In the first installment of this series, I described a voyeuristic experience which led to sex with (Katie) the 19 year-old friend of my stepdaughter (Michelle). At this point I hadn't done anything with Michelle except let her tease the hell out of me around the house. Some people might consider this category to be incest, but I am one of those who don't consider it incest if there is no blood relationship.
I had called Katie a few times and she didn't answer her cell phone, so I figured she was busy, in school, or otherwise occupied. When she finally returned by call on Wednesday morning, she said that she couldn't come over because she and Michelle were going to party at Ben's house when Michelle got out of school at noon. Apparently there was a teacher's workshop or something that would free up the students early. Katie had no classes until that evening.
I asked Katie what they would be doing and she said, matter-of-factly that it was going to be a "fuckfest" with a few others invited as well. I asked if the "few others" were guys or girls, and she told me girls. Apparently, the size of Ben's cock is has become the talk of the senior girls and they all want to see what he's packing. In my last segment, I described him as being 6'5" tall, around 250 lbs with a size 15 shoe and packing around 10" of cock in his jeans, although it is average in circumference, maybe even leaning toward the skinny side.
"Is it a show & tell, or are they all interested in fucking him?" I asked her. She responded by saying that she hoped they would be satisfied in just checking him out, because she and Michelle were horny and didn't want to share him with the rest of the girls.
I told Katie to let me know what happened and if she wanted to do it in person, I'd be home all day on Thursday. She said she would, and most likely it would be in person, but she'd confirm later.
Around 1:00 pm that day, I was shocked to find Michelle coming in the front door alone, and it looked like she had been crying. Of course I played dumb and asked why she was home early. She said she got off at noon and did a few errands before coming home. I said "looks like one of the errands was to buy onions"!. She looked at me, and I said "looks like you've been crying". With that, she ran upstairs to her room and I could hear her sobbing. I waited a few minutes until the noise stopped and went up and knocked on her door.
"What?" came the question from inside her room. "Can I come in?" I asked. "OK" came the reply.
I went in and asked what was wrong. "Nothing" Michelle replied, "Oh come on, I don't know a lot about young girls, but I do know that tears usually signify something is wrong", I responded. I then sat on her bed with her and put my arm around her shoulder and pulled her to me.
"Are you sure you don't want to unload on me?' I asked. "I'm a good listener".
She said nothing for a few seconds, and then said "if I tell you, you're going to think I'm a bad girl, and I don't want that!".
"What did you do, rob a bank or kill someone?' I followed.
She laughed a little, and shook her head. I said "then I won't consider you a bad girl" and gave her a reassuring hug.
"Ok, but this is a little embarrassing" she said. "I promise not to laugh or make fun of you" I responded.
She then proceeded to tell me she and Katie were going to go to Ben's house and hang out this afternoon. She didn't indicate the part about sex that Katie had told me about. When she got to Ben's, he was naked on the couch, with Katie sucking his cock and two other girls were there as well, watching. She asked what was going on, and Katie told her that some of the girls had indicated they'd like to see a 10" cock because they didn't believe Katie when she told them about it. Apparently, these were girls that went to school with Katie, not the high school seniors that she referenced in her conversation with me.
