Guilty arousal fluttered in Kate's stomach. It didn't matter how often her girlfriend said there was nothing wrong with this fantasy. It didn't matter that Kate's girlfriend was now indulging her fantasy. Shame still heated her cheeks and hollowed her breathing. Kate would call the whole thing off if she wasn't so horny.
'Katy,' said Lucy. She took Kate's chin to raise her from the bed to her feet. 'Do you still want this?'
'Yes,' Kate said, shaking and shivering.
'Brave girl,' cooed Lucy. She widened her eyes. Her gaze caught Kate in an irresistible embrace. 'You are a brave girl for sharing your deepest fantasies.'
Lucy's praise melted Kate's guilty jitters. She relaxed into Lucy's love, into her big, green eyes which saw, understood, and accepted Kate's everything.
'You are a brave girl,' said Lucy, guiding Kate into a kneeling position. 'You are a brave girl for asking to be put in your place.'
**
Ever the gentleman, Luke tried to help Kate up. Kate was so discombobulated by her fall, and by Luke's big, green eyes, that she accepted his proffered hand, before yanking her hand back. Kate Welles couldn't accept Luke Roi's help: for one, she was a strong, independent woman who could get to her own two feet; for two, Luke was a chauvinist pig who probably got off on helping damsels-in-distress; and for three, they were opponents in Petruchio University's annual live-streamed debate. Weak little Katy getting help from big strong Luke was bad optics in front of the crowd in the auditorium – especially for today's topic.
'I do admire your can-do attitude,' Luke said. 'A double major in medicine and journalism – you must be trying so hard.'
Kate stuck her tongue out at him, before huffing her way to her team's side of the stage. He made her so angry. He could say the most patronising things without a hint of sarcasm, as though he had genuine faith in her 'attitude', but none in her ability. Oh, but she'd show him today. With the research she'd gotten from her medical training, and the rhetorical skills she'd gotten from journalism, she'd cinch victory for the negative team on today's topic.
'A Woman's Place is in the Home,' read the projection on the wall, which showed the live-streaming footage of the stage. The topic hung over the two teams. For the negative, the three co-chairwomen of the Young Feminist Society. For the affirmative, three guys from the Traditionalists' Association.
Kate would smear the dialectal floor with their frat-gentleman blood, especially Luke. Look at him, smiling. How hellish it would be to be his girlfriend. He'd tell her to stay at home and cook his food. He'd buy floral dresses he'd expect her to wear. And after Kate did a hard day's work homemaking, he'd come home with a bouquet of roses, kiss her, and tell her she grew more beautiful each day. Kate blushed. Angrily.
Kate's teammate nudged her. The debate had started.
Well, if you could call it a debate. Kate had expected an easy victory in this culture war, but the enemy didn't even throw a grenade. The first man from the affirmative brought only sodden fire-crackers, dredging up decades-debunked studies, and 'logic' as leaky as a colander. The camera-work on the projector couldn't sex things up. When it cut to the packed audience, you saw only slouches and yawns. Kate felt sorry for her parents at home who'd have to slog through this whole live-stream.
The first woman for the negative prodded the audience awake by her show of competence, before the next man for the affirmative tranquilised the crowd. No one would be awake to see Kate take down Luke!
As her next teammate took the stage, Kate locked eyes with Luke, him smiling while Kate felt a little smile tickle onto her lips – No! No, she does not smile at sexists. Kate put on her crossest frown. Luke took centre stage. Kate couldn't wait to see what bilge dribbled from his mouth which she could throw back in his face.
And then Luke spoke.
As Luke weaved unfaultable logic, compelling rhetoric, and natural charm into an irresistible argument, Kate's neck grew hot and her stomach hollow. All the arguments she would use, he pre-empted; all the studies she researched, he outmatched with more robust one; all the feminist ideals she had engraved at the bottom of her heart, he stripped bare as the silly ideas of silly girls. And worst of all, Kate couldn't hate him for what he said. Even when he called her team 'irrational', 'emotional', and 'in need of good boyfriends', he spoke so gently that Kate knew Luke just wanted the best for her.
All the men in the audience leaned back, nodding their heads, hearing their unarticulated sentiments ne'er so well expressed. All the women, negative team included, leaned forward, their worldviews unmade brick-by-brick, as Luke laid proposition upon proposition towards his inescapable conclusions.
And Luke did this all within the ten-minute time limit. He finished with a modest shrug, concluding, 'Girls, we just want what's best for you.' Luke sat, but Kate couldn't stand. How could she stand when she didn't know which way was up anymore?
'Katy,' said Luke from across the stage. 'Have I upset you?' His voice was full of genuine concern and regret.
'No!' Kate shot to her feet. She would not be patronised to. She sure as heck wouldn't be undone by pretty speech. 'I am merely, um, contemplating triumph!'
With a big grin, Luke said, 'You'll make a lively catch for a lucky man.'
Kate marched to centre stage and pulled out her cue cards. She had crossed out every point Luke had pre-empted, which left her with only a few closing jokes. Looking through the audience of shivering female students, and female professors reconsidering their career choices, Kate realised the stakes of her defeat. So what if Luke had nice arguments. Up is not down, one plus one equals two, women do not belong in the home – no matter your counter-arguments, truth remains true. Kate had no arguments, but she'd make it seem like she did. She sucked air in, ready to bellow fundamental truths: