Maybe I was too naΓ―ve but I really thought that Gary Morgan loved me -- Abby Prentice.
I had moved to the city where my best friend, Jean Williams, lived about a year after college to accept a good job and met Gary at a party hosted by Jean soon thereafter. I was immediately struck by how cultured and smart he was -- and the fact that he was good eye candy didn't hurt either. I was thrilled that he called me the day after the party and asked me out.
After about five or six dates I was in love with Gary. He was three years older than my twenty three and seemed so stable and mature -- in addition to being hot. Then when we first had sex the deal was sealed as far as I was concerned.
Instead of just fucking my brains out the night that he figured out that I was a "sure thing" he slowly disrobed me in his classy apartment, laid me gently on his bed, and then pleasured both my titties and pussy. I was trying hard to reach his cock -- I was desperate compared to his methodical -- but he held me off. Only after he had sucked my nipples to the point that he would have consumed a quart of milk had I been nursing, and then manipulated my pussy and clit so that I was driven to two spectacular fireworks display orgasms did he begin to penetrate me.
Showing him to be the gentleman that he was he rolled on a condom (the fact that the box he got it from said "Trojan Magnum XL" indicated that I was in for a real treat) before actual penetration. His penetration was also slow, allowing me to get used to his size. Once he was buried, however, he turned into an animal and brought me through three major orgasms before he grunted and filled the condom.
The day after our first copulation I promised to get an STD test and display my birth control record to him if he desired because I wanted him bareback. The condom fuck with him was the best of my life but I imagined that a bareback fuck would be even better. He readily agreed, and the next weekend I was proven correct when after the first time that he fucked me bareback I passed out from sensory overload.
I guess that I was giddy as a result of my relationship with Gary because Jean would laugh at me when I told her how great the sex was and say "You're like a toddler with a new toy, Abby."
My response was "No toddler ever had a toy so wonderful."
After Gary and I had been going together about two months Jean met a guy that she really liked. Burt Cavanaugh was a nice guy a few years older than Jean and as laid-back as Jean was high-strung, leading me to believe that they were a good match since each one's strengths were the other one's weaknesses. Gary and I often double-dated with Jean and Burt.
I was really hoping for a ring after Gary and I had been going together for about a year when suddenly -- without warning -- he broke it off with me. At least he had the decency to do it in person, but I think that he regretted that because I was a basket case. I asked him to tell me why but all he was willing to say was that he wasn't ready to settle down and didn't want to string me along. I thought that was a cop-out but after some initial begging I regained my dignity and walked away, very sad.
I almost drove my best friend Jean crazy opening my heart to her. Despite how high-strung she was she seemed to be good at calming me down. When I learned a couple of weeks after my tragedy that she had broken up with Burt I commiserated with her but she didn't need it. "I just told Burt that we needed a break," she told me, indicating that she was the one to break it off.
Jean did help my self-confidence telling me that I was great relationship material for any man and even fixed me up with a couple of guys who were really hot, but I had a really hard time getting over Gary. I finally was relatively successful in putting him out of my mind when I heard that he had moved to NYC.
After I heard that Gary had moved to NYC when Jean and I were having a night out with the girls she told me "I think that I made a mistake with Burt. I really missed him so I called him up and we're going out tomorrow night."
I was really happy for Jean and gave her a big hug because I thought that they were great together. I saw them at a party hosted by a mutual friend a few weeks after that and I went up and gave Burt a big hug. He seemed surprised by that and how thick Jean and I were which puzzled me somewhat, but by the end of the evening he was acting just like he always did when I was with Gary and he was with Jean and gave me a smiling hug and kiss on the cheek when the night ended.