Most often, when I don't recognize a phone number, I let it go to voice mail, as I did that Tuesday morning. Instead of answering, I entered room 106 in Hudson Hall for my 300 level Economics class.
I have back to back 90 minute classes on Tuesdays and didn't bother checking voice mail until after lunch.
When I punched in the code for my messages a female voice started, "Hi Chris. My name is Susan Franks. I'm a friend of Kate Young and she gave me your name and number."
That was the first of many surprises as I listened to the message. Kate and I had an unusual relationship. Her daughter Gretchen and I had been fuck buddies during our last two years of high school. As Gretchen and I were both top students, gifted athletes and involved in our school and town, we didn't have time for a traditional boyfriend/girlfriend relationship.
However, we were sex maniacs and fucked whenever we could. Kate caught us one afternoon, when she'd come home from work early. Gretchen had given me a blowjob and after cumming down her throat we'd settled into a girl on top sixty-nine. I had sucked, licked and fingered Gretchen's clit, bare pussy and asshole to three shuttering climaxes, as she bobbed on my meat.
Gretchen only pulled her mouth off my cock to beg, "I need to get fucked! Please fuck me."
As the blonde haired athletic nymph climbed off me and positioned herself on her hands and knees at the edge of the bed, I slid off the queen size mattress, stood and settled behind Gretchen's nineteen year old heart shaped ass.
As I positioned my cock at the entrance of her pink swollen hole, I noticed movement in the dresser mirror. I saw Kate standing in the partially open door, but was too horny to care. After wetting my cock head along Gretchen's open lips, I grabbed her hips and pushed into her sopping tunnel.
I figured that Kate would burst into the room at any moment and I wanted to take advantage of the willing pussy in front of me before I was stopped. I started pounding Gretchen hard. My cock drove deep into her womb and a crack sounded each time my groin hit her hard ass.
Gretchen howled, "Jesus Chris! What the fucks gotten into you?'
"Want me to slow down?'
She answered, "Fuck no! You bastard, I'm getting close."
A minute later Gretchen's hands tightened around the bed cover as she cried out, "Cuuuummmmming!"
I kept fucking my nineteen year old neighbor and watched Kate's reflection in the mirror. I was stunned that she hadn't tried to stop us and even more surprised when I watched one hand slip from the door jamb to her crotch. Kate started slowly rubbing her married pussy through her black form-fitting work slacks.
Knowing that Kate was watching us and didn't know I had spied her through the mirror excited the hell out of me. I pounded her daughter relentlessly. Gretchen was slamming back at me just as hard. One hand was attacking her clit as she growled, "Fucking ... FUCKing ... FUCKING ... CUMMING ... AGAINNNNN!"
I'm not sure what I was thinking and acted as if on automatic pilot. As Gretchen finished her orgasm, I pulled from her stuffed pussy and asked, "Had enough?"
She bellowed, "Asshole! Keep fucking me!"
I turned sideways and looked Kate in the eye. Kate's hand stopped rubbing her mound, as we stared at each other. Kate's view slid from my all-American face, wide shoulders, six-pack and thin athletic waist. I don't think her gaze made it to my thick muscled thighs, as right above stood my nine inch, wrist thick cock, covered with her daughter's pussy juice.
Kate's stare returned to my eyes, when I told her not-so-innocent daughter, "I'll fuck you to another orgasm, if I get to cum in your ass."
Gretchen still had not noticed her mother and she answered immediately, "Hell yes! I love when you cum up my ass!"
I slid back into Gretchen's tight teenage hole and pounded her for twenty minutes, until she exploded again. The entire time, Kate and I stared at each other through the mirror.
As Gretchen caught her breath and rested on all fours, I pulled from her very sloppy and well used twat, walked to her bedside table and grabbed a half-full tube of KY lube from the drawer. Kate watched intently, as I opened the tube and squirted a dollop of KY into my palm and coated my over-sized cock.
I turned my intention to Gretchen. I concentrated on preparing her asshole for me. I wasn't ignoring Kate, but I wanted to make sure Gretchen's tight back hole was stretched and properly lubricated. I started by circling my slick index finger over her pink crinkled butt hole.
I slowly opened her with one finger and then two. When she was comfortable with two fingers, her asshole was open enough to squirt more KY directly into her ass. I pushed the lube in with two and then three fingers.
Gretchen was mostly silent as I prepared her and when I asked, "Ready?, she answered, "Do it. Fuck my ass!"
When I looked at Kate, I was amazed to see that she had undone her belt and unbuttoned her pants. Her zipper was down and her right hand was stuffed into the front of her pants as she played with her cunt.
Turning my attention back to her slutty daughter, I pushed my KY slick cock against Gretchen's pink anus. I love the next part. I love watching an asshole slowly spread open. I love the obscene sound of Gretchen grunting as I invade her treasured ass.
Gretchen opened and three inches slid home. I let her adjust and slowly and gently fucked more and more cock into her super tight tunnel. Although Gretchen is a willing ass slut, her warm slick hole can only take a little bit of ass fucking. She likes to move me to orgasm as quick as possible.
She lay face down in the bed and reached both hands under her torso. One hand played with my swinging balls and the other rubbed her clit.
I picked up the pace as I felt the first stirrings. I was fucking six or seven inches of fat cock into Gretchen when she begged, "Please cum. Fuck. Please fill me with another load."
I held her hips a bit tighter, fucked her a little harder and announced, "Cuuuuming," as I shot three volleys into Gretchen's tight young anus.
That unique teenage memory flashed through my mind as I listened to the rest of my voice mail from Kate's friend Susan.
Susan's message continued, "I live in Dayton, about ninety minutes from Ohio State. Kate says you might be ... qualified ... to help me with a problem. I'll commit to sending you $100 cash, if you return this phone call and discuss my problem. If we decide to take the next step, I'll pay you an additional $400 to drive to Dayton after your classes next Friday and discuss the details in person. I'll also pay for a tank of gas. Finally, if we decide together to proceed and you stay until Saturday night, I'll pay your accommodations and food, along with another $500. I hope you'll give me a call."
Like most college students, I'm poor and struggling. I was also intrigued, so I gave Susan a call.
She answered, "I recognize the number. Thanks for calling, Chris."
"Hi Susan. Your message was ... well ... interesting. How can I help you?"
"Right to the point? I guess I like that, although I'm a little nervous." There was silence as she gathered her thoughts and then she told me, "The bottom line is ... my husband is cheating on me and I want to get even. I want more than to get even. I want revenge. When I told Kate my ultimate idea, she thought of you and she said you might help."
My only response was a silly sounding, "UUmmmm. OK?"