This story is based on a comic by a guy named Rex. Only found out halfway through what this was based on. Hopefully it feels different enough.
*****
How does a guy accidentally get himself to of the hottest girls he's met to not only date him, but sleep with him? Normally any jock or douchebag you see on TV who cheats on a girl end up with none the girls and their car trashed, or something of the sort if movies are to be believed anyway. I on the other hand wasn't actually trying to cheat on anyone, my weird luck kicked in and it just shot me in a weird slope.
I wasn't the most popular guy around. I used to be a pretty geeky looking kid, skinny and weak, but at some point growing up I just sort of hit a growth spurt and became a incredibly active and good looking guy. I still looked kind of goofy if you looked closely but people actually came to like my goofy face once I started getting into my school sports team. Everything was turning around and going great for me, and that's around the time the girl I've had a crush on for years actually took interest in me.
Gwen was a cute blonde with an adorable face. She used to spend her times either studying or hanging out with the popular kids in the past because of how good looking she was. If it wasn't for how quickly the guys fell for her, making her popular, we might have actually been friends a lot sooner. Luckily for me we did actually finally get to really know each other and surprisingly to me we both had a lot in common. She was into a lot of things I liked and her hobbies actually interested me quite a bit. It was incredible how quickly we got along cause in only a week's time we started dating. For almost two years we dated until we graduated. Unfortunately Gwen and I weren't able to see each other as much and from what I understood on our last meeting, it was time we broke it off.
Having split from Gwen after such a long time together was really heartbreaking. She was the first girl I ever had an interest in, so to lose her after having such a great time left me in a pretty bad spot. For months I would mope around with my friends or at work. I lacked any real motivation to do anything besides work and practice. One day some friends had taken me out to a bar where we could listen to a band on stage while eating and drinking. To my surprise one of my friends got the lead of the band to come over and talk to me. I didn't realize until they left me but once she arrived I knew what they were doing, trying to get me to date someone new. It had only been a few months after I finished dating Gwen so looking for another girl wasn't actually on my list of priorities, but something about my mood at the time made me change my mind quick. When she arrived the first thing I noticed about her was that she looked familiar, probably a girl from high school or something. I didn't bring it up seeing as she didn't recognize me but there was something about her that at the time was eating at me, something I should have known.
Her name was Emma. She's a redhead, slender beauty that has a look on her face that scream, "I'm a rocker girl bitch!" When compared to Gwen she was basically the complete opposite. Emma was a party girl that liked to get wild and have fun, yet she still liked to chill out and just talk. Gwen wasn't always the calm collected girl, she would usually let her true colors show with friends but she definitely wasn't like that all the time. Emma felt so out of my ball park that it felt awkward just partying with her that night. At some point during our conversations we brought a topic on a movie and in a flash we just kicked it off. I don't know what it was but we both laughed at our jokes and would sing on the karaoke till we we starting cracking up and run off stage, we were having a great time. Eventually our night led to me heading over to Emma's place where we both had sex out of nowhere. I was probably incredibly drunk at the time so I must have agreed to it like a horny idiot. The morning after we both woke up and the first thing I was greeted by was Emma's hot body over mine.
"Last thing I was expecting last night was having amazing sex with a guy like you." Emma dropped down on me to land a kiss on my cheek. I have had sex with Gwen before but it was only a few times. It was hard to gage how well I was since she wouldn't say anything about it. So it came to my surprise to find that she was actually that impressed by how I did.
Almost immediately me and Emma hooked up and started dating. It was completely different experience than being with Gwen. There were many parties and her wild attitude felt like a nice change of pace that I could get around. For the most part everything was starting to go great and I had already gotten over my slight depression from Gwen, but one day something unexpected happened.
Emma had found out about my previous girlfriend and Gwen figured out the same about Emma. Gwen had called me to give one of the loudest rants I've heard. Apparently I had misunderstood what she meant by, "it's best to stay apart for a bit," cause we never actually broke up, I was just being an idiot. I was always bad at getting some things through my thick skull but I never thought I would mess up something so major. The worst part was that she still wanted to be with me, problem was the girl I was dating at the moment.
Emma and Gwen were actually huge rivals back in school. I must have not realized at all, not being popular and all. They hated each other and would compete over the smallest thing. So Gwen hearing that my new girlfriend is her rival probably wasn't the best thing for her to hear and same could be said for Emma. I was in a rough spot between the two. Both of them had actually stopped talking to me until I had figured this out. Emma was crazy into me and Gwen was technically still my girlfriend. The choice should have been simple but for some reason I couldn't wrap my head about it.
