Many thanks to bythewx for first editing this story.
Grateful thanks to Dowageroftwo, who edited, corrected, questioned and inspired until the story became far better.
*
Roger heard Mary in the next room talking to Alice.
The voices were low, because they thought he was asleep, but he focused, and soon every syllable was clear. It was remarkable how acute his hearing had become since the accident. It was almost as if he had grown new ears to make up for what had been taken from him.
"You are so patient," Alice said. "I could never do what you've been doing."
His wife's response was subdued, different from the upbeat, cheery voice she used when speaking to him.
"Not that it's done a damn bit of good. I did everything Dr. Roth said to do. I've been soothing, tender, encouraging, affectionate, hopeful and always positive. I keep on talking until I have no voice left. It's like talking to a wall."
"Can he even hear you?"
"Dr. Roth tested him, and his hearing is nearly back to normal. He's better every day, and he's less confused now. I can see it in his eyes. Dr. Roth says when he wants pen and paper, it will show he's recovered most of his comprehension. But he hasn't even tried to talk as far as I can tell."
"What does Dr. Roth say about that?"
"He says there's nothing wrong with his vocal cords. He could be talking just like you and me if he wanted to."
"So why doesn't he?"
"The diagnosis is hysterical mutism. It's rare, and it's the first case that Dr. Roth has seen personally. Roger's brain wasn't injured in the accident, but it was so traumatized that something disconnected the desire to talk. He wants to talk. But at the same time, on a deeper level, he never wants to talk again, and that deeper level is in control."
"But he will talk eventually," Alice said.
Roger heard Mary choking back tears.
"We don't know. Dr. Roth said in some cases the hysterical mutism lasts the rest of the patient's life. He was starting to tell me the percentages, but I stopped him and told him that I didn't want to know.
"I told him I would do everything and try anything, and I wouldn't give up until Roger talked again. He said that if there was no progress after a certain point, I would have to change my attitude or it could destroy my life.
"I'm scared, Alice. Each time we go in, Dr. Roth asks what I've been doing and how Roger reacted. I can tell he's not hopeful. If he tells me I have to live with the fact that Roger will never speak again, I think I'll go insane."
"No you won't. Other people have had accidents, and their families learn to deal with it. So will you."
Roger closed his eyes. His concentration on the conversation had tired him, and he soon drifted off to sleep. He had a smile on his face because he was thinking about Mary. He would soon tell her how much he loved her and how he would make it up to her for all the worry and unhappiness she was going through. If the doctor said he could talk, there was nothing that was going to stop him from talking.
*************
"It's so strange talking about Roger with him sitting right here with us," Alice said.
"Dr. Roth said there was no reason for me to keep anything a secret from him," Mary said. "Hearing people talking about him will help him adjust better to the changes coming to our lives.
"I'm pretty sure he now hears everything we're saying. Watch his eyes. You can see him reacting. He's got a long way to go before he's mentally and physically strong enough to take care of himself, but Dr. Roth is sure that eventually he will recover completely, except for his voice."
"You're a lot calmer about it now than you were a few weeks ago."
"Dr. Roth finally convinced me that I wasn't doing anybody any good by acting the martyr. He said I needed to heal as much as Roger did and to start thinking of myself.
"At first, I resisted, but then I tried it, and you know what -- it helped. I feel better now than I've felt since the accident.
"I also finally admitted to myself that I have resentment toward Roger. Dr. Roth says there's no shame in that. Roger can talk, but he won't. Because of that, my life is going to more difficult. I was suppressing those feelings, but now I have empowered myself to think them without feeling guilty.
"You've helped me tremendously by listening to me vent without judging me. You are the best friend anyone could ever have, and I'm so grateful to you. I'm not afraid to tell you of the times when I actually hate Roger for what he's doing to me. I can say things to you that I can't tell the children."
"Remember, it's not his fault," Alice said. "The drunk driver in the other car slammed into his door without warning. There is nothing he could have done."
"I know he's not responsible for the accident, but Roger is no innocent. I found out he's been screwing someone at his office."
"Shut up! Roger would never cheat on you."
"Did you see how he just jumped," Mary said. "He even told me about her. She's a spitfire named Celia."
Roger tried to say, "No, no, Mary, you're wrong," but his lips didn't move.
"He said she had gone after five or six married men at work and had affairs with all of them," Mary continued, "and she had warned him he was next. We laughed about it, and he told me I didn't have anything to worry about because he wasn't attracted to sluts. I believed him, but now I realize that I was in denial. I knew all along he was only telling me to protect himself in case someone mentioned anything about her to me."
"I can't believe it. Do you have any proof?"
"I don't need proof. There are some things you just know."
Mary's words cut into Roger like a knife. All he could think of is that she had been exhausting herself with nursing him and trying every therapy to help him recover his voice. It must have affected her mind. How could she believe that he would ever touch another woman?
"Do you think he was still seeing her when he had the accident?" Alice asked.
"It doesn't matter," Mary said with finality. "He won't see her anymore. Dr. Roth told me one of these days, he's going to be strong enough to have sex again.
"Imagine it. He'll screw like an animal. Maybe he'll grunt. But he'll never tell me that he loves me ever again. I'm realizing just how much I needed to hear his lies."
"I can't believe what you're saying. I've never heard you like this."
"It's hard for me to believe I never said a word to him about his running around. Who knows how many women there were before Celia. All I can think of is that I probably didn't want the children to find out.
"I have to adjust to a future in which Roger won't make a living anymore. We'll be living on our savings and the insurance settlement. It will be enough to be comfortable, but it's the end of our plans to travel after his retirement. Once he can take care of himself, maybe I'll go back to work.
"That's what I've got to look forward to. It's all on me now.
"His silence is deafening. I've been thinking about sneaking out while the nurse was here to find a man who could talk to me while he's making love. Then I thought, why should I? I can invite him over here. Roger isn't strong enough to do anything about it."
"That's sick!" Alice said.
"You think that's bad. I was watching the nurse putting the restraints on Roger that keep him from falling out of his bed at night. It occurred to me that I could leave them on one morning and fuck the guy while he watches."
Roger began shaking.
"Don't say that. Look what you're doing to him."
They both watched him shake for a minute before he calmed down.
"Did you notice that he didn't even try to move his mouth," said Mary. "Maybe he'll shake like that while he watches us."
She laughed a bitter laugh.
"I'll be watching him while I do it. It already gets me hot thinking about how humiliated he'll look. I'll probably have the best orgasms of my life."
"You actually sound serious."
"I'm dead serious. Have you ever had an affair, Alice?"
"I almost did once. I was really angry at Jim. Now I can't even remember what he did that made me so mad. He didn't cheat, but I wanted to get back at him, sort of revenge. Some sales guy at a store started flirting with me, but I stopped before it got serious.
"Do you know any single studs looking for something purely physical?" Mary asked. "No married men. I wouldn't do to their wives what Roger did to me."
Alice laughed.
"You're getting me wet with this kind of talk. I'm going to jump Jim's bones the minute he comes in the door. He won't know what hit him. But he won't complain. I've got to go now. He'll be home in an hour."
"Do you have time to help me get Roger back to bed?"
Roger tried to struggle as they led him to the bedroom, but he suddenly felt tired. After Mary gently tucked him in, he tossed and turned for a while and then fell into an exhausted sleep.
*****************
"I think he's stirring," Alice said.
"Yes," Mary said as she sat down next to the bed and leaned over to look at Roger's face. She was smiling but also twitching nervously.