AUTHOR'S NOTE: I realize the Native Americans taking a frontier woman story is a clichΓ© and that the lesbian story line might not be realistic. Apologies to any readers who are offended or have any complaints about accuracy/authenticity.
Sarah Winston and her husband Tom were young homesteaders in the Midwest in the late 1860s. They were in the mid-20s and had recently been married after Tom had returned from fighting for the Union in the Civil War.
It was late summer. Tom was wrestling with the plow towed by one of their horses. Sarah was in the one-room plank-and-sod house they had built together.
Sarah was sweeping the rough-hewn plank floor when she heard shouts. She looked through the open door and gasped at the sight of half-a-dozen Indians on ponies closing in on her husband. She watched as he unslung his musket and fired. It missed. In seconds, the Indians were surrounding her husband, who swung his musket like a club in a futile attempt to defend himself. One Indian clubbed him from behind; he fell to his knees and another Indian buried his hatchet in his chest.
Sarah stifled a scream with a clenched fist. She pulled the door shut. Their other horse was tied out back. As she reached the back door, she glanced through the viewing slit and saw three braves untethering the horse.
She grabbed her husband's other musket and the bag of shot and powder. They had built a shallow trench under the floor as a root cellar/storage area. She lifted the plank in the floor and laid down in the hiding place that was barely large enough for her body.
Sarah's heart was pounding, and she was breathing in gasps. She clutched the musket with both hands, her palms sweaty. After what seemed like an hour but was only a few minutes, she heard the front door bang open and the footsteps of the invaders. They pillaged, gathering whatever they wanted to carry away.
Sarah lay in the dark of her hiding place, listening to their voices, their yelps as they discovered whatever treasures they considered valuable. But then the voices stopped. "Were they about to leave," Sarah wondered, her heart leaping with the hope of survival.
Unbeknownst to her and to her misfortune, when she climbed into her hiding place a small section of her dress remained visible between the planks. A sharp-eyed brave had noticed this and signaled for silence.
Two Indians positioned themselves at each end of the plank and worked their fingers so they could lift it. With a quick move, the plank was removed. Sarah blinked at the sudden light and tried to bring the musket to bear. Before she could, one of the braves grabbed the barrel and yanked it from her sweaty hands. She looked up from what she assumed would be her shallow grave.
Nine bronzed-skinned braves looked down at her. Some were wearing buckskin breaches, others only loin cloths. All were wearing war paint. Sarah's eyes revealed her terror as she glanced at the Indians who had murdered her husband and who now controlled her fate.
Two of the braves leaned down and each grabbed Sarah by the forearms. She yelped as they yanked her out of the trench and on to her feet.
Sarah Winston was about 5-2 with light brownish-blonde hair which she had pulled back and secured with a ribbon. She was pretty but not beautiful. Her hips were wide, and her breasts were round and full. As she stood there, surrounded by her captors, the front of the blue gingham dress rose and fell as she gasped for breath, her breathing accelerated by fear.
The leader of the war party grunted a few words and another brave grabbed Sarah's arms and yanked them behind her back. Her wrists were tied with a leather cord, and she was led outside.
The Indians mounted their ponies. Sarah was tossed onto the leader's mount, and he climbed on behind her. One arm encircled her waist, the other his pony's halter. He dug his heels into the animal's sides and the war party took off at a gallop.
Sarah was terrified on several levels. Not only was she a captive but as the horses galloped along, she felt like she could fall off at any minute. Without her hands, Sarah could only grip the pony's sides with her legs and thighs.
Her bottom was jammed back against the Indian's crotch, and it wasn't long into the journey that she started to feel something hard jabbing against her soft ass. She heard a chuckle in her ear. Then the Indian's hand moved up from her waist and Sarah gasped as he cupped her right breast, squeezing it as they galloped along. Sarah felt his cock grow larger and harder as it pressed against her.
The group rode for hours across the flat terrain. Sarah's riding partner stopped groping her and his cock seemed to lose some of its hardness. She hoped that perhaps she would be spared any further indignities.
As dusk fell, the Indians came upon a stream which had a small stand of trees. They stopped to make camp for the night. Sarah was pulled off the horse and told to sit under a tree. A brave watched her as two others set up camp. The others rode off and just after dark returned with a few dead rabbits slung over their ponies.
Sarah's hands were re-tied so that she could eat. After she consumed some of the meat, one of the braves led her to the stream. She knelt down and cupped some water in her hands to drink and wash her face.
The Indians prepared to sleep. Again, Sarah's hands were retied behind her back and her feet were also bound. The brave trussed her hands and feet together and then tied that binding to a tree. The leader approached with a blanket from his pony and threw it over her.
Sarah was exhausted and fell into a deep sleep despite her fear and the awkward manner in which she was forced to lay.
The next morning, she awoke to voices and the sound of water splashing. She opened her eyes and looked toward the stream. The braves were in the water, some squatting, some standing. They were all naked. They appeared to be bathing.
One of the braves noticed that Sarah was awake and said something. The Indians climbed out of the water and headed for Sarah. She could see that some of their cocks were erect, while the other cocks were semi-hard.
The leader walked over to the horses and then returned holding a knife. He bent down behind Sarah and cut her bindings. She groaned as she tried to move her stiff muscles. The leader reached down and grabbed the collar of her dress and yanked Sarah to her feet. There was a ripping sound as part of the collar tore from the force.
She was dragged/led to a spot between two small trees that were about 10 feet apart. She noticed that two braves were tying a rope around a branch of each tree. They then tied her wrists so that her arms were spread and at shoulder level.
The war party formed a semi-circle in front of Sarah. The leader approached her. She could see that his large cock was erect; it bobbed as he walked toward her.
He brought his hand up to her face. His rough, calloused fingers traced over her cheek and her lips. She jerked her head away. He frowned and reached behind her, taking a handful of hair in his hand to hold her steady. The knife was in his other hand. He brought it up and placed the sharp tip against her cheek. There wasn't enough pressure to draw blood, but she understood the meaning.