Note: This is a fantasy about acts that would be evil in reality.
--
"I should be afraid," I said softly as we climbed the back stairs.
"Really?" Edward said, squeezing my hand.
"Professor Connor could destroy us," I said.
"If she wanted to," Edward replied. "But you're right about what she wants."
"And what if I'm not?"
He smiled. "We'll fuck that bridge when we come to it."
"That is the worst turn of phrase I have ever heard."
"So far," he said. "I've still got time to top it, right?"
I smiled at him, my little knot of nascent fear sinking down beneath my affection.
"I hope so."
"Me too."
--
Professor Connor had been a lot of things to us, since this year began. She started out as our favorite psychology professor, who taught the exceedingly popular human sexuality class. Then she assigned Edward and I to do a video project about rape fantasies with a party girl named Gianna. When Gianna refused to help us with the project, we cornered her in the woods and ravished her, figuring that she was still helping even if she wasn't helping willingly.
When Professor Connor figured out what we'd done, she became our co-conspirator. Gianna dropped out when she got pregnant, so Professor Connor had recruited us to ravish other cheaters. Apparently, knocking them up without their consent was both easier and more exciting than formal honor code charges.
But last time we'd spoken, she'd become something else. She'd demanded a sex tape from us, and implied that she might turn us in if she didn't get it. Tonight was the deadline she'd given us.
As intimidating as the deadline was, I had a suspicion that I understood what she wanted. There was only one way to know, though.
"Come in," Professor Connor said. She was curvy like a Pixar mom, with brown hair tied in a ponytail and a mischievous grin. "I'm glad you came in person."
"Of course," I said.
"That way, if I need you to reenact anything, you can do it without any interruption," she added.
Edward glanced at me. This presumably meant that no other professors or janitors would be close by.
"You don't have to do anything you don't want to," I said softly.
"I know," he replied. "Neither do you."
Professor Connor raised an eyebrow at us, then shrugged. "May I have the video?"
Edward took a flash drive out of his pocket and handed it to her. She smiled, her cheeks flushing a bit as she pulled the video file up.
"You know, I've never watched this sort of thing with an audience before," she admitted. "It's a little strange."
"A bit," I agreed. "But it can be nice."
"When I ravished Gianna, I knew I had an audience," Edward said, "and it changed the way I did everything. I wanted Sofia to enjoy it too."
I felt my heart racing. I couldn't tell if it was his words or anticipation.
Professor Connor opened the video. I could see the reflection in her glasses as it started, the image showing her office.
"What is this?" she asked, as on her screen Edward and I stepped into her office and sat down.
"It's a video of you, congratulating us for ravishing Jenny and asking us to ravish Trinh," I said.
"If you skip ahead, you congratulate us for Trinh too," Edward added.
She kept her cool pretty well - only the wrinkling of her nose told me that she was caught by surprise.
"I see," she said, pausing the video. "How did you record it?"
"Sofia put a camera on your top shelf during one of your classes," Edward said. "I love how clever she is."
"So, now if you turn us in we all go down together," I said. "We all go to jail, but you also lose tenure."
"Tenure is really good here," Edward added.
"Alright," Professor Connor sighed. "You've made your point."
I reached over and squeezed Edward's hand.
"Not quite," I said.
She figured it out quickly. Before I had time to say another word, she jumped up and rushed for the door. Edward intercepted her, grabbing her wrist and pulling her back.
"No!" she cried. "You can't. I can bring you down."
"If we go down, we go down together," I said. She squirmed, trying to twist her way out of Edward's grip, and he grabbed her other arm and pinned them both behind her back. She gasped, trying to regain the control she'd had so recently. I couldn't bear to let her.
"I was just thinking. I love the way Edward fucks me, but I love watching him take other women too. And you've enjoyed watching, but maybe you'd enjoy more than that."
I didn't give her a clean chance to reply. Before she could speak, I reached down and unbuttoned her khaki pants. She squealed and kicked, and Edward pulled her back.
"Don't hurt her," he growled.
I melted a bit, but I kept myself under control. There would be plenty of time for me to keep melting soon enough. I smiled at Edward, then turned back to Professor Connor.