It started out as a game we played before sex where we told each other our fantasies. We got pretty wild with the stories, because they were, after all, made up.
Then one night I asked her how many men she'd been with before me. "It has to be before you?" she asked playfully.
"Okay, how many have you been with period?" I said with a grin.
"Well, less than a hundred, more than fifty," she said.
"Fifty?" I said with a gasp.
"Well, I was a busy girl back in the day," she said.
"Tell me about some of them," I said. "Tell me about the good ones, the ones you think about now when we're fucking. The ones you would chose to be with again if you could. The memorable ones. The ones with dicks so big you swoon when you think of them?"
"Swoon?" she said. "You think I swoon for some of them?" I said for her just to tell me about some of them, whatever she remembered, whatever she looked back on favorably.
"Tell me about the best fucks you've ever had?" I said snuggling up against her.
"You mean other than you?" she said with a wicked grin. "You don't want to hear about other men in my past," she said. " Why would I do that? You don't want to know that."
I nodded. "Yes, I do," I said. "Really, I'd like to hear about them."
"Well, okay," she said with a look that said "if that's what you want. "Well, there was Monty, who could eat pussy like a world champion. He could suck on a clit for hours and hours and never lose his hard on. He was a college English professor who specialized in Elizabethan and could spout poetry. and eat pussy all night. You sure you want to hear this?" she said. I nodded. "Okay, well, he would send me on blissful trips while I laid on my back with my legs spread all night," she said.
"Any soul brothers in that woodpile?" I asked as I kissed her.
"Two," she said with a grin. "Jacob and Amos," she said wistfully.
"Was one of those the biggest you ever had?" I asked.
"Close," she said, "but no, that would be Andrew. He was a stallion," she said with a wide smile. I asked her to tell me about those two and she grinned, then started telling me how she met them and about her first encounter with each.
I asked how she met them and she said at school. "Jacob was out for track and Amos worked in the cafeteria where I worked. I only saw them at school and went to their rooms. Jacob liked me to get on top and buck and rock and let him lift me from underneath. He was so big I had to be careful I didn't come down to far. Amos loved me to suck his dick and he'd pick me up in his car and I'd blow him as he drove. Sometimes I went to his room and we'd stand just inside the door and I'd suck him against the door so no one could come in.
One night she told me about Monty, the pussy eater, and I stretched out fascinated at her stories about him eating her in some amazing places. He ate her once in the park where she stood by the jungle gym and he knelt below her and ate her pussy as she stood looking out over the park. She said her mother liked Monty and she'd let him come over and while she was at work he'd eat Claire in her room on her bed. "One time he ate me in the kitchen while I looked out the window watching for my mother to come home," she said with a look of nostalgia on her face.
"He sure could eat pussy good," she said with a smile.
I asked her one night to tell me about Andrew, the one who she said was a stallion. "I first saw Andrew when I was fourteen," she said. "He showed it to me in the tack room at the stables. He took it out and I could believe it. I had only seen a few at that time, but his was so big I thought it was fake," she said.
Incredibly, I was fascinated at hearing about her ex-boy friends and sex partners. Some she didn't think of as boy friends, she just thought of them as someone she fucked on occasion.
She told me the best fuck she'd ever had was Matt, and she almost swooned when she told me about him. His dick wasn't especially large, but what he did with it was magnificent. She said they had a place they'd go out by the back bay where there was a lot of trees and he'd fuck her standing up in the trees. She said she'd do just about anything to get him to fuck her, and he liked getting blowjobs so they'd trade one for the other. He'd fuck her and she blow him. She said she like just holding his dick in her hands, and he liked it too so they did that a lot.
She told me the person she liked having sex with the most was her roommate in college, a girl named Carla. She and Carla would get back from dates and they'd lay in bed together and kiss and share about their dates, telling secrets about the guys, then they'd usually go down on each other and she said she always came with Carla, although she rarely came with the guys. I was thrilled that she'd tell me about Carla, as I think it was part of her history that she rarely shared with other people.
Then one night she told me about Jacque. He was the best kisser she'd ever been with. She said she actually came one night during a kiss from Jacque. It was the first and last time she'd ever had an orgasm from a kiss. she said, except for Carla, she'd never had a kiss so soft and tender, so passionate. She still remembered the excitement of kissing with Jacque.
One night as we began to talk, she began to laugh. I asked her what was so funny and she said she was thinking about Anthony. I asked what it was about Anthony that made her laugh. She said he could talk her into anything, and his favorite thing was to have sex in public and he had convinced her many times to risk being discovered, having sex with him in public places. She began to laugh again and said he convinced her to have sex with him on a crowded bus under a blanket. She remembers covering her mouth to keep from calling out as she came with all the people around them.