no, no...Whatever you have in your head, definitely no. Don't even think about saying it out loud." I groaned loudly and began pacing across the room.
"You should listen to me before you decide that it sucks," he followed me like a lost puppy.
"Dude! In the past couple of weeks, I spent every conscious moment with you or thinking about you, sometimes even complaining about you. Do you think I trust you? Definitely no. No, no, and no!" I argued with him.
He grinned that stupidly beautiful grin, and I knew I was melting.
"Ugh! Didn't I say no? So, shut it. Stop that whole cute face thing." I said, exasperated.
For some reason, his grin got bigger, and he started walking toward me. He took hold of my wrist and pulled me to him in a tight hug. I could feel his smile against my neck as he began kissing me.
"Fine! Alright, what is it?" I sulked as I gradually began to cave in. Instead of answering, he kept grinning and took out his phone.
"I'm sure I took a picture of it," he said, scrolling his phone, looking for something. Taking this as an excuse, I moved away from him and subtly moved away from him to keep my sanity in check.
"What do you mean? You took a picture of me?" I all but yelled and ran to him with the hope of grabbing his stupid phone and destroying the evidence.
"It hurts my heart to know how little you think of me, sweetheart," he smirked and quickly pecked my lips.
"No, stay away from me until you show me the picture. I want to know what it's about. Are these pictures of us in compromising positions? Are you going to blackmail me?" I questioned him apprehensively.
"Okay, my little nerd, what exactly are you reading in your free time." Wes looked up from his phone and chuckled.
"What free time? We keep having sex all the time," I said absent-mindedly. As soon as the words came out, my eyes widened with embarrassment.
Wes chuckled and kissed my forehead, "yeah, that's true."
He finally found what he was looking for and excitedly pulled me closer to him. It was a picture of a paper that looked like a list. It was wrinkled, but I could distinctively see the bullet points and recognize that it was my handwriting.
"Do you remember the list? In a way, this list brought us together," he said with a smile.
"What list?" I looked at him, confused, and looked at the phone again.
"Remember the first time we met? It was a party at Delta Pi's house. We kissed for the first time, and I bet with you that I could make you come in five minutes. I then ate your pussy, and you came hard."
"Oh my God! Did you just say that all out loud?" I groaned in embarrassment and moved away from him with the phone tightly held in my hand.
"It's necessary for the story, sweetheart." He continued, "you left your bag behind, and there was a list in it. I can't believe you forgot all that!" He took my hand, holding his phone, and pulled me to him.
"My bag?"
"Ames...," he said.
"The list? There was a list in the bag?"
"Babe, you're repeating yourself again..." he continued.
"The list...that list...Oh my God! That list! I made the dumb list before forcing myself to go to that party that day." I gasped as I suddenly remembered that list.
A month ago, I made that list when I decided to take control of my life and change it for good. I was an invisible nerd back then (not that anything changed now, except for the sexual labyrinth I have created for myself), so I wanted to make a list of things that my old self would never dream of doing. Sort of a bucket list.
Gosh! I was so naive back then. The first one on the list was to go to a party, and I went to that party. That was where I met Wes, and the rest is history.
"Give me the phone, Wes." I grabbed the phone and looked at it again.
"Go ahead, read it." He encouraged. When I wasn't reading aloud like he wanted me to, he got impatient, grabbed the phone from my hands, and started reading aloud.
I scanned through the list.
He must have read it already. After all, he took a picture with his phone. I wouldn't be surprised if you memorized it by now, just to make fun of me. But at the time, he seemed like he was having so much fun reading it.
"So, this is your idea? To blackmail me with a stupid list?" I looked at him suspiciously.
"You wound me, baby." He continued, "why would I blackmail you, sweetheart when it's more fun helping you finish it?"
"You...what?" I choked with sudden shock.
"But I already lost my virginity. We slept multiple times, remember?" I asked in confusion.
"Not just that, although I am proud of myself for all the hard work I have done for the sake of your list." He mumbled like a total idiot.
