INTRODUCTION: Here it is, the final part.
I hope you've all enjoyed the ride. There are some questions still unanswered with a few of the characters, of course, but I've got to leave something for future stories, right?
Please take the time to comment. I'm really curious to see how you all feel about how this turns out.
Thanks again!
CHAPTER NINE
They were both at my apartment this time. We were sitting on the floor eating grilled cheese with bacon, tomato, and spinach and sipping tomato soup from big mugs. Grilled cheese and tomato soup, it was my favorite meal from childhood kicked up a slight notch. But I couldn't muster up a warm cozy feeling as I ate and listened to Whitney and Rebecca think out loud as if I weren't even present.
"That really does change things," Whitney said, her voice soft. "I mean, I can really kinda see it from her point of view."
"Assuming you believe her," Rebecca snapped.
"But it all makes sense, right? I mean, if she didn't really love him, she could've left, too."
"Or keep on with that boyfriend she latched onto while just toning it down a bit."
"But he said they were happier at the end than at the beginning. And that the look on her face when he brought up having children, how do you explain that?"
"Fuck, I don't know," Rebecca said. "Biological clock or something."
"I don't think so. Her answer is the easiest and it makes the most sense. That's when she realized for sure that he wasn't gonna be ditching out. That's when the arrangement finally clicked into a true marriage."
"Yeah, but it was still based on lies. All of it. And she was part of them. Think about it, if she really thought he was in the know, she's gonna just make snide comments now and then. Never once really bring it up and out in the open?"
"There is that," Whitney agreed. "It is a bit farfetched. I mean, I can see it coming out real easily in a fight or something. That ever happen, Mark?"
"Huh?" I said, listening but not really hearing them.
"You two ever have fights? Yell at each other and throw shit in each other's face?"
I shrugged. "Sure. Doesn't everyone?"
"And she never threw this in your face? The arrangement?"
"Yeah," I said, then, "no. I guess so. I mean, they'd be the same snide comments, just yelled instead of joked about. You know. 'I don't know why I ever agreed to marry you,' shit like that."
"See?" Whitney said. "I can see it playing out like that, can't you? Especially if she thought he was in the know the whole time."
"Bullshit," Rebecca adroitly countered.
"So what d'ya think?" Whitney asked me.
"I don't know. I think I believe her, but I'm not sure it makes a difference."
"So you believe her?" Rebecca asked, astounded at my apparent naivete.
"Yeah, I do. You weren't there, Bec. She was a total wreck. I can't see her being that good an actress."
"Fooled you all those years you were together, though."
"She wasn't acting then. She was just being Sandy; making the best out of a bad situation at first, then genuinely just trying to make the best out of . . . well, out of our marriage. Trying to keep it together. So yeah, I believe her. It all fits."
"Yeah, but-- "
"You didn't see her face the few times she talked about our folks," I cut in. "It wasn't even anger yet. She was still trying to wrap her head around it, like she couldn't believe they'd never told me."
Rebecca snorted, I pushed my plate aside, and Whitney put her hand atop mine. "I think you need to see her again. To talk this through. The divorce is still there if you want it."
"And you should take it," Rebecca insisted.
"But," Whitney continued, looking over at Rebecca in annoyance, "you don't want to look back ten years from now and wonder what if. What if she'd been serious? What if your dream girl really was in love with you and wanted to have your babies and grow old and die with you? What if-- "
"What if she fucks around on you again and again and you just sit back and take it," Rebecca interjected. "What if you continue playing along with their games--all of them--and they win. They all get what they want. Daddy Truelson gets the White House and your daddy gets the Majority Leader position. What do you get, Mark?"
I stood and left them sitting there, almost running to my bedroom and shutting the door behind me. I needed to get away and think this through.
I laid on my bed and pondered. Whitney made solid points. We were all three of us lawyers, and we intuitively knew how we all thought. Law school does that to you; it fucks up otherwise normal thought processes. Still, they'd hammered it into our heads in criminal law: Actions without the requisite intent are mere actions. If you're on a roof and you trip and bump a brick and it falls and kills someone, it's not murder. It's an accident. If you're on the same roof, you see people walking below, and you push off the brick, it's at least voluntary manslaughter, and more likely second degree murder. You see someone you know and intentionally push the brick at them, it's first degree murder. All three scenarios you caused the brick to fall and kill someone, but the outcomes all differ based on what you intended to do.
But Rebecca was right, too. Wilful blindness is not a defense. If you intentionally push that brick not knowing whether anyone's on the street below, it's still gonna fall into the second category, voluntary manslaughter at least.
So I guess the issue was whether Whitney wilfully blinded herself. Did she intuitively sense my ignorance? Should she have said something? Would I have played it any differently in her shoes? The last one was particularly difficult because I'd have to put myself in the place of someone as incredibly popular being foisted upon me.
There was a soft knock at the door. "Can I come in?" Rebecca said, opening the door and poking her head through.
I looked at her, and she hesitated before stepping in and closing the door behind her. She walked to the bed and sat down beside me, placing her hand on my thigh.
"I'm sorry," she said. "I want her to be a bitch because you didn't deserve any of this, y'know?"
"You don't need to-- "
"Yeah, I do. I told you that first night I don't make it a habit to sleep with married men, and here I've let myself begin falling for one. And that's not fair to you. Especially now."
I sat up and leaned against the wall, looking at her.
"Why haven't you ever been married?"