"Okay," Cathy began. "I got there and this so-called roommate, Dave, answers the door. And he makes it pretty obvious that he knows all about why I'm there, you know?" Cathy paused long enough to give Tracy a look of disapproval before continuing. Tracy ignored it. "So anyway, he lets me in and I follow him upstairs and Tony's waiting in the living room. He says hi and introduces me to Dave. And then..." Cathy paused.
There had been some sort of vibe, hadn't there? She had sensed something, even though she didn't know exactly what it was. At the time, she probably thought it was just that Tony seemed to have told Dave why Cathy had come over. Who wouldn't be a little embarrassed? Standing in front of a guy who knew she was there to suck his roommate's cock?
"And then?" Tracy prompted impatiently.
"Well, and then.... nothing," Cathy shrugged. "We all stood there looking at each other for a long time. At least, it seemed like a long time to me."
"That's it? You just looked at each other?" Tracy sounded incredulous.
"Well, yeah," Cathy said with another shrug. "But then... well, Tony started to rub himself through his jeans. And then, well... Dave started doing it too. And they were looking at me... well, maybe like predators or something." Cathy took a deep breath and let out a sigh. The electricity in the air had been like nothing else she had ever experienced. Her heart had been racing, her hands sweaty and the adrenaline rush almost intolerable. She hadn't known what she wanted to do or what she would do. But the charge tingling through her body barely allowed her to stand still. And they had just stood there, rubbing themselves, letting the tension mount.
She tried to convey the feeling to Tracy , but her words sounded woefully inadequate.
"I just couldn't stand it," she said. "I wanted something to... to... happen or... something. Just something to break the... the tension. I could hardly stand it anymore." She took another deep breath and let out a long sigh. "It was... unnerving, electrifying, exciting and scary and... well, you get the picture. And they just kept me hanging there like that, like cats playing with a mouse. Yeah, that's a pretty good way to describe it. Like they already knew they had me.
"Which of course," Cathy shot another look at Tracy , "they probably already knew, thanks to you."
"No thanks necessary!" Tracy chirped. Cathy threw her another half-hearted sour look before continuing.
"Then Tony just says, 'Why don't you do Dave first?'" Cathy paused for emphasis. "I just looked at him. I heard his words and I knew what he meant, I just couldn't believe it. I was surprised, truly. How stupid is that? I mean, I went over there to give a bj and next thing I know, two guys are staring at me and rubbing themselves. Why was I surprised that they figured I'd do both of them?" Cathy almost flashed another look at Tracy , but only another shrug came out.
"I mean," Cathy continued. "If I'm enough of a slut to go over there and suck Tony off every week, why would I be surprised that they would think I was enough of a slut to suck off one of his buddies too, right? It wasn't until afterward that I put it all together with you and Trish and you two screwing with me again.
"At the time, I was just plain old surprised."
"Well, you have to admit," laughed Tracy , "you WERE enough of a slut to suck them both off!" Cathy tried to flash another look, but a smile crept out instead. She let out a small laugh and nodded.
"Yeah, I guess I am. Who knew?" The corner of her mouth curled up in chagrin. "I had never seen the guy before in my life and I sucked his dick! With Tony watching, no less!" She shook her head, as if in disbelief. But inside, was she really so surprised at herself? No, not really.
She had been struggling with the idea of being on a schedule. Of having what she craved rationed out to her in weekly parcels. Suddenly there was more to be had. And she, apparently, was enough of a slut to make the most of it.
"So then...? Tracy prodded.
"Well, what do you think, 'then?'!" Cathy said with mock sarcasm. "He--Dave--unzipped his pants and next thing I knew, I was staring at his cock." She shrugged. "It was pretty nice. Not as big as Tony's, but pretty good sized. He wasn't a hundred percent hard, but it was getting harder as he stroked it. I just stared at it for a minute. Then Tony said something like, 'Well, what are you waiting for?' and... well, I guess you pretty much know what happened next!" Cathy smiled sheepishly, feeling the warm tingle of a blush on her cheeks.
"Just like that? Right there?" Tracy asked with little squeal in her voice. Cathy nodded. "Details! Give me details!"