"Happy Halloween!" I proclaimed as I entered the home we always referred to as the Halloween House.
For many years I'd brought my kids and their friends by the van load to this home early on Halloween night. The house and the acre or so of property surrounding it was decorated like a Disney Halloween set and it got bigger and better every year. In addition to that Jim, the homeowner and party-master, always gave the kids a full sized candy bar and the parents a beer or a glass of wine. We were usually there for a half hour or so looking at the decorations before heading back to the streets to let the kids fill their candy bags. It had been my one mandatory stop for 18 Halloweens in a row.
"Welcome Captain!" Jim replied walking quickly towards the door to greet me.
"Where's the Kids?" He said with a puzzled look on his face...
"They're all grown up" I responded looking down "but you've become a habit that I just can't break."
Jim reached out his hand and shook mine vigorously. Then he folded his middle finger in and tickled the palm of my hand with it. This was actually something he'd done every year, but in the past we were surrounded by kids so I always just shined it on and went about enjoying the Halloween festivities.
He continued to stroke my palm long after we'd stopped actually shaking hands.
I pulled him close and whispered in his ear "You know, some people might think you were offering something more than candy and a drink when you do that..."
"Maybe I am." He responded out loud. A wicked smile came over his bearded face.
I quickly scanned my surroundings to be sure nobody else would hear me. Then I said "Well I'm interested if you're really offering, we just have to be discreet."
The moment it was out of my mouth I felt panic begin to set in. I only had the courage to make that statement because his hand-shake escapade had stimulated my libido and triggered the beginnings of a hard-on. I'd let down my guard. Now as I shook with fear I could only hope he really meant what I thought that signal meant...
"Hey there!" a cheerful female voice chimed out. It was Jim's wife Misty and she was just what I needed right then to snap me back from my inner terror.
We shared a quick hug and she invited me to join her and Jim in the living room for a while.
"My sister wants to greet the trick or treaters for a while and you always have to run off with your van-load of ghosts and goblins. It's about time we sat down and got to know each other." she said as she took me by the hand leading me to the living room...
I felt uncomfortable as I took a seat on the couch. Misty sat on the end chair next to my end of the couch. Jim followed a moment later with three cold beers. He handed one to Misty and one to me. He then took his place on the couch right next to me.
After a moment Misty leaned over with her elbow resting on the end table, hand on her cheek... "I sense my husband is making you nervous." She quietly said, then took a sip of her beer.
I didn't know how to react or what to say so there was a pause.
"You know we're not trying to pressure you Captain, we're just trying to seduce you..." she said as the same smile Jim had earlier spread across her pretty face.
Suddenly I felt my fears melt away "I'm certainly interested " I said.
Misty continued in a soft, seductive voice "Jim is bi-curious. Has been for as long as we've been together. A few years ago I agreed to bring a third into our bedroom if we found a man we both wanted to share. You Captain, are the only man Jim and I have agreed on. He's waited years to satisfy his curiosity."
Jim began to slowly rub my back and caress my neck as I spoke with Misty. He remained silent as she continued to explain the offer they were proposing.
"Jim and I talked about approaching you a couple of years ago, but you still had kids at home and you didn't seem interested. So we just left it alone."
The conversation paused again. I thought this was probably where I should put in my 2 cents worth and let them know where I weighed in.
"I too have been bi-curious for as long as I can recall. My wife however would not be as cooperative as you are Misty. That's why I tend to keep my guard up...until tonight."
I turned and looked Jim right in the eyes.
"You're a brave soul Jim. I could never initiate a romantic gesture to another man. Kudos to you Jim, for your courage."
I took a long drink of my beer.
Misty raised her bottle and Jim and I followed suit.
"Here's to new adventures, and the courage to experience them!" Misty toasted.
"Here here!" Jim and I said in unison.
We all sat back and took a deep breath. It was all out there and we were all in. What an interesting turn of events...
I suddenly remembered my wife was home waiting for me. I had promised her a candy bar...
"Why don't you come over for lunch tomorrow Captain." Jim ordered.
"I'll be here at 11 o'clock. I honestly can't wait."
