"Jamie, is this a male or a female student?" I asked, pointing at the picture on my roster.
She looked at me over her glasses and said, "Does it make a difference?"
"Not for grades. No. But, for putting students in groups and referring to their work, you know? Things like that happen in class. I'll need to use third person pronouns—he, she, him, her—and I won't know which one to use."
She sighed, looked at the picture and said, "Aryn's unsure of her gender."
"'Her.' Got it. Thanks, Jamie." I left the counseling center.
***
I taught mostly the juniors, but I had one section of English 12C—what my fellow English teachers called "Supersenior English." It was the class no one wanted. I had all the Superseniors—the students who failed to earn enough English credits to graduate during four years of high school and needed to come back for a semester or two.
Our school district is an affluent one: lots of money and highly involved parents. At a previous teaching gig, nine times out of ten, when a student failed to graduate, they were pretty much gone, never saw them again. They maybe ended up in some GED program down the road. But here, most kids end up coming back for the Supersenior classes. 18, 19 years old, and they come back. Strange place.
My roster for English-12C included Aryn Hunter McGrath.
When she walked into the classroom, I looked for signs of femaleness. Aryn had a boy's short hair, buzzed around her neck and ears. Yet, her mahogany brown hair was, perhaps, styled in a way that suggested a feminine attentiveness. Aryn didn't wear make up, but she didn't need to. It was a youthful and blemish-free face, with big brown, almost black, eyes. The shape was definitely not masculine.
Yet, Aryn had a man's bearing. She crossed her legs like a man—foot on the knee—stuck her hands into her jean pockets like a man, and strutted like a man. She looked at things the way some men do—like there is dominance or ownership in what they see. There was a kind of rugged confidence and carelessness about Aryn's demeanor. She didn't give a fuck who thought what.
If there were breasts, I couldn't see them, nor if there were hips. Aryn was straight as a board and skinny. She was on the taller side for a female, about five-seven. Unlike many of her female classmates, she didn't wear tight clothes to look hot; she wore loose jeans and tee shirts for comfort.
Like with every new class, I asked the students to fill out a little index card. The usual contact information went on it, but I always asked them to write in some information that told me a little bit about them—what activities they were involved in, hobbies, where they worked, a favorite book, song, show or film.
Aryn's card looked like it was written by a boy—it had a guy's shitty, chicken-scratch handwriting. She wrote that she was looking for a job, and she wrote down that her favorite film was Heat. Next to it, she wrote, "I love movies."
One of the things I really believe in as a teacher and a coach, a thing I really go out of my way to do, is to show an interest in my students' interests. I'll go to the restaurant where they work. For my underclass students, I'll see them at their performances or games. I'll watch their favorite show, listen to the song they really like, or rent their favorite movie and watch it. Then, I'll try to have conversation with them about it. These were the kinds of things that built good relationships with the students, and that, to me, was the essential ingredient to both a comfortable classroom and student learning.
Meanwhile, I took notice of Aryn—I had a bit more curiosity about her than the others; she was unique, a mystery. She usually only hung out in the halls with girls, but not the way other girls hang out with girls. The female students Aryn spent time with interacted with her like she was a boy—almost like they flirted with her.
Her flock of female followers consisted mostly of the ones who didn't conform—the ones way into Japanese animation, the ones whose bodies didn't quite meet society's expectations, the moody ones who dyed their hair bizarre colors, the ones with extra piercings. These suburban high school misfits orbited Aryn in the halls.
I only rarely saw her converse with a male student. In fact, for the first several weeks of class, she would never look at me when she answered one of my questions. She didn't volunteer; I called on her. When she responded, she would look at her desk or at another student.
I spoke with Aryn's previous English teacher about her.
She told me Aryn had hated her. My colleague said, "I didn't cut her any slack, and Aryn just quit on me."
"What's her deal? The look, the clothes, the girls. Do you know?" I asked.
My colleague looked at me strangely and said, "Isn't it obvious?"
"No."
"She's a lesbian. I've heard other students talking about her."
"Huh," I said, "Is she—does she want to become a guy or something?"
"As to that, I don't know, but she's gay. That I know for sure."
I asked her how she knew, and she told me a story about Aryn and some girl back in a junior high restroom.
I wasn't sure how much stock I'd put in a middle school rumor. I thanked her and left.
I figured it was time to reach out to Aryn. I put a sticky note on her desk while I was lecturing about our personal narrative paper. I let her know that I was going to watch Heat that weekend. I was in the back of the classroom, yapping about types of narratives, and I watched her read the note. She turned around and looked at me. A first.
So, I watched the film. I really liked it: Pacino and the cops vs. De Niro and the robbers. It was great, and there was this riveting city shoot out, maybe one of the best I'd ever seen.
When I walked into the classroom on Monday, Aryn watched me. I gave her a thumbs up and nodded with a big smile. She smiled, too. Her big brown eyes shined, and she never looked so feminine as just then.
When the bell rang, I was sitting at my desk. Aryn came over.
"I loved it, Aryn. That robbery shoot out? Incredible. And so many storylines all woven together. It was deep. Rich."
She nodded. "My favorite scene is where they fool the cops at the shipyard."
"Yeah, that was pretty cool."
"Think you'll ever watch it again?"
"Sure," I said.
"Will you do me a favor, then?" she asked.