19. Allie and Cassie Bargain, Jenny Has a Petplay Date
Saturday Mid-Day
Cassie had wound up spending the whole night with Dana and Miguel, much to the mutual satisfaction of all parties. Cassie was even able to convince the two to wander around the apartment naked, at least while she was there: eating at the kitchen table in the buff, lounging nude on the couch, watching television while waiting for their libidos to recharge. Both seemed perfectly happy to take direction from Cassie, and had confided in her that their sex life had previously been limited to occasional bouts of simple vaginal sex, usually missionary; they had both enjoyed their unions before, but Cassie had opened so many new doors for them that they were kind of in awe of her. Cassandra liked that just fine, as she preferred more malleable partners when she could find them.
Now Cassie was climbing the stairs to her apartment after another sweaty morning of softball practice, wondering what she would find with Maddie's sister hanging around. She had never met the girl before but had seen some pictures. Maddie had been pretty chill about her nudism, so hopefully this Allison girl would be, too, but there was only one way to find out. Fumbling with her keys, Cassie opened the door to reveal a brunette sitting on the couch playing with her phone. She definitely looked like the pictures, although her makeup was heavier and almost professional looking, compared to what Cassie had been expecting from the photos.
Maddie's sister glanced up and smiled brightly when the door opened, saying, "Hey, you must be Cassie! I'm Allie, Maddie's sister." Cassie returned the greeting, a little surprised but pleased at the nonchalant reaction to her nudity. Cassie stood there for a few minutes chatting with the younger girl about fairly trivial things like school plans and softball and the weather. Allie finally asked, "So, have you met Maddie's new girlfriend yet? She just told me and mom about it the other day, and I'm dying of curiosity! I'd thought she was pretty straight, at least back in high school."
Cassie smirked and said, "I don't really know the girl, but I've seen her a few times, even had a class with her last year. Did Maddie tell you she was dating a bunny girl?"
Allie's eyes got huge and she exclaimed, "NO WAY! Really? Holy shit, I would never have guessed that."
Still smirking, Cassie went to sit down on the other end of the couch but bounced up again when her butt felt cold wetness on the cushion, saying, "Eurgh! What the hell?!"
Allie remarked, in a very offhand way, "Oh, sorry. My sister seems to squirt a lot when she cums."
Cassie's breath hitched and she asked, "Maddie was masturbating on couch again? With you here?"
Allie looked confused for a moment, wondering, "Again?" before shaking her head and saying, "No, she wasn't masturbating, I agreed to go down on her in exchange for the ride and letting me hang out here."
Cassie was stunned, not sure if Allie had a really perverted sense of humor or was actually really perverted. The younger girl had said it with such casualness it was impossible to tell which was more likely. A strange feeling was developing somewhere in Cassie's mind, and before she really thought about what she was saying she had remarked, "Well, since it's my apartment also you should probably at least finger me."
Cassandra held her breath, amazed that she would have said such a thing, but Allie seemed to be giving it serious consideration. A few moments later she agreed, saying, "That seems fair to me. Where do you want to do it?"
Blinking and licking her suddenly dry lips, an increasingly aroused Cassie suggested, "How about the shower? I need to take one anyway."
Allie smirked and said, "Intriguing, but if you want to get me naked that's extra, and I'd rather not ruin my make-up. How about you stand in the shower and I stand outside and finger you?"
Getting into the haggling, Cassie countered with, "If you're topless while you're standing there we have a deal."
Allie giggled and said, "You drive a hard bargain, but okay!" The young brunette stood up and took off her shirt and bra, revealing very long and very erect nipples, which stirred Cassie's lust even higher. "Lead the way!" she chirped, so Cassie grabbed the girl's hand and led her to the bathroom.
Wasting no time, the redhead adjusted the water and jumped in, putting one leg up on the rim of the tub to give Allie easy access. Allison licked her fingers and started teasing the taller girl's lips while running her other hand over the fuzzy red curls adorning her mound. Allie remarked, "You have such a beautiful bush, I'm glad you don't shave!"
Cassie chuckled and confided, "I used to, back in high school. It was trendy, and I kind of like the smoothness when it's freshly shaved, but I eventually realized that a lot of the people who like redheads get extra excited when the carpets match the drapes, so I stopped bothering doing anything more than trimming the edges. I don't regret it!"
Allie soon had Cassie panting with pleasure as she stood in the spray of the hot water. She was looking pretty turned on herself and said, "I've got a few hours to kill until my ride gets here, so how about we renegotiate the terms of our deal a little?"
Cassie frowned slightly and asked, "You're not trying to back out, are you?"