The world seemed to swim in and out of focus. She felt herself being lifted, heard a sound of clanking and another sound of sloshing, but Arii was unaware of what was happening. She was hiding somewhere safe, where it didn't hurt any more, and that was where she wanted to stay.
Eventually, though, she had to come out again. She was in the inner room, sat laxly in a tin bath that was filled to waist height with warm water, and Seth was washing her gently with a cake of rough soap. By the light of a single candle, she saw that the two of them were alone together.
"Why did you do that?" she asked, and burst into tears before Seth could answer. She sobbed as though her heart would break while Seth finished soaping and rinsing every inch of her, and lifted her out onto a rough off-white towel. "Why did you do that? I was keeping my side of the bargain, I was pleasing all of you – wasn't I?"
"You were," Seth said gently.
"Then why – why – why?" Arii demanded between sobs. "Just for the fun of being cruel?"
He picked her up, wrapped in the towel, and sat on the bed, holding her. She huddled, not wanting to be touched ever again, not by Seth, not by anybody else. "Well, if it was just for that, it wasn't against anything I promised," Seth said, "but it was for a reason. Maybe two reasons."
"I don't understand," sobbed Arii.
"No, you don't," said Seth. "Mostly, you don't understand the difference between a prank and a crime. That's why I did that."
"Why? Because I was enjoying my punishment too much? So for it to be a proper punishment, I had to hurt? Or because I needed more punishment for being a slut?"
"That's not it, exactly," Seth said. "Remember how I told you about the price of a loaf of bread? That's when they find out who did it. I told you what we do to thieves. What I didn't tell you is what happens when nobody saw who did it.
"Now for a start, if you're seen running away from the scene of a crime, and someone yells 'Stop, thief!', or whatever, that's known as the hue and cry. Once the hue and cry's up, anyone can stop you how they like, and if you get hurt or killed, that's your look-out, whether or not you actually did anything.
"But if you do give yourself up, or get dragged in some other way, then there are ways and means, if there's no evidence against you. Sometimes they make you carry a red-hot horseshoe ten paces from the anvil. Then they bind your hands up and on the third day they see if you're burned. Or they get you to swear on the Bible that you're innocent, and the priest gives you a piece of the Host, because that won't go over a lying tongue. Otherwise they take the story to twelve good men and true to hear the case against you, and they have to agree that you're guilty.
"All very well, except that if you ask me, anyone who carries red-hot iron in his hands gets burnt, or if he doesn't, he's got the luck to know some knack that I don't, and it's got nothing to do with whether he's guilty of anything. Or if you've got a crowd looking on ready to swing you from the nearest tree, you're throat's too dry to swallow a hard crust. Or if you go before the jury, you need to hope you're not the village recluse, or a senile old woman who lives alone with just her cat, or a simpleton, or a stranger who looks a bit funny. You see, once a crime's been committed, people like to see someone punished for it."