"You already went to two parties, so we can check that off," he said as he proceeded to type something on his phone.
"Wes, you're becoming delusional with each day. Why don't you find another girl who isn't intimidated by your status."? It was pathetic, but I knew his obsession came with an expiration date.
"Why would I find someone else when I have you all to myself?" He chuckled.
"This is all a game to you, isn't it? What if you realize that I'm boring and that this game is boring one day? Or what if we both decide to date, other people? What will happen then?" I asked while trying to keep my voice clear
"Is that what you want? To date and fuck some other asshole? You always assume that I'll leave while you constantly plan to find another asshole to keep that pussy entertained." Wes got into my face and all but growled.
I was angrier than hurt at this statement. I slapped him on the chest before realizing what I was doing.
"We had sex without protection, and I didn't even say anything when you wanted to.... umm... wanted to..."
"Fuck" he supplied with a grumpy expression.
"When you wanted to do it in public. Whenever you suggest anything crazy, I just go along with it, and you think I'm looking for another guy? I don't want another guy, okay! I don't even know how to handle this one guy that's constantly questioning my sanity.
That answer somehow appeased him, but he kept following me like a lost puppy.
"Okay, you finally realized that I am your soulmate, but we still need to finish this list. Think of this as a bonding exercise between you and me."
"I swear, I don't think we'll need any more bonding. How do you always come up with something crazy? More importantly, why do I agree with you every single time?" I groaned in self-disappointment.
"Come on, baby. It will be fun," Wes slowly coaxed me.
"Ugh! Alright fine. Help me check each item on this list. I guess I still do want to do some of those things."
"I would love to, sweetheart," Wes grinned.
But I had this weird feeling. That there is something else to it. Wes would help me, but why did it feel like he expected something in return.
"Wes, what is it? What do you want now?" I asked skeptically.
"Your list inspired me to make up my own fantasy list. So, if I help you fulfill yours, you should help me fulfill mine. How does that sound?" He seemed so proud of himself for coming up with that dumb idea.
"Wes, do you realize that this is getting out of hand? My list itself is dumb enough to ignore. Why would you come up with another list?"
"No, hear me out!" He replied excitedly, and before I could even say anything, he continued, "I think it's a smart idea. I have a couple of fantasies that I want to try with a girl."
"You keep saying that! What do you mean? What fantasies?" I asked, confused.
"For example, something like fucking your bare pussy. You do have that on your list, right? The day you get the bikini wax, I will get to fuck your bare pussy. How does that sound?"
"Huh! But that list is for my sake. I will be checking things off my list for me, not for you or anybody else." I hissed at him.
"Yes, similarly, my list will be, for my sake, fulfilling my fantasies. It has nothing to do with you," Wes huffed.
"Alright, what do you have in mind?"
"I want to test something, the feasibility of how far we can go?"
"What do you mean? Like whips and chains?" I freaked out immediately.
"What the fuck? No, it won't be anything you don't like," he reassured me.
But I wasn't convinced. I kept pestering. "Like what? Tell me or show me." I asked, frustrated at this point.
He looked at me, and suddenly his eyes and smile turned dark. That's when I realized I walked right into it. I basically gave him permission to use my body.
"Hey, I want to try something new with you." He said with a heat in his eyes.
"Wes, we already had sex today, multiple times." I tried reminding him in vain.
"That's okay. We're not having sex this time." He tried to convince me.
The last time he told me that we would not have sex, he tortured me with the vibrator. I moved away from him or at least tried to.
"Promise me that you won't be using that stupid vibrator on me again." That's pure torture, and I'm not mentally prepared for that.
"For the rest of the day, I won't, I promise, unless you ask me to. How does that sound?" Was that a compromise?
"Alright, now that I have your approval, come with me." He held my hand and pulled me towards the bathroom.
"Are we going to have sex in the bathroom?" I asked, confused.
He grinned, "no, at least not tonight. As I said, I want to try something new with you, and we already fucked in the bathroom," and chuckled, "many times."