This is part two of a four part story. It may be difficult to follow without the first part (Weekend in Amsterdam - Thursday). If you don't like stories where the wife strays from her husband, please read a different story rather than getting irritated!
- - - - - - - - - - -
Friday
Rudi woke early the next morning because he had a photo-shoot to do at the set of a theatre production. He got dressed and ready quietly, without waking Susan. On his way out of the apartment he stopped by the couch and gently shook Mike awake.
The latter seemed disoriented and looked at Rudi blankly as he said "I have to go out. Let yourselves out of the apartment when you want to. Susan is still asleep upstairs and I suggest you go to her. She will need an understanding husband when she wakes up!" Mike nodded blankly. Rudi then continued, "Susan is an exquisite fuck. You are a very lucky man." And with that he left.
As Rudi left, Mike snapped fully awake and the events of the previous evening crowded back into his head. It struck him hard and with a surprising clarity, given his hangover, that his marriage was finished. What other conclusion could he draw from Susan's behaviour? She had cheated on him and had done so literally in front of him. She clearly needed something other than what he could offer her and he realised that now, in the cold light of day.
Upstairs Susan stirred in Rudi's bed and then also woke with a start. She recalled in horror - and for some reason Edgar's Munch's 'The Scream' flashed before her eyes - what she had done. What on earth had she been thinking? She recalled Mike seeing her fucking Rudi and she buried her face in her hands and started gently sobbing. How would Mike react? He was sure to be hurt, but she could not imagine how he would respond - she had no precedent from which to judge. And if it got messy, what would happen to their two children, currently blissfully unaware at boarding school. Susan hurriedly got dressed in the skirt and blouse she had been wearing but despite a good look around the room she couldn't find her bra or thong and silently cursed Rudi, who had presumably put them somewhere.
Mike got up and washed his face in the bathroom. He glanced at Rudi's photographs again and thought ruefully that a lot had happened to his life in the few short hours since he looked at them last. He felt the ice of Susan's betrayal seeping into his heart. He kept asking himself why she had done this, but couldn't come up with any answer other than that she no longer had any feelings for him.
As he came out of the bathroom Susan was coming down the stairs. She faltered for a split second before rushing down the last few steps and virtually throwing herself at Mike, sobbing into his chest that she was sorry for what she had done, didn't know what had got into her and could Mike ever forgive her? Mike stood stock still with his arms by his side and in a cold voice that barely masked his anger, said, "I think we should go back to the hotel now".
Susan looked up at him, through tears, and was terrified by the grim look on his face. Any thought that she had that the situation was somehow retrievable vanished. She bowed her head and followed him numbly out of the apartment and onto the street, where Mike hailed a cab to take them to the hotel. They journeyed in silence, looking at the passing streets but lost in their own thoughts - Mike's bitter and Susan's a frenzied loop of "Oh my god, this is bad! What have I done?"
As they entered the hotel room, Mike said "We need to talk. About last night. About everything."
Playing for time, Susan responded, "I know. But I need to wash and change and clear my head. Let's talk after I've had a shower."
Susan's outward calmness belied a variety of conflicting thoughts and emotions. She examined these as she stood under the shower hoping the hot jet of water could somehow wash away her guilt. She still loved Mike deeply. And she couldn't quite explain what had driven her to be unfaithful to him with Rudi. But then thoughts of Rudi came back to her. She had had the most wild and enjoyable sex of her life and she felt deeply attached to Rudi for providing that. And deep down she recognized that she really, really would like to fuck him again. She enjoyed toying with the word 'fuck' - she rarely used the word but it was entirely appropriate in this context. She had never been so thoroughly fucked. She even got a little bit wet again thinking about it as she soaped her body. But her brief night of passion had probably ruined her entire life, judging by Mike's understandable reaction. As she rinsed off and stepped out of the shower, she recognized that she still had not resolved what to say to Mike. She wanted to have 'the conversation' away from the hotel in case Mike caused a scene, so she grimly suggested a coffee in a nearby cafe.
Once they were sat at the cafe table with their coffees and pastries, Mike looked at Susan and asked, "Do you still love me?"
