The next day, Debbie got a text from Claire, "Call me when you have time."
She called her friend later that day.
"Debbie, I want to talk about something. About Saturday--I don't think we should let Anne sit around by herself. Last year she was worse on the anniversary of Sam's death than on their wedding anniversary and I assume it's going to the same this year."
"I'm with you on that. Let's take her out and do something."
"She already said she doesn't want to go out."
"Then what?"
"Well, I want to talk to you about something else." Claire sounded a bit nervous. "Look, we all know Anne's been in the dumps lately, what with her anniversary and all. But, yesterday, she was excited and laughing. She had a good time."
"Yeah, I noticed that, too. The party was a good idea."
"Yeah, well...the thing is, after you told us about The Game, that good mood kept going until I left. That was hours..."
"And...," Debbie didn't like the sound of where this was going.
Claire finished in a rush. "Well, I want you continue the story, tell her one of your fantasies. Keep her interested. Wait! Wait!" Claire interrupted as Debbie started to respond. "Listen! I know what you're going to say. Just listen a second!
"Deb, I haven't seen her like this in a long time. She couldn't stop talking about what you told us. She was laughing, chattering away, getting us to speculate on what you guys maybe did. It was almost like Anne before Sam died. Ask Mary if you don't believe me."
"I believe you, Claire. But...those are really personal things. I know we've talked about sex before, but this is a bit beyond 'So, I slept with him' kind of thing. I'd be too uncomfortable to talk about them."
Claire's voice turned serious. "I know. Really, I do. I'm not trying to manipulate you..."
"Yeah, right!" Debbie snorted.
"No really. But, she still hurts and Saturday is going to remind her how much it all sucks. This is the only thing I can think of."
"Yeah, I know it is. But...I don't know, Claire. It's just...," Debbie didn't know how to finish the sentence.
"Beyond embarrassing?" asked Claire.
"To say the least!"
Claire sighed.
"Why don't you tell a story about your sex life instead, Claire?" asked Debbie.
"Honestly, Debbie?"
"Sure."
"Well, Bill and I have never done anything as hot as what you started to describe. Not even close. That's why."
"How do you know? I didn't describe anything."
"Deb, are you kidding me? Don't you realize how unbelievably sexy just making a game of fantasies is? That alone makes your story incredibly hot. Bill and I have never really done much of anything beyond what any college kid does."
"You haven't?"
"He's tied me up on the bed once. That's it. We have good sex, Deb, but it's kind of vanilla beyond a little groping in a movie theater and me going braless once in a while to tease him."
"So tell her about being tied up."
"It's not the same. I was embarrassed and then that made him embarrassed and it didn't go much farther than a little teasing and...umm...oral, you know. It would be hard to make much of a sexy story around it. You've already started and her imagination is already going. There's nothing I've got to match that."
"Claire! This isn't fair!"
"I understand. But...think about it, Deb. Just the four us; no one else needs to know. Or just with Anne if you don't want Mary and me there. That's fine. Really. This isn't about me trying to worm a story out of you."
"Uhhh..."
"Please? Think about it?"
...
"John?"
"Yes, hon?" he said absently.
"How would you feel if I told the girls about one of my fantasy days?"
"Whoa! I guess I mind," he replied. "You want to tell me what you're talking about?"
"Okay, so you know what we did at Girls Night yesterday...the Fuckerware party, right?"
John nodded, smiling.
"Well, I kind of slipped and made a comment about one of the toys being useful, and Claire pounced all over it."
"And what did you say?" asked John.
"Well, she kept after me and finally I just told them about The Game. Not what we actually did, just that it existed and the rules for it."
"I see," he said slowly.
"Are you mad?" she asked.
"Well, not mad, exactly. Maybe a bit irritated that you didn't talk it over with me first," he responded.
"Hon, I know. I kind of just choked and got flustered. Then, I figured I might as well just tell them the truth rather than let them imagine whatever they wanted." She grimaced, "Can you forgive me?"
"You just told them the rules, not what we actually do?"
"Yes. They asked, of course, but I clammed up."
"But now you want to tell them more? Why?"
So, Debbie told him about her conversation with Claire, about Anne's reactions, about the three of them getting together with Anne to cheer her up this weekend. "So, I said no, at first. But Claire kept pointing out that we don't have a better idea for how to keep her from going into a funk. So, I thought maybe if I told about some of the tamer times..."
John was silent for a long time, thinking.
"Which ones?"
"I was thinking maybe my second one or that time at the Fremont Hotel, or maybe your first one."
"None of mine!" his response was sharp.
"Okay...no problem! Ummm, can you tell me why?" she asked.
"Those are my fantasies, Debbie. I'm just not comfortable having you tell others about things I feel or think about." He sat for a moment. "Look, I'm sorry I snapped...but, it was awkward for me to talk about them with you...I'm really not comfortable having people outside the marriage know about them."
"That's fine, John. I understand. Does this mean you're okay with me talking about some of mine."
"I'm thinking about it. There are some of yours I wouldn't want talked about."
"Which ones? I wouldn't talk about anything you didn't want me to."
"Well, obviously not the February one."
"Yeah, I never considered that one."
"I don't know, Debbie, this sounds a little embarrassing but, on the other hand, I understand where you coming from about wanting to help Anne." He paused for a while. "I have to think about this a bit."
...
John ran into Anne at the grocery store the next day. He waved, "Hi, Anne."
She walked over. "Hey, lover boy!" she grinned at him.
"What?" he said, knowing perfectly well what was coming.
She laughed, "Oh, don't give me that innocent look. That was certainly an eye-opener that Debbie hit us with. Of course, we couldn't get her to spill the REALLY juicy stuff...but our imaginations are certainly filling in the blanks!" she teased.
John flushed a little, "You think The Game is weird?"
"Oh my God, no! I think it's sexy as hell; I bet everyone did whether they admit it or not. Half of them are probably wishing they had the nerve to suggest the same thing to their husband. No, she made our evening."
John smiled, "Well, I'm glad you were entertained."
"Best night in a long while."
...
"Okay, Debbie, go ahead. But just the ones we talked about."