I gave Misty a hug, a much more friendly hug than earlier, as I rose to my feet.
Jim took ahold of my shoulders and turned me towards him. I took him below his armpits and brought our bodies together for a hug. A hug that quickly became intimate as we both felt each other's hard-ons collide. Oh god. What a rush it is the first time you feel another man's arousal.
I woke up early as usual the next morning. All I could think about was meeting Jim and Misty for lunch. My mind was spinning with thoughts of what might happen. One thing that I was sure of was that I was stepping far out of my comfort zone by allowing this to proceed. On one hand I felt guilty knowing that I was about to cheat on my wife. She's pretty and very sweet to me so she definitely doesn't deserve to be hurt. At the same time though, I've experienced years sexual frustration. My wife believes that being intimate three times a month, missionary style, is a healthy sex life... I strongly disagree. I have an opportunity here to fulfill one of my greatest and most frequent fantasies — and I'm not inclined to let this chance pass by.
At breakfast my wife asked what I had planned for the day. I told her I had a lunch meeting with clients that would probably take all afternoon, but I had nothing scheduled for this morning so I'd probably just work at home and make sure I got myself prepared for my meeting.
As soon as she headed out the door, I drew a hot bath and began "preparing for my meeting."
I soaked in the hot water for a while. I was just letting my thoughts run wild. I was wondering what Jim and Misty would look like naked. I wondered what they'd think of me naked. After all, we're all in our sixties now. Jim and I both have "dad bods" but Misty is still very youthful looking. My thoughts alternate between my desire to experience the physical love of another man and all of the possibilities that entails, and the thought of making love with a woman other than my wife...
While my thoughts raged on I started to prepare my body for events that I only hoped could happen. I washed my cock so thoroughly that I almost came. Then I took a razor to the areas behind my ball sack and on back to my anus. If I got the chance to offer it to Jim I wanted to be pretty for him! Then I gave myself a thorough flushing of my insides and inserted some lube deep inside — just in case!
It was nearly 11 so I got out of the bathroom and got myself dressed. "I'll finally get to show someone my thong" I thought to myself as I stepped into my beautiful piece of lingerie (a thong I'd purchased years earlier in an attempt to impress my wife... fail.)
Then I headed out to the kitchen for a snack. I didn't figure we'd really be having much lunch so I grabbed a banana. As I peeled it my mind went directly to a dark place...I decided I'd like to practice for Jim by taking this banana whole...
I drove slowly up the street towards Jim and Misty's house. A thought flashed across my mind, a thought of turning and running, I knew that if I made it to their driveway there would be no turning back.
"Am I really ready to become gay?" I asked myself. "You're not gay. You're bisexual. You always have been. Now man up." I answered myself sternly.
I turned into their driveway and saw Jim working on putting away the decorations.
He saw me too... no turning back now.
I turned off the car and took a deep breath. Jim had stopped what he was doing and was at my car opening the door for me. I felt a twinge of panic as I knew there was no time to allow my budding woody to calm down. I feared it would be prominently displaying itself when I stepped out of the car. I was right.
My thong cupped my balls but failed to completely constrain my hardening cock and my khakis really didn't provide adequate back up. I stepped out of my car and stood face to face with the man I hoped to be making love with a short time from now. That thought alone caused my boner to become blatantly obvious.
"Is that a banana in your pocket or are you just glad to see me?" Jim said with a chuckle.
"Well at least I know where that banana went now, anyway." I responded with a blush and a smile.
Jim moved to shut my door and nonchalantly grasped my swollen package, giving it a quick squeeze before he began to walk back to his pile of Halloween decorations.
"Misty's inside waiting to prepare our lunch. Why don't you go on in and give her a hand." He called back to me.
Inside Misty was waiting for me. Her eyes lit up and greeted me with a smile. Then she brought herself close, rose up on her tip-toes and we shared one of the most passionate kisses I've ever been a part of. By now my hard-on had relaxed some, but I was obviously still engorged. Misty gave my cock and balls a squeeze and let out a soft coo, like a dove, expressing her approval.
"I think we picked the right man." she said. Then she kissed me hard.