Content warning: this chapter, again, contains cuckoldry. Same as before, this is written from the POV of the male cheater, not the cuckold. There is also dialogue at the end that references abusive family relationships - but if you've been following this far, you're probably okay with that.
Many thanks to everyone who commented on the last chapter. I know I'm not usually this fast with my content, but I tried a little harder to get the potluck dealt with before the end of the month. Thank you all for your patience. I hope you enjoy.
It probably goes without saying that my encounter with Marilyn in the bathroom had easily put the fear of God back in me. Once I was out of there, I did not even know where to head next. The living room? My friend's room? Marilyn was probably in the first and her grandson in the latter. Neither option felt appealing at all.
I lingered in the corridor for a while, physically and mentally trapped between those two unpleasant possibilities. All this time, I was terrified of anyone walking into the corridor and catching me there, standing around aimlessly.
When Betty stumbled out of Karla's room, I nearly had a heart attack. Karla had done a good job disguising the rope marks. She must have used makeup on her sister's neck. The sex, however, had been a little harder to cover up. Betty still looked like she had just woken up. Her eyes had a sort of emptiness to them that felt obvious in a very dangerous way. She shot me a vacant smile once she noticed me.
"Hey..."
"You do
not
want to go into the living room," I hurried to whisper.
"Huh?" Betty tilted her head sideways. Adorable, really. Irresistible even, if I wasn't so hopelessly terrified.
"Your mother... She knows about me and Karla. She might be able to tell you've just had sex."
To my growing frustration, Betty only blinked once and paused. I know it was probably my fault she was acting this silly to begin with, but at that point I was not in the mood for accountability.
"Peter," she shot me a lazy smile. "You don't know the things I got past my mom over the years. I'll be fine."
I wanted to grab her and shake her until she saw some sense. I wanted to snarl at her. I would have even considered slapping or pinching her a bit. Unfortunately, I had a feeling she would do something stupid if I were to do any of that. The last thing I wanted was more attention from other guests in that potluck. Clutching my fists, I could only watch as Betty tried to walk casually back into the living room. I couldn't stop staring at her until she turned and greeted her family. Even her voice sounded unfocused. Not that I could really hear much else. Behind me, another sudden voice gained priority by virtue of startling me.
"Good. That saves us some time."
I turned around to find Karla locking her bedroom door once again, now from the outside. She didn't seem concerned at all about the fact she had just allowed her own sister to potentially make the affair even more widely known.
"Karla, we-"
She pushed her index finger against my lips in a deliberately slow motion.
"Shh... You don't want the kids to hear you, right?" Karla pointed at my friend's door. It
was
close enough to make me reconsider speaking up.
"Then-" I tried to whisper, but Karla just pushed me against the wall and pressed her body against mine.
"Mmm... You showed Betty who's boss, back there. I should have made my son tie me up instead... It should have been me..."
"Karla..." I tried again in an exhausted tone.
"I know baby..." she stroked my cheek. "We'll have more chances to tear each other apart and play with the pieces. But right now... I need you to take a piece of me this instant."
"Will you focus?!" I growled, trying to push her away. "We have a problem."
"Indeed we do..." she wrapped her arms around me, still squishing her curvy body against mine. I felt her nails trace a tantalizing path along the back of my neck. "
You
need to fuck my adulterous pussy again, and yet we're both still dressed."
"Marilyn
knows
, Karla," I grabbed her by the shoulders, shaking her mildly. "She knows about us."
My only response from her was a mild bite on the neck, along with a couple of kisses there.
"God... this corridor won't do," she muttered. "Not if we want real fun."
"Karla-"
"The kitchen! Follow me."
She even grabbed my hand, the crazy woman. I had to pull myself free as she led the way there. The kitchen was literally in front of the living room. Whatever was going on inside Karla's head at that specific moment, it was far from rational. I didn't even have the heart to glance at the couch to search for Marilyn or Betty. For all I knew, the secret was already out and we were all doomed.
Karla only closed the door halfway through. Typical of her to disregard security the more aroused she got. Without delay, she bent over the sink. Her perfect round ass wiggled alluringly.
"I don't care what you do to me, Peter. Fuck my pussy. Fuck my ass. Pull my hair. Waterboard me. Whatever. Just do it
now
!"
I couldn't even unpack her batshit insane demands at this point. Ironic, I know. Here she was, Karla in total meltdown due to her arousal, and I couldn't even enjoy the control I had over her due to my own inner panic.
"Look at me, Karla," I leaned on the sink, right next to her. "Look at me! Your mother, Marilyn, knows about the affair. She knows when you've had sex just by looking at you!"
"Peter, please..." her words came out pleadingly. I had never heard such a genuine tone from her. "I am begging you to fuck me now.
Please.
"
She pulled her jeans down with some difficulty, just enough to bare her ass and pussy. Her green eyes glanced upwards at me. There was no malice in them now. Just an endless well of desperate lust and supplication. It was a lovely thing to see, marred only by the unfortunate circumstances.