"Very much, Mike. But do you still love me after what I did last night?" She asked in return, immediately regretting throwing her actions in his face.
Mike paused, then said, "I'm not sure what I feel. Betrayed, I guess. Hurt. Cheated on. I just feel cold and empty. I don't understand where last night came from. How did you think I would feel after seeing you fucking another man?"
Mike had to fight not to spit these last few words out. He wanted to remain as calm as possible.
Susan looked at her hands on the table and paused before saying, "I know there is nothing I can say that will make this better. I don't know what possessed me last night. All that I can say is that I am deeply, deeply sorry for the hurt that I have caused you and I would do anything to save our marriage. Anything."
Mike was struck by this abject apology, which was very out of character for Susan, but couldn't reconcile her words with last night's actions.
"But seeing you like that last night, Susan... you have no idea how that made me feel." It struck Mike as he was saying this that he didn't really understand his feelings the previous night either.
He ploughed on. "I just regret that you have never told me about your sexual desires. It's clear to me that I have failed to satisfy you this last 15 years. We could have worked something out between the two of us with better communication." Mike immediately regretted implying that it was somehow his fault that Susan had fucked Rudi. But deep down he worried that it might be the case.
Now it was Susan's turn to pause. She noted once again the sense of finality about Mike's tone, indicating there was no longer any hope for their relationship. This tightened the knot of dread in her stomach. She realised that she had been passive in the bedroom with Mike, but until last night she thought she had been content with the way things were. She could have communicated better with Mike, been more open to his advances. But the truth, she now realised, was that she could never get the unbridled joy from his cock that she had experienced with Rudi. But she was desperate not to lose Mike and the life she had with him, the life they had built together. Rudi held a powerful attraction to her but she knew it would never be more than sex, fantastic though that sex was. She could forego that forever and return to her normal life with Mike, if he would accept her back.
In the face of her silence, Mike went on "you know, I have often fantasised about you being fucked by another man. I've no idea why. Maybe it's because I knew deep down that you had in you what I saw last night, that you were much more highly sexed than you demonstrated with me and that I wanted you to experience what you seem unable to experience with me. But in my fantasy I was always in control - consenting to you being a 'hotwife' - and it was always with my permission. Last night you were simply unfaithful. I still can't understand how you could have done that with me just downstairs."
Susan was deeply shocked by Mike's revelation about his fantasy. Was it just a way for him to get permission to stray himself? She didn't feel she could justify her actions in any way and was still lost for words.
Mike asked "how many times did he make you cum?" And when Susan still didn't answer, he continued "I counted three times, that I know of".
Susan blushed and looked down, her mind flying back to the previous evening. "You don't want to know."
"Yes I do - how many times?"
"I think it was six." Susan whispered quietly.
"Jesus!" exclaimed Mike, feeling both dread but also a twitching in his cock at the same time. He heard himself pressing her for details. "Tell me about them."
Susan took a deep breath and said, "The first one was on the dance floor."
"Oh my god!" Mike said, dismayed. "So Rudi had already fucked you when you held my hand in the taxi?"
"No." Susan responded and, without intending to, added the detail, "He fingered me to orgasm."
"So you went back to his place fully intending to fuck him?" Mike asked.
Susan looked down guiltily again and said, "Yes. I don't know what got into me. I was probably high and drunk. But I had felt his cock in his trousers on the dance floor and knew I wanted it inside me."
She looked Mike in the eye and asked, "Can you ever forgive me? I acted like a slut. But I love you and really don't want to lose you! I will do anything to keep our marriage together."
Mike realized that for some strange reason the idea of Susan feeling Rudi's cock on the dance floor and her openness about wanting to fuck him was making him hard.
"I'm not sure I will ever completely forgive you." He said. "You still haven't got beyond telling me about the first of your six orgasms." Mike silently calculated that Rudi had made Susan cum more times in one night than he had in over a month. He wasn't sure how the conversation was shifting away from Susan apologizing to her describing sex with Rudi.
"Well, we fucked twice when we first arrived at his apartment."