An entire month had before I received a text from Gwen. She said she had a plan on how to deal with the problem. We were all gonna meet a local diner and just talk it out until I eventually chose which one to go with. The first thing that popped into my head was how that place was gonna be a battlefield. Emma and Gwen both together while fighting over a guy they liked was sure to end in bloodshed.
At the diner I first encountered Gwen who was wearing a blue stripped sweater shirt with long sleeves and a short skirt with the same design. Her hair was let down and she was using cute makeup with blue eyeshadow that paired up nicely with her beautiful blue eyes. She looked like she was trying to impress me with how she was dressed. I never took her for the jelous type but I do know how motivated she can get and when she sets her eyes on something she won't let go.
"Chris over here!" She waved over at me so I could see her even though I was sure she had already seen me walking over. Maybe she was trying to get people to see me with her, it was a common place where our friends would meet up so word would have spread around probably.
"Hey, sorry if I'm late. You won't believe the mess there was on the way here," I wanted to make sure I made it on time to not further mess anything up and most importantly, get there before both of them saw each other.
"Oh please, don't worry about it. Besides you're always late to stuff," Gwen didn't seem as angry as she sounded the other day. In truth it was throwing me off at first. She was the kind of girl who could calm herself down for something, I just wasn't sure if it would last.
We both headed inside the diner and got our seats on the back, next to a window. It was relatively early so not many people were around. Gwen had helped out the owner of the diner and was able to order some things for free. As we were about to sit down, someone had caught my eye as they entered through the front.
Emma arrived wearing a red, sleeveless shirt and a purple skirt with a large belt on it. Her obviously and intentionally seductive clevage and short skirt stood out immediately the moment she walked in. More so than Gwen it was obvious she was also trying to win me over.
"Sorry for arriving late. Finding a good parking is impossible around here," Emma swung her hair back before walking next to the table. I could see Gwen roll her eyes the moment she heard she spoke.
"Emma," Gwen said out of the blue.
"Gwen," Emma replied back as she sat next to me.
I was now in the middle between both Gwen and Emma as they stared directly into each other. There was nothing but silence, the table in front of me and the dumb nervous smile on my face. The silence was soon broken when one of the waiters came over.
"Welcome. We will come back in a bit but first. Here's the menu and the specials for today," surprisingly both of them thanked the waiter in a unexpected tone. But once she was gone their eyes once again clashed with one another.
Gwen had finally stopped staring at Emma to look at the list we were given. Emma had reached out her hand to momentarily struggle with Gwen over the menu before they held it down in place in front of me. I was spending all this time trying to come up with something to say, anything that would get us all to speak. Finally something had blurted out of my mouth, I had no idea what I said or how it popped out but it didn't matter since both of them turned to look at me. I don't know why but it worked, Emma had started to talk and Gwen also would join in on ocassion until all three were in on it.
It was awkward but I was keeping them distracted from one another by talking about work and the such, only delaying the inevitable. I was able to do so until the waiter had arrived to ask for our orders. It was around there that we lost our pace.
"Oh good, can I get a large strawberry sundae smoothie please? Sprinkles, whipped cream, and a cherry on top if possible," Emma always had a way of speaking like a movie star or famous person with attitude whenever she was out. It's probably because of her rocker girl vibe.
Gwen raised an eyebrow while looking in Emma's direction, she smiled slightly right after, "Chelsea honey, can you get me and Cris the usual if you could?" Gwen was always incredibly nice towards people and really caring. Seeing the two contrast right before me was like seeing a wall half black and white.
After our orders had been taken we spent the next few minutes in silence once again. I didn't have anything to say and my mouth would tie up the moment it spoke up. When the food arrived I for some reason felt a little better about the position I was in even though it didn't mean much in the end since nothing had changed. The first thing Emma did was place two straws on the sundae smoothie, one pointing at me and one at her. Gwen quickly noticed this and placed her own straw before we could drink from ours.
"You are so lame you know that? Doing all that fake romantic crap," Gwen's eyebrows lowered a little as she looked at Emma. It felt like she was radiating hate over fdom her side.
"Oh please, this is lame? Has anyone told you how you spent your free time? Homework and more work aren't fun honey. No wonder he left you for someone more interesting." My heart stopped for a second and my eyes widened. The moment I was dreading had come.
