When I first asked her to tell me about her fantasies, or her past sexual experiences she simply refused, wasn't interested, and resisted my prodding, but she was curious about hearing mine and I carefully told her about a few. I tried to be sensible about what I told her, being careful to stay away from people she may have known or had ideas about. She didn't seem to mind hearing those fantasies and past experiences, and-- although she said it didn't turn her on--but our sex that night was heated and fantastic.
I told her about a friend asking me once to sleep with his wife, and I went into detail about what actually happened, how I refused unless he explained it to her, got her okay, and let her be apart of the idea. I left out very little and she was curious and seemed to be intrigued as I told her the story and our sex was again very intense afterwards that night. She wanted to know all about the people involved, how he asked, what he actually said, and exactly what occurred. She wanted to know why a man would ask another man to do that, and all I could say was that it was pretty common.
That's when she asked if I ever fantasized about that and I admitted that I had. "You actually fantasize about me fucking someone else?" she asked. Being as honest as I could be without risking it blowing up in my face, I told her about my fantasies involving her and other men. How I pictured it, daydreaming about what would actually happen. She wanted to know everything about it: what kind of a man I would imagine her with, what would they do, how would it play out, what I saw her doing with this imaginary lover, how big his cock was, and just how I envisioned her reacting to my setting her up with someone else?
"Do you imagine me being fucked by this imaginary guy?" she asked. "You actually get turned on by thinking of his screwing me, putting his cock in me and maybe eating my pussy?" she wanted to know. "Do you ever fantasize about me giving him oral?" I was honest with her, telling her yes, that I really did get quite sexually aroused by the fantasy. "Well, do I like it, in your fantasy?"
"Yes," I said. "I imagine you really liking being fucked by a handsome man who fucks you silly, who eats your pussy expertly, and who does things to you that you have only dreamed about in the privacy of your own mind. I guess I think you'd like it in real life." She looked at me incredulously and I went on. "What woman would not like to have a good looking, virile man want to fuck her? You don't think you would?"
"Well, I am a married woman," she said. "I don't just lust after every man I see."
"And you don't think you'd get some pleasure from knowing a desirable man wants to fuck your body? You don't think you'd be turned on by that? You never fantasize about being fucked in a wild, no-holds-barred sexual encounter?"
"I wouldn't want you to be fucked by some other beautiful woman," she said. "Or even have one attempt to seduce you. I would scratch her eyes out," she said.
"Well, don't you ever, while we are having sex, think about someone else you've fucked and liked it. Haven't you ever done that, even once?" I asked.
After turning a shade or two of pink, she nodded, and acknowledged that she had, on occasion thought about some experience she'd had with someone else. "Okay, so who?" I asked trying to tickle her and make light of it. "Who do you think of when we are fucking that you liked having sex with?" I prodded.
She thought about it for a few minutes, then got a thoughtful look on her face. "Well, once I thought about Jeff when we were, you know...."
"So you liked fucking Jeff?" I asked, trying to make light of it.
It took her a long time to answer, but she finally nodded and said she did. "So, was he bigger than average?" I asked. After a minute she nodded, then smiled broadly. She said he was and admitted she had really got turned on having sex with him. "So you've thought about him on occasion?" She nodded and admitted she had. "What if you could have sex with him again?" I asked. "Would you still like it?"
She shook her head, said she was a married woman, and she would never consider doing that. "But what if I said it was okay?" I said.
Finally she began to smile again. "Seriously?" she asked. "You would do that?"
I told her that I did not want to keep her from something she genuinely wanted to do. "I don't want you resenting me because you feel I keep you from doing things you want." I went on to explain that I did not own her, that if I loved her I would have to be able to accept her needs, even if realizing those needs meant letting go and giving her the chance to do something she longed for.
"What if I could help make your fantasy a reality?" I said. "What if I was okay with you enjoying another man's cock inside of you?" She just sat and thought about what I had said.
"And you would have no problem with me doing that?" she asked, studying my face after her question.
"So it is a possibility?" I said. "I'm sure you have thought about it, almost everyone does. So if I were to give you a 'free pass' to do whatever you have dreamed of doing with someone, would you consider that?" Almost imperceptibly,I saw her nod. "Who would it be?": I asked.
"Jake," she whispered.
"So we'll find a way to get Jake and you together again," I said. "Does he live close?"
"In Omaha," she said. "He works at a school there."