This is the first time I've made any of my stories public! Please leave feedback!
Takes a bit to get started, but I hope it's worth the wait.
This is also my submission for the 2020 Halloween contest but may turn into a longer series if it's enjoyed.
**************************************************
Growing up, Chelsea was always one of the popular ones. Always one of the pretty ones. Always one of the ones that everyone tried to be around. It wasn't that she was conceited -- of course growing up like that would give her some sort of an ego -- but she knew her value. She was also an only child, so she was used to getting her way. It also didn't help that her parents were fairly well off and had the biggest sweet spot for their little angel. That's not to say that she made a habit of taking advantage of her loving mother and father, but only to say that she knew exactly how to get what she wanted. And if she put her mind to it, she could get nearly anything she wanted.
Chelsea was one of those girls who not only was pretty, but was smart. And not just in the ways of wrapping people around her fingers. She actually put the time into studying and learning, not only when it came to her classes, but even about herself. She wasn't ever afraid to put in the effort that she felt something deserved.
Now a couple years into college, she had more experiences than she'd ever expected while in high school. She saw how things worked, and she worked hard to get through her classes with the goal of getting through this part of her life as quickly as possible. But she wouldn't let that stop her from having fun.
Last year, she remembered the parties that her roommate-turned-close friend, Noelle, had invited her to. She was still one of the prettier ones, even on this larger scale, but she had to fight for attention in some of the crowds. That didn't make her jealous, but it lit a competitive fire somewhere in the back of her mind. She never had to be the best at anything, just up there in the spotlights with the others.
Most notable of these parties where she didn't stand out was the Halloween party. It was her first college party, and she didn't realize quite how... well... slutty most of the girls dressed up.
Chelsea and Noelle thought it would be cute to go as a pair of puzzle pieces so that when they stood next to each other to pose for a picture, they linked nicely. Their parents loved the pictures. Unfortunately, it didn't do well to make Chelsea stand out against the likes of all the girls that were wearing practically nothing but colored underwear or nearly sheer nighties, the occasional halo or devil horns, tails, and glittery wings of all the sexy devils and angels vying for attention.
It didn't take a gigantic leap of either of their imaginations to figure out why most of the doors would close for differing periods of time. Especially not with the amount of alcohol and other substances that were easily available. She'd never felt the need to imbibe in any mind altering substances before, but Chelsea figured that since it was college, she might at least let herself be pressured into some alcohol.
This year, she'd vowed to do better. Much better.
*****
It was the middle of August, and Chelsea was on a trip exploring some of the states back in New England; her way of enjoying the last bits of summer before school started back up.
She loved history, and was planning on majoring in specifically US history, if she could figure out what sort of career path she'd take once she finished her degree. Until then, though, it was one of her passions, and back East, she'd always heard, was rife with history. So many old tales, from the beginnings of the country, to ghost stories, to gangsters, to the underground railroad, it was like heaven on earth, and as she consulted the guide she'd picked up from Amazon, she figured that the best way to decide where to start was by wandering aimlessly in the oldest part of whatever tiny town she'd found herself in.
The sun beat down from between the old brick buildings onto Chelsea's long blond hair, and she'd finally had enough of toughing it out, dropping her sunglasses from the top of her head to settle in front of her eyes. Her hotel was a short taxi from downtown, and when asked where she'd wanted to be dropped, she told the driver to leave her in whichever part of oldtown that he thought was most interesting.
Apparently she and the driver had a very different viewpoint on the word "interesting." Though intrigued with the botanical garden, she wanted her passion. She wanted rich history, not flowers, no matter how nice the block smelled in the midday sun.
Long legs carried her first to the local museum, which was basically a single old church building that used to serve as the town hall when the city was originally founded, and while it was rich in knowledge and Chelsea learned much in the half hour she'd spent there, she felt a pull deeper into oldtown.
About a mile farther down the road, the asphalt turned suddenly to old cobbles, the sidewalk into brick with brass placards inlaid into the ground. Chelsea was sure that it couldn't be the original work, but it didn't bother her that the town had kept it up as much as they had.
Looking around the street, lined with old fashioned street lamps and long, colorful awnings added to the feel of the town. Everyone was smiling, a horse-drawn carriage wheeled down the road toward her, the buildings were made of either brick or wooden walls. The place felt like it had transported Chelsea back a hundred years, and she couldn't help but wonder what it would have been like to live during that time period. No cell phones, no computers, no cars. A much simpler way of living. But along with the simplicity, she knew it would come with the down sides of being so far in the past and was glad that she lived when she did.
After a few more stops at buildings that seemed to look important, and a quaint ride on a carriage where she was able to listen to a couple ghost stories that were based in town, it was beginning to get late. Chelsea knew it was about time to find a ride back to her hotel -- maybe a trolley if she could find one- but something pulled her onward.
Ahead, she saw an old iron sign hanging from a solitary building. It was no bigger than a house, and the sign was a black cat. Images of the Halloween party came rushing back to Chelsea, and her lips curled in a devious smile. What better to tame the angels and devils than a witch? Maybe she'd be able to pick up some enticing props for her costume.
Inside was almost pitch black, even after Chelsea raised her sun glasses back on top of her head. There was a slight smell of incense, which she'd never cared fore, but it wasn't so overpowering as usual, and she found herself relaxing after the long day of walking around town. She was a little disappointed to find the front of the shop covered in book shelves, rather than magic paraphernalia, but something made her feel like she was in the right place.
"Hello?" She called into the darkness, letting her eyes adjust as much as possible. Maybe the place was closed for the night?
A chill ran down Chelsea's spine, but she couldn't place whatever had made the feeling. It's just cold, she thought to herself, rubbing her hands on her arms. She was wearing short jean shorts and a tee shirt with the shortest sleeves imaginable, with her midriff just barely teased. It was a hot summer day outside, but this shop was like winter. Along the front windows were racks of cheap 'witch' hats with pointed tips, plastic cauldrons, green noses attached to fake plastic glasses, along with some stuffed cats and rubber lizards. It was almost like that was for show, though, because as she moved along the shelves, she noticed that most of them didn't have any writing on their spines, and the deeper she got, the dustier the store became.
"Hello?" She asked again, her voice slightly more timid as she fought against her desire to get back into the warm summer air.
Finally, she heard another door open and close, this one at the far end of the shop from the back. "I'm comin'," she heard, and once she saw the figure that had spoken, the voice fit perfectly.
Walking up to the checkout counter was an older lady, with softly curled gray hair. No, it was more of a shimmering silver in the candle light. The lady was probably in her late sixties, dressed in a black, flowing robe and a thin black choker around her neck with a silver crescent moon inlaid into it. When she saw Chelsea, her smile seemed to light up the dimness in the store, drawing the younger woman closer. "What can I do for you, my dear?"
Suddenly shy and nervous, Chelsea stepped forward, oddly feeling slightly warmer with each step closer to the older woman. "I'm just browsing," she managed, not making eye contact, but looking around at the jars and racks on the counter instead. "I thought I might find something to go with my Halloween outfit this year."
"Are we masquerading as a witch?" The shopkeeper's voice sounded partly teasing and friendly, and partly scornful. "They used to torture witches, you know. Death by fire and drowning, stoning and other cruel devices. You sure you want to be one of those?"
Another chill shot down Chelsea's spine and she managed to suppress the shudder that went with it. "It's just a party," she replied, grinning and hoping that the old lady was just trying to scare a tourist as part of her persona.