The Janitor's Closet
Chapter One:
I let out an exasperated sigh. This was not going the way I'd hoped. When I suggested my wife take a lover, I'd envisioned watching a young frat boy with a smooth body having his way with her. I'd seen her checking out just that type. To be honest, I liked young pretty boys too.
"Why Carl?" I asked, hoping to change Katelyn's mind. My wife and I were both professors at the local university. Carl worked there as the janitor. We were an attractive early 40s couple. Both accomplished, both PhDs. Carl looked like he was closer to 50, thick limbs and coarse. On top of that, he was kind of a dick. "That guy's a royal asshole," I said in protest.
"He's perfectly nice to me," Katelyn responded.
"He's nice to you, because he wants to fuck you."
"Isn't that the point, Michael," Katelyn said back. "He wants to
fuck me
, I want to
fuck him
, and you
want to watch
. You're getting everything you wanted, I don't see what the problem is," Katelyn said with a challenging smile. She knew exactly what the issue was. The issue was that Carl was dismissive toward me, outright rude. The other issue: she was right about everything else.
It was summer on campus, and Katelyn was wearing a yellow sundress with nothing else underneath. She looked at me and said, "Take off your clothes, Michael." I quickly did as she instructed. Not being particularly hairy to start with, Katelyn had me keep my entire body shaved. Furthermore, I got hard immediately, standing naked in front of her she asked. "How long has it been since you had an orgasm, Michael?"
"Three days," I replied. "It was Tuesday."
"I'll see if Carl can come by this weekend. I don't want you to cum until then," she said firmly.
"Should we talk about this?," I pleaded.
"We did talk about this," she sounded like she was getting angry.
"
You said
you wanted this."
"
You said
you would respect my choice."
I asked
are you sure?'' Michael stood there with his head hung.
Katelyn raised her voice. "
I recall telling you once I get started, I'm not going to want to stop."
"Do you remember those conversations, Michael?"
"Do you remember me asking OVER and OVER if you were ok with this?"
Katelyn was on the verge of getting seriously pissed. That didn't happen very often, and it was kinda scary when it did.
I nodded yes. She took my hard cock in her hand and started to stroke and tug at it. My resolve weakened immediately. She was right anyway. I did want this. Just not with that guy.
"Do you think Carl has a bigger dick than you?" she asked tauntingly. My dick was about 5 inches and average in girth. "I mean, your dick is nice and all, but I bet Carl has a big fat one. A working man's cock."
I glanced at her breasts as she stroked my cock. Katelyn was skinny and muscular with little perky tits. I loved them. Her nipples were hard and poking through her dress. Girls with little bitty tits always seemed more sensitive to me. "I bet he's rough. I bet he fucks like an inconsiderate asshole," she said, staring into my eyes. "Do you want to see that sweaty pig grunting all over your little wife, Michael?" I shook my head no. "Well,
I do
." She was stroking faster. "I want him to use me like a whore. Smack me around like a drunken towny. You're a good lover, Michael. You always take care of me. But since you brought this up, I miss getting fucked by someone who doesn't give two shits about me, just uses me to get his rocks off." I was getting close to an orgasm and Katelyn could tell. She stopped stroking and sat back on the sofa. Lifting her skirt, she pointed between her legs. I took my place, lapping and sucking her to several orgasms. Katelyn always appreciated my oral skills.
By the time Friday came, I was out of my mind with horniness. Carl was right on time at 7, I went to the door to let him in. He was wearing tight jeans and a white t-shirt with rolled up sleeves that showcased his muscular biceps.
"Hello, Carl," I said, trying to sound confident. He just nodded. "Would you like a drink?"
"Beer," he said curtly and started strutting around the house. I brought him his beer. Katelyn came down the stairs in a tight-fitting red dress. Katelyn was a petite little thing. She was a gymnast in college and never lost her wiry look. She was about 5'3" tall and slight of build. Long blond curls flowed across her shoulders. Katelyn had long muscular legs and a hard round ass. Her abs were still tight. The dress she wore was short, and sleeveless. She was barefoot with a silver chain on one ankle. Her perfect toes were painted red. The dress, ankles bracelet and wedding ring, other than that, she wore nothing else. She could be naked in a second. For some reason, that made me nervous, even though I knew it was the point. I know it's hypocritical, but when it was something I was eager for, it was one thing. Now I could see that
she was eager for it.
Carl studied her as she descended. I watched them look at each other, and I began to panic inside as I realized what was about to happen. There would be no turning back soon. I did my best to compose myself. I figured I should go over some ground rules.
"Ok, I said," trying to sound in control. "If we're going to do this..."
"Oh, we're going to do this," Carl interrupted rudely, staring at Katelyn like a steak on the grill. Katelyn let out a schoolgirl giggle. My wife was an author, a tenured professor at an elite university. Twelve years of education and 40 plus of culture regressed into a giggling school girl at the thought of a crude fuck.
"Like I was saying. It's important that you know that this is something that my wife and I have agreed to. Any sex only happens when the both of us are present..."
"Except for blow jobs," Carl interjected. Katelyn's face dropped a little when he said this. I glanced at her and she looked away. "Oh, you didn't know about that, did you?" Carl smirked.
"No," I replied. "I did not." Now I was a bit angry. Katelyn had promised that nothing would happen unless the two of us were present and had carefully agreed on everything. This was a bad start; she'd already broken our arrangement. If I couldn't trust her to follow a few simple rules.
"I think you're going to have to leave," I said to Carl. Honestly, I was relieved that a way out had presented itself. This guy was a royal asshole, and the thought of inviting him into our lives was creepy. Besides, he was the janitor where we both worked. We would see him every day.
"I'm not going anywhere," Carl said and walked over to me, standing shoulder to shoulder. I was a thin man, but in decent shape. I had what you'd call a swimmer's build. Carl was a brute, thick hairy body, with big arms. His face was covered in stubble.
"Yeah, your wife sucked my dick, what's the problem, that you didn't get to watch or that it wasn't part of your precious arrangement?". He looked me up and down, sizing me up.
"Here's what I think. You don't
want to be in control
. Guy's like you want to be pushed to the bottom. Only you don't have the guts to admit it to yourself, so you want a real man to make the decision for you. Put you in your place a little. Maybe you feel guilty of all your success. Well, kid, you're in luck. I'm just the man for the job," he said in his arrogant asshole tone. I was beginning to think that was the only tone he had. He grabbed my hand and brought it to his crotch. "Why don't you soothe yourself a little by putting my cock in your mouth."