As will be pretty obvious to those who've read my other stories, this is a sequel to "Bad Cop, Worse Cop." I've found I like Mike LaFratta, partly because I can feel good about making horrible things happen to him.
Enjoy!
* * *
So here was the problem with Daniella (and I was embarrassed it had taken me this long to figure it out).
In bed she was just about perfect. Young and supple, limber in all the best ways, with the smooth firm skin and shapely body she shared with her sister, she was built ideally for the kind of fucking I liked to give. She had a natural sense of balance, making sure she kept her center of gravity low when I took her from behind; on the other hand, when she was on top, she knew just where to perch so that I didn't get tired.
Some girls never figure that out; they just drive themselves into your intestines from above, leaving you farting uncontrollably as they fuck you. Daniella wasn't like that. She wasn't quite the perfect sexual specimen her sister was, but she was close enough. Way above average. Very deserving of my semen.
The problem with her started once she got out of bed.
There was none of her sister's low, confident voice. She had a nasally, whining overtone when she got stressed, which was often, and frankly that was a chore to listen to. I got enough of that shrill, mopey-tense-female shit from Roberta. She got easily flustered; between the sheets she kept her cool and maintained her poise, but once she got her clothes on it seemed she couldn't make a decision to save her sweet, peachy ass.
This afternoon, the subject was prom dresses.
"I mean, it would be fucking brutal if I ended up in a shitty color just because I didn't give the dye enough time to set. But, like, what if I get all fat and gross over the next month, and can't cram my tits into the dress? Like, I could get it now and have it be the right color, or get it later and hope it fits." She looked at me, her eyes big and rimmed in pink, and it occurred to me she just might be smoking weed again. "I just feel like I'm fucked either way."
Maybe you should be,
I reflected, keeping my mouth shut.
You get much more decisive when you have a dick in your slit.
I cleared my throat. "You're not going to get all fat and gross in just a month," I pointed out, trying not to sound as exasperated as I felt. "Look at you. You're a fucking dime. You'd need to spazz out and do nothing but eat the whole time. No exercise..." I trailed off. She didn't do any exercise as it was, either, other than fucking me. I shook my head. "Just buy the goddamn dress and forget about it."
She fretted. "It's so fucking easy for guys," she spat. I wondered vaguely whether she was starting her period; this was extra moody, even for her. "Just make sure the tie matches, and you're all done." She frowned, though it was a pretty becoming look with her eyelashes down like that, all frustrated; I felt my dick twitch, felt a sudden urge to nibble on that protruding lower lip of hers. Or hell, just present her with my cock and let her suck on it, with the dual benefit of getting a sweet blowjob and simultaneously shutting her up.
I sighed. I'd started fucking her on her sister's referral, and I wished now that I'd listened to the fine print. "I mean, she's a fucking awesome little bitch," Tori had explained, her breath stinking of my cum. "But she's... well, she's not like me." Of course not. Nobody was like the splendid, the incomparable Tori.
Something nagged at me. "Why dye it at all?" I frowned. "Why not just buy a dress that's already the right color?"
She looked at me then with an expression only possible from a high-school girl, righteous and Pope-level correct in her opinions and with no way of understanding why nobody else was capable of understanding the world with her level of sophistication. I swallowed involuntarily; it was a highly, highly fuckable expression. I felt my cock twitch again, more vigorously. Shit. What was it with these Lynne sisters? Only eighteen, and already so effortlessly sexy...
She knew it, too. She stared at me a long time. "If you're mocking me," she said calmly, "I'll stop fucking you. Are you mocking me, Mike?"
Ah yes. This was why I kept tolerating her. That face... Her eyes were smoky-soft under her long lashes, not green like her sister's but with a sharpness to them, a slight lift at the corners, that was unforgettable, especially when she looked up at me with a mouthful of my cock. Her sister's occasional acne, her sister's thin lips, but the rest was all her own, and all gorgeous. I couldn't stop myself from reaching out to stroke her cheek, which wasn't the kind of thing I was known for. "You'll be fine, Dani."
Her lips worked a tad, almost smiling, but she didn't usually let herself do that. Smirks, yes. Smiles, no. It went against her image. "Fuck you," she murmured automatically; it was just something she was always saying, sort of an in-joke by now. So, my penis swelling steadily under the sheet, I gave the expected response.
"When? Right now, or later?" There was lust in my eyes; there had to be. She always knew when I was getting turned on.
"Right now, Officer Mike." Like many girls, she got off on fucking cops. None of them ever liked to admit that, but I'd benefitted from it for years now.
Old Larry had gotten me started on that shit, back when he'd been a sexual legend on the East Adams police force, back before he'd wound up in the chair. "We call them Badge Bunnies, Mikey," he'd told me back when I'd been a rookie, fresh out of the Air Force. "With those kinds of bitches, you could be the hunchback of Notre fucking Dame, and it won't matter. Put a badge and a gun on a guy like that, and the Bunnies will fall over themselves for the privilege of taking your dick in their ass."