"Holy shit, you're tight." Tears rolled down her cheeks as he pushed his dick in... in shame because those wonderful feelings in her pussy didn't seem to realize that everything was all wrong. Every nerve felt vibrant and alive as his dick nudged its way deeper and deeper. As he began to move in and out of her pussy she began to forget her angry feelings as his balls tapped her clit and the head of his penis moved deeper and deeper, spreading her apart. It felt good, full, and she was starting to burn with a different sort of heat.
Then he pulled all the way out, chuckling again, and she realized that she had been moving in time with his strokes, and felt her face turning red again in humiliation. All she wanted was him back in her, her pussy felt tight and coiled, and she needed release. If there hadn't been a gag in her mouth, she would have pleaded, there was something wonderful waiting and she was so close to it.
Instead, Vincent placed the head of his dick just above her ass hole and whispered in her ear, "This is for letting that guy grope you after you slapped me for it." One quick shove and half his dick was buried in her ass. Jennifer arched her back in pain, tensing her asshole, trying to expel him - which just made it hurt worse. Her eyes glazed, it hurt too much to even try to scream, instead she just panted for breath while he let his dick rest halfway in her ass, squeezing her breasts and nipples while he waited. Slowly, very slowly she began to relax as the pain started to fade a bit. Then he began to move again, and tears leaked down her face again, it felt like he was shoving a baseball bat into her. Every movement grated into her, burning even with the lubrication of her pussy juices coating his dick. As he worked his dick in and out of her asshole, moving deeper and deeper, he started to feel a little bad for causing her so much pain, after all she'd been pretty good once she didn't have a choice. It had seemed like she'd started really getting in to the pussy licking and the sex.
One hand slipped down begin toying with her pussy and clit, making her quiver and her ass clench around his dick. He moaned. There was nothing like a tight virgin ass, and hers was exquisite, the more so for all the waiting she'd made him do. Pushing one finger into her pussy while the other rubbed her clit he enjoyed the sensations of her ass pulsing around his dick. For Jennifer, she could feel her orgasm building again... and despaired. Surely she couldn't be enjoying this, she couldn't cum with him in her ass, could she? The strokes began moving faster, going deeper, and she realized that it was starting to feel good.
Maybe she had been wrong. Maybe she wasn't really a good girl at heart, maybe the outer exterior that she liked to play with had been more right than she knew... maybe deep down she was just a slut. Her body was rocking in time with his strokes, and she finally gave herself into the feelings, into the total naughtiness of having a dick up her ass and fingers in her pussy.
Vincent could actually feel the moment of submission, her whole body relaxed and she began moving her hips back against him of her own volition, actually trying to fill her own ass up with his dick. Moving faster he began really pounding into her, riding her ass hard and squeezing her tit with one hand while fingering her pussy faster with the other. Moans of pleasure began to sound behind the gag, as his fingers brought her closer and closer to climax.
It felt like an explosion, like every part of her body just burst, and her pussy was burning and flowing and filled with fire. Her orgasm caused the insides of her ass to ripple and pulse, which finally brought Vincent to his own completion; he shoved hard into her ass, stretching it one last time as his dick pulsed and released white stickiness deep in her hole.
Reluctantly, he eventually pulled his dick from her ass with a pop, knowing that he'd probably never see her again. Really the relationship had been pretty good, it was just the teasing. At least he'd have one hell of a memory - and a story - to take with him.
He began untying her and slipped off the gag before getting up and going towards his clothes. Surprise as her hand gripped his wrist and glazed, pleasure-filled eyes looked up at him. Her whole body was covered in a sheen of sweat, her nipples were still hard and topped her breasts like cherries on ice cream, cum was just beginning to slide out of her ass, and her pussy was still pink and swollen.
"Do it